2
Red Swan Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😐 One bite everybody knows the rules. This pizza is a 6.8. Decent undercarriage but the sauce has a weird tang that doesn’t go well with the pizza. Almost taste like honey garlic. Guy was confused when I ordered a cheese pizza, half pepperoni and he wanted to “make it his way” because he never heard o...
$ $$$
4.70 (328 reviews)
3
Paesano Pizza
Pizza takeaway
👍👍 Ordered panzerotti from the Carlton location and amazing. We were driving back from Niagara Falls and wanted panzerotti. We didn't know how big they would be so we ordered 2 small and 1 large. OMG! Delicious. Will def6order from here again.
$ $$$
4.60 (475 reviews)
4
oddBar.
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 First time customer, but definitely not the last. This place came suggested by people in a Facebook group, and they were right. Everything about this pizza is a work of art. The crust is crispy and full of flavor, the sauce was full bodied, and all the ingredients tasted really fresh. The most i...
4.60 (320 reviews)
5
Big brothers gourmet pizza
Pizza delivery
👍👍 I've come here to grab a slice on several occasions. There is always a freshly made pizza waiting, and many flavours to choose from. Their slices are huge, the toppings are fresh and the pizza is definitely delicious. The owner provides friendly and courteous service.
4.60 (113 reviews)
6
Cafe Amore
Mediterranean restaurant
Relaxed, family-run kitchen in a strip mall since 1995 with wood-fired pizza & Mediterranean dishes.
$$ $$
4.50 (1K reviews)
7
Fabio's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😠 Ordered a large pizza and it costed $51 plus delivery, are you kidding me? Thats insane high priced. R.I.P OFF Thank god I canceled it, who will pay $51 for 1 large pizza? Not me thats for sure. DONT ORDER FROM FABIOS PIZZA EVERYONE
4.50 (306 reviews)
8
Pie Guys Tap And Grill
Pizza restaurant
😠 Pie Guys Bar and Grill on MacTurnbull drive completely dropped the ball today on their customer service. I placed an order for a pizza at 6:15pm today was told an hour delivery time, I get it Friday nights are busy not a big deal. 7:45pm rolls around and we still don’t have our pizza, I call back an...
$$ $$
4.40 (748 reviews)
9
Red Swan Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😠 I’m appalled at their lack of basic customer service skills. We ordered a pizza for delivery and received this mess (look at the photo) so we called and brought up the issue in a polite manner simply looking for a simple solution to an unfortunate issue….. our pizza looked like it was kicked around...
$ $$$
4.40 (472 reviews)
10
Maestro's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Best quality that worth the price👌 + very friendly customer service. As I have some food restriction owner made sure to deliver delicious pizza with my special needs. I am so happy to find this place 🤗
$$ $$
4.40 (364 reviews)
11
IL FORNELLO St Catharines
Italian restaurant
👍👍 I’ve been here a few times and each time this place was an absolute delight!! As a vegetarian, I’m always on the lookout for restaurants that offer flavorful and creative meat-free options, and this place certainly did not disappoint.
The ambiance is lovely and inviting, warm lighting and cosy seat...
4.40 (324 reviews)
12
St. Catharines Pizza Company
Restaurant
🫤 With all the pizza joints in St. Catharines to choose from, you have to wonder why these guys are still around …. Until you realize that they have a captive audience with a couple of schools nearby.
I had the pizza and wings combo, which was well-priced but sub-par in quality. Wings very dry due to...
4.40 (210 reviews)
13
Stromboli's Pizza Ltd
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Finally what I would I refer to as incredible pizza in St Catharines. Great tasting cheese, delicious sauce. Fresh tasty toppings. The wings are mouth watering with just the right amount of sauce. Worth a few extra dollars to get a quality meal. They are my go to place from now on!
$$ $$
4.40 (100 reviews)
14
Pizzajerrys/Pete's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
🫤 I ordered a pizza and 2lb wing combo . My pizza was supposed to be half pineapple and this is what I got, you could literally count the amount of pineapples pieces on it . The wing looked very pale,not flavored and not appetizing at all!! No one ate the wings . While the pizza did not taste bad (...
$ $$$
4.30 (283 reviews)
15
Fat Louie's Pizzeria & Bar
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 When Anthony bought this place he tore it down to the bare studs. Everything in this place is brand new, including the kitchen. I can see that great efforts were made to make the bar look as clean and modern as it does.
Everytime I walk in I am instantly welcomed. My wife and I love coming in fo...
4.30 (273 reviews)
16
Super 2 For 1 Pizza
Pizza restaurant
🫤 Pizza was a six out of ten. Very dry dough with not enough sauce. Wings were a two out of ten.My wings were absolutely drenched in sauce; so much sauce that it overflowed the container they were in and leaked everywhere. It made a huge mess on my desk.
$ $$$
4.30 (265 reviews)
17
Bella Noella's
Pizza restaurant
😠 Truly disappointed with my Margherita pizza. The tomato sauce to dough ratio was way off. It was like chewing dough with a hint of pizza flavour. Much better options out there especially for the price. With two sauce’s and a tip it was $30+ out the door. Won’t be back.
$ $$$
4.30 (256 reviews)
18
Westside Pizzeria/Bar
Pizza restaurant
🫤 So I was coming home from work and my mom let me know she ordered west side pizza. I was excited to get home and eat from my favourite pizza place since I was super hungry after a long shift. West side pizza has never disappointed me and I’ve always enjoyed the pizza from there until today… I come h...
$ $$$
4.30 (142 reviews)
19
Boston Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Tonight, on a whim- my friend and I wanted to grab some dinner. I had my puppy with me, and needed a patio that was dog friendly. We were sat in the most thoughtful spot with lots of space for the puppers. They offered us blankets since there were no heaters.. which was a lovely touch. Our server wa...
$$ $$
4.20 (1K reviews)
20
Fat Cat's Pizza Inc.
Pizza restaurant
😠 I appreciate you not cutting a single slice. or even an attempt at cutting the pizza aswell as charging me for extra toppings you definitely didnt put on. way to go assclowns..Oh yeah i guess nobody checks what they're doing right? I did try to call the store. Im not about to drive another 30m each...
$ $$$
4.20 (531 reviews)