Top rated Italian restaurants in St. Catharines

Experience the best that St. Catharines has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 24 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories



Mele Trattoria image
1
Mele Trattoria
Restaurant
👍👍 My mom and I went here for dinner, unexpectedly, as we are from out of town and will definitely make our way into St. Catharines just for dinner here again. Everything was so delicious and the service was great. Congrats to the Chef :)
$$ $$
4.80 (120 reviews)
Valley image
2
Valley
Italian restaurant
👍👍 When seated, you’re started off with a complimentary focaccia bread drizzled in balsamic and olive oil. We ordered the fried provolone to start which was delicious. I definitely recommend the house lasagne as the portion is large, it tastes absolutely fantastic and for $20 you will not find somethin...
$$ $$
4.70 (810 reviews)
Coppola's Ristorante & Banquet Facility image
3
Coppola's Ristorante & Banquet Facility
Italian restaurant
Familiar Italian fare, including pasta dishes & family-style meals, served in casual surrounds.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.4K reviews)
Paesano Pizza image
4
Paesano Pizza
Pizza takeaway
👍👍 Ordered panzerotti from the Carlton location and amazing. We were driving back from Niagara Falls and wanted panzerotti. We didn't know how big they would be so we ordered 2 small and 1 large. OMG! Delicious. Will def6order from here again.
$ $$$
4.60 (475 reviews)
Cafe Amore image
5
Cafe Amore
Mediterranean restaurant
Relaxed, family-run kitchen in a strip mall since 1995 with wood-fired pizza & Mediterranean dishes.
$$ $$
4.50 (1K reviews)
Antipastos image
6
Antipastos
Caterer
👍👍 We just moved to the area, and were hoping to find an Italian/Mediterranean grocery to frequent, and boy were we lucky. This place is amazing, great selection of frozen and ready to go meals. We had the meat lasagna, and were very pleased. We’ve also tried their house pasta sauce, and it was excel...
$$ $$
4.50 (786 reviews)
Cafe Garibaldi Ristorante image
7
Cafe Garibaldi Ristorante
Italian restaurant
👍👍 First time customer last night. The ambiance was very nice. The food was very good. There was 7 of us for dinner and everyone thoroughly enjoyed their meals. Overall, the food was fantastic and the price was reasonable for the portion size. (large portions) We will be back soon.
4.50 (40 reviews)
Lina Linguini's Pasta & Grille image
8
Lina Linguini's Pasta & Grille
Italian restaurant
Established eatery serving Italian tapas along with pasta & classic entrees in a relaxed atmosphere.
$$ $$
4.40 (1.2K reviews)
The Twisted Pig | Italian Kitchen image
9
The Twisted Pig | Italian Kitchen
Italian restaurant
👍 Really friendly staff. Great location. Incredible pizza..... Meh pasta.... Burger was great! Stopped in here on a Saturday evening after a few hours in the park. The place was heaving.... A great sign! The staff were really friendly and took our number and called about 20 mins later saying a table...
$$ $$
4.40 (716 reviews)
IL FORNELLO St Catharines image
10
IL FORNELLO St Catharines
Italian restaurant
👍👍 I’ve been here a few times and each time this place was an absolute delight!! As a vegetarian, I’m always on the lookout for restaurants that offer flavorful and creative meat-free options, and this place certainly did not disappoint. The ambiance is lovely and inviting, warm lighting and cosy seat...
4.40 (324 reviews)
Valentino's image
11
Valentino's
Deli
👍👍 The BEST place to come to Niagara, I have a sensitive stomach I can’t eat a lot of pasta or bread from other restaurants as it’s full of salts and fats, I saw this open near my house and decided to give it a try! It is fantastic fully fresh ingredients and made hot! Amazing prices along with portion...
4.40 (166 reviews)
Stromboli's Pizza Ltd image
12
Stromboli's Pizza Ltd
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Finally what I would I refer to as incredible pizza in St Catharines. Great tasting cheese, delicious sauce. Fresh tasty toppings. The wings are mouth watering with just the right amount of sauce. Worth a few extra dollars to get a quality meal. They are my go to place from now on!
$$ $$
4.40 (100 reviews)
Johnny Rocco's Italian Grill image
13
Johnny Rocco's Italian Grill
Restaurant
Sophisticated outpost featuring upmarket Italian cuisine & fine wines in a modern, brick interior.
$$ $$
4.30 (2.3K reviews)
Fresco's Euro Grille image
14
Fresco's Euro Grille
Italian restaurant
Casual eatery serving Italian, Middle Eastern & bar eats including pasta, falafel & burgers.
$$ $$
4.30 (715 reviews)
Super 2 For 1 Pizza image
15
Super 2 For 1 Pizza
Pizza restaurant
🫤 Pizza was a six out of ten. Very dry dough with not enough sauce. Wings were a two out of ten.My wings were absolutely drenched in sauce; so much sauce that it overflowed the container they were in and leaked everywhere. It made a huge mess on my desk.
$ $$$
4.30 (265 reviews)
La Terrazza Bar & Bistro image
16
La Terrazza Bar & Bistro
Restaurant
👍 Excited to have our wedding here next fall and the food did not disappoint. Even though the service lacked somewhat due to them being short staffed, they were super accommodating and very friendly. Great experience overall and the food speaks for itself. Authentic and tasty Italian food and amazing...
4.30 (53 reviews)
Fat Cat's Pizza Inc. image
17
Fat Cat's Pizza Inc.
Pizza restaurant
😠 I appreciate you not cutting a single slice. or even an attempt at cutting the pizza aswell as charging me for extra toppings you definitely didnt put on. way to go assclowns..Oh yeah i guess nobody checks what they're doing right? I did try to call the store. Im not about to drive another 30m each...
$ $$$
4.20 (531 reviews)
Big Marco's Italian Restaurant image
18
Big Marco's Italian Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Long-time family-owned pizzeria offering classic pies & Italian dishes in a down-to-earth setting.
$$ $$
4.20 (407 reviews)
Fabio's Pizza image
19
Fabio's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Standard pies, hot wings & sub sandwiches round out the menu at this bare-bones, tiny counter serve.
$$ $$
4.20 (372 reviews)
Pizza House image
20
Pizza House
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 One of my favourite pizza places around here! When you order extra cheese they don’t skimp! The layer of cheese is almost thicker than the crust. Sooo good!
4.20 (199 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories


Last updated:
( )