Don't let the fairly plain exterior of this theatre fool you, the interior is one of the more lavishly decorated theatres on Broadway. Book of Mormon is a fantastic show and this beautiful theatre helps provide a great setting for it! The seats are VERY close together, I am 6' 2" and I was a bit crunch where I was, fortunately my seat was against a staircase wall so I could sit diagonally otherwise I would have been uncomfortable. It is of course an old theatre and this is to be expected. The staff are very friendly and had me in my seat very quickly. Mezzanine seats have very good views of the stage and I was very impressed with how good my view was for how cheap my ticket was.

Came here as many others did to see The Book of Mormon which was even more incredible than imagined. But this review is for the theater, not the show. The theater was great, seating was done in a timely manner, and even though the line to get in stretched around the block, it was a quick process and by having guides stationed along the street it was nice to have the bag security checks done before getting to the door. The theater itself is beautiful, even if the seating is narrow and those of us who are on the wider side may feel tight. Didn’t ruin the event whatsoever.

Excellent theater. Our view from the mezzanine was excellent. Only downfall is there no elevator. To get to mezzanine, you had to climb 2 flights of stairs.

I recently had the pleasure of watching the Book of Mormon, and I must say, it was a truly entertaining and humorous experience. The show's clever writing and wit had me laughing throughout. However, it is important to note that the production does contain vulgar language and explicit content, so it may not be suitable for all audiences. The actors' performances were outstanding, showcasing their talent and dedication to their roles. Their delivery of the comedic elements was impeccable, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to the overall experience. The theater itself has a charming vintage feel, which adds to the ambiance of the show. However, it is worth mentioning that the seating arrangement may not be the most comfortable. The seats are quite small, and the armrests are positioned in a somewhat awkward manner. Despite these minor drawbacks, the Book of Mormon is a must-see for those who appreciate sharp humor and exceptional acting. Just be prepared for some explicit language and ensure that you are comfortable with the content before attending.

Saw the Book of Mormon this after noon, the theater is gorgeous and the show was spectacular. The reason for the 4 stars instead of 5 is the woman who was in charge of mezzanine rear left and the seats were on the small side. That woman was miserable and barking orders at everyone around rather than just just asking nicely if things weren’t done to protocol. She needs a lesson in customer service. All the other employees were super nice and accommodating. Unless u r smaller than 5’5 and weigh less than 150, u might find it kinda of tight. Theater and show were amazing!

The building is old, but has its own vibe. Everyone is super welcoming and nice. Went there to see The a Book of Mormon and it was great! Tickets are pricy, but hey, it's Broadway. Definitely recommend

We greatly enjoyed seeing Book of Mormon at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre. Older theater and has so much charm and the staff was so amazing!

This theatre was great! We were initially worried we wouldn’t have a good view when we bought Book of Mormon tickets last minute, but were pleasantly surprised that even the far left back mezzanine seats (row K) had a great view! We could see everything happening on stage and the music and singing was crisp and loud. Highly recommend!