Top rated Italian restaurants in Cartagena

Experience the best that Cartagena has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 25 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories



Norma Restaurante image
1
Norma Restaurante
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Oh my God! I see why this place has such a high rating. I am glad my American Express concierge recommended this to me. The atmosphere is out of this world. My server, Victoria, gave me amazing service with excellent recommendations for the best appetizers and entrees. If you are rising to the Cernt...
4.80 (112 reviews)
LA RUMBA Lounge Bar image
2
LA RUMBA Lounge Bar
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Fantastic place in Calle Larga Cartagena between bridge to Manga and Convention Center just over from Plaza Trinidad. Look for the giant Italian flag. I was impressed with the ambiance the food the fair prices. The service is excellent and friendly. It is a bar also with delicious cocktails but m...
$$ $$
4.70 (300 reviews)
Di Silvio Trattoria image
3
Di Silvio Trattoria
Italian restaurant
Airy, rustic wood-hewn eatery offering Italian plates from pasta to pizza plus wine & cocktails.
$$ $$
4.60 (5K reviews)
Basilica Pizzería Café image
4
Basilica Pizzería Café
Pizza restaurant
😠 Beware of the staff here. Our waiter tried to demand a tip after we paid with a credit card. He tried to crumple up the receipt after I asked to see it to confirm the service charge was already included. Message to the owner: You should fire staff that tries to cheat and take advantage of your custo...
$$ $$
4.60 (1.9K reviews)
Da Pietro - Restaurante Italiano & Pizzería image
5
Da Pietro - Restaurante Italiano & Pizzería
Restaurant
👍👍 Great place. We got the steak carpaccio de Carne, margarita pizza, Lomo Fino pizza, chicken lasagna & drinks. Everything was amazing. The crust on the pizza was cooked perfectly. The chicken lasagna was season so well. Overall amazing experience.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.3K reviews)
Di Silvio Trattoria image
6
Di Silvio Trattoria
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Beautiful place, great service. The pizza is delicious and have delivery. Beautiful Italian place at Cartagena.
4.60 (1.3K reviews)
Pizzas La Vera image
7
Pizzas La Vera
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Good place!
$$ $$
4.60 (858 reviews)
La Girolata image
8
La Girolata
Italian restaurant
👍👍 We always love dining at La Girolata when we visit Cartagena. It’s a very romantic place to enjoy one of a kind food. The service is beyond amazing and the restaurant itself is beautiful. You’ll always be greeted by the chef himself and he makes you feel right at home. Highly recommend this restaura...
4.60 (740 reviews)
Trattoria donde Wippy (Cartagena) image
9
Trattoria donde Wippy (Cartagena)
Italian restaurant
👍👍 We live in Cartagena part time and this is one of our absolute “go to” restaurants! We have never had a bad meal nor bad service. And frankly the pasta dishes are as good as many restaurants we’ve been to in Italy. Even the drinks are spot on. Love, love, love this place. (Ordered pasta Bolonese and...
$$ $$
4.60 (529 reviews)
Di Silvio Trattoria image
10
Di Silvio Trattoria
Italian restaurant
$$ $$
4.50 (1.6K reviews)
Pizzeria Aguanile image
11
Pizzeria Aguanile
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This place was very accommodating. I speak very little Spanish and they were able to help me order exactly what I wanted. The pizza was great, thin crispy crust with great flavor. I was able to pay in person with a card and had them deliver this to my hotel 20 minutes later.
$$ $$
4.50 (1.3K reviews)
Italiatto Pizza & Pastas image
12
Italiatto Pizza & Pastas
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Upon arrival a handsome guy appeared welcoming to the restaurant, apparently this guy should me part of the management team Always smiling took my order personally identified him self as Mr Albes Anillo and began a friendly chat while explained assorted dishes available with the ingredients He sugge...
$$ $$
4.50 (670 reviews)
La Fontana Trattoria & Wine Bar image
13
La Fontana Trattoria & Wine Bar
Italian restaurant
👍👍 ✨✨✨✨✨ We stumbled on this place and we're so happy we did. The service was excellent. Very full service... The food was super yummy. We had the following: Limonada = both Mango and cherry🍒. They were made frozen which we loved so they could melt and stay cold in the heat. We shared a ceasar sa...
4.50 (471 reviews)
Semolina-cartagena image
14
Semolina-cartagena
Restaurant
👍 Italian restaurant, extensive menu Good care, excellent anti-COVID protocol Delicious dishes in flavor and strong in presentation Rich dessert Beers at a good temperature, rich natural juices
4.50 (416 reviews)
Ristorante Italiano Dolce e Salato image
15
Ristorante Italiano Dolce e Salato
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Dolce E Salato is THE BEST ITALIAN RESTAURANT in Cartagena! I am Greek with Italian from my Father’s side. I LOVE good quality Italian food. I have searched all over Cartagena for good Pizza… Every pizza I eat in Cartagena is TERRIBLE… I also search all Cartagena for good Italian food. Every res...
$$ $$
4.50 (369 reviews)
Casa Della Pasta Don Ignazio image
16
Casa Della Pasta Don Ignazio
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Such a great experience! Get their fettuccine if possible it’s made fresh in house
4.50 (233 reviews)
La Santa image
17
La Santa
Restaurant
😠 What a disgusting restaurant, horrible service and also; MORE THAN 45 MINUTES OF WAITING FOR A SIMPLE PIZZA. The people next door arrived and gave them the pizza in 20 minutes, and the argument they gave didn't even match, they had said that the waitress was not paying attention to the service, when...
$$ $$
4.50 (223 reviews)
Restaurante Pizzería Napolitana image
18
Restaurante Pizzería Napolitana
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Delicious pizza 😋 I always recommend it Very economical
4.50 (197 reviews)
Pasticceria Dolce e Salato image
19
Pasticceria Dolce e Salato
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Das ist wirklich lecker lecker lecker. Alles was süss ist hat ne tolle Qualität. Kaffee ist ebenfalls top. Aber auch die belegten Baguettes sind absolut frisch leckere und eine Gaumenfreude. Wir waren in 2 wochen 4 mal da und wirklich absolut nichts zum aussetzen. Preise etwas gehoben für Cartagena...
4.50 (33 reviews)
il forno CC. Mallplaza El Castillo | Cartagena image
20
il forno CC. Mallplaza El Castillo | Cartagena
Italian restaurant
😠 Terrible, I asked for a chicken teriyaki salad and lettuce was not fresh, the once in the bottom were all black , also the pizza was so hard and difficult to bite, it had too much tomato sauce and tasted bitter.it wasn't good. I asked for delivery and it took 20 minutes more to arrived and the pizza...
$$ $$
4.40 (710 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories


Last updated:
( )