Top rated Italian restaurants in Barrie

Experience the best that Barrie has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 20 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Top rated  
Most reviewed  
Hidden gems  
Worst rated  
Recently discovered  

Search radius


Licious Italian Food and Catering image
Licious Italian Food and Catering
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ I can tell you off hand that you will not be disappointed once you have tried this location's food. Everything is freshly made and really delicious. Long before Francesco have opened his cafe, I have personally ordered from him and he delivered the food. The lasagnas are amazing. Not only you're gon...
4.90 (97 reviews)
Il Buco image
Il Buco
Italian restaurant
Polished venue offering traditional Italian fare, including pasta, veal & seafood, plus lake views.
$$$ $
4.70 (1.1K reviews)
Bacio Trattoria image
Bacio Trattoria
๐Ÿ‘ Great place to dine. Service was great and food was really good. Head chef and owner says Hi ๐Ÿ‘‹ when he has a minute. We had Pizza Fettachini Pasta and Chicken al Pesto. ๐Ÿ˜‹ music is awesome and fits the vibe. The only think I would change is the lighting...was not able to take good photos because...
4.70 (334 reviews)
Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace image
Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace
Pizza restaurant
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ Fantastic pizza! have had it twice this week and so glad we found this place. Weโ€™ve moved here from Vaughan and have been looking for a pizza spot, Paezanoโ€™s will definitely be our go to. Itโ€™s very light, airy, and flavourful, canโ€™t have enough with how easy it is to eat.
$ $$$
4.60 (592 reviews)
Mondos The Original Mondos Restaurant & Deli image
Mondos The Original Mondos Restaurant & Deli
Italian restaurant
๐Ÿซค Best pizza in town hands down, however multiple times Iโ€™ve driven out of my way to find a locked door or closed sign, unfortunate they cannot keep regular hours
$ $$$
4.60 (163 reviews)
Fuda Italian Bakery image
Fuda Italian Bakery
Family-owned since 1957, this standby offers baked goods, Italian groceries & prepared entrees.
$$ $$
4.50 (1.2K reviews)
147 Ristorante image
147 Ristorante
Italian restaurant
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ Me being Italian has nothing to do with this review the staff and the team at 147 are absolutely phenomenal. From the minute we walked in which we did come a little early they still seated us to the moment we walked out absolutely five star service The food is incredible we had a mix of things and...
4.50 (607 reviews)
Casano's Italian Restaurant and Catering image
Casano's Italian Restaurant and Catering
Italian restaurant
๐Ÿซค I had been to Casano's many years ago when it was run by the husband and wife. The food was delicious and fresh made pasta, the veal was tender and flavourful. I went there recently and was very disappointed. The veal sandwich was not good at all chewy ,tough and no flavour, the coating cameoff afte...
$ $$$
4.50 (71 reviews)
Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta image
Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta
Pizza restaurant
Unpretentious eatery offering a full range of familiar Italian favourites for eat-in or takeout.
$$ $$
4.40 (619 reviews)
Dino's 2 For 1 Pizza image
Dino's 2 For 1 Pizza
Pizza restaurant
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ Iโ€™ve tried a lot of pizzas! Although, this afternoon I had received pizza from โ€˜Dinoโ€™s 2 for 1 pizzaโ€™ ,Nice small family business, In Barrie, ON. The owner is super friendly and the pizza is amazing as well. My kids love their pizzas which is a huge compliment! Best,
$ $$$
4.40 (410 reviews)
Zio's Italian Comfort Food image
Zio's Italian Comfort Food
Italian restaurant
A menu with an array of small & shared Italian-inspired dishes in a relaxed space with green walls.
$$ $$
4.40 (403 reviews)
Reginos Pizza image
Reginos Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Tiny, no-frills outpost of a local chain dishing up wings & whole wheat, thick- & thin-crust pizzas.
$ $$$
4.40 (362 reviews)
Casa Mia Barrie image
Casa Mia Barrie
Greek restaurant
Warm, spacious fixture providing traditional Greek & Italian cuisine in a low-lit setting.
$$ $$
4.30 (952 reviews)
Limoncello Bistro image
Limoncello Bistro
Italian restaurant
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ I celebrated my birthday here at Limoncello Bistro in July and was craving more! Made reservations to come in tonight (Friday Aug 26) and Allison greeted us with a warm smile and welcomed us to have a seat. I had heard great things about the Eggplant Parmesan Tower and so I ordered it with a house s...
4.30 (456 reviews)
California Sandwiches Barrie image
California Sandwiches Barrie
Italian restaurant
4.30 (418 reviews)
The Italian Eatery image
The Italian Eatery
Italian restaurant
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ Best Marinara sauce! Super casual atmosphere and very delicious, authentic Italian food experience. Very reasonably priced foods. Order from the counter, and sit down. Food will be brought out to you. Consider leaving a tip as the food will be served and you are cleaned up after. We enjoyed the Ca...
$ $$$
4.20 (705 reviews)
Pizza Nova image
Pizza Nova
Pizza restaurant
Relaxed chain restaurant for signature & build-your-own pizzas, plus sandwiches & salads.
$ $$$
4.20 (586 reviews)
Pizzeria Italia Restaurant image
Pizzeria Italia Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Family-owned institution serving traditional pies & housemade pasta in an old-fashioned dining room.
$$ $$
4.20 (248 reviews)
Topper's Pizza, Barrie-Bayfield image
Topper's Pizza, Barrie-Bayfield
Pizza restaurant
Regional counter-serve chain dishing up gourmet pies, wings & calzonelike Topperottis.
$$ $$
4.00 (219 reviews)
Topper's Pizza - Barrie Bryne Drive image
Topper's Pizza - Barrie Bryne Drive
Pizza restaurant
Regional counter-serve chain dishing up gourmet pies, wings & calzonelike Topperottis.
$$ $$
4.00 (157 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps


Last updated:
( )