Hidden gems: Hotels in Key West

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Key West. This list contains 9 places from Hotel category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages image
1
Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages
Hotel
Circa-1900 B&B with airy, tropical-inspired rooms, plus a poolside happy hour & loaner beach gear.
5.00 (134 reviews)
The Porch on Frances image
2
The Porch on Frances
Hotel
Upscale guesthouse in a 19th-century home featuring refined quarters, some with patios or balconies.
4.90 (99 reviews)
Seaside Place Key West - Vacation Rental image
3
Seaside Place Key West - Vacation Rental
Vacation home rental agency
👍👍 My family stayed at Seaside Place in August and loved it! Abbey was great! She responded almost immediately to emails and texts. With the uncertainty of COVID, Abbey helped put us at ease and made sure we were provided with as much information as possible. The house and pool are amazing! Nothing lik...
4.80 (38 reviews)
Key West Fishing Charters image
4
Key West Fishing Charters
Fishing charter
😐 Been here. Done that. Honestly not that impressed. The only thing to do is drink and bar hop. The beaches suck and everywhere is just trying to lie to you to get you to spend money because everyone is trying to make a quick buck or two. Everyone is scamming everyone. The best way to enjoy the place...
4.70 (47 reviews)
Travelers Palm Inn image
5
Travelers Palm Inn
Hotel
Casual inn with an outdoor pool & airy quarters, some with kitchens, set in conch-style cottages.
4.60 (71 reviews)
The Carriage Trade Inn image
6
The Carriage Trade Inn
Hotel
👍👍 Really enjoyed our stay; the location, aesthetic, accessibility, and friendliness of the owner was amazing for the price especially around a holiday. It was an old hotel with some quirks, for sure, but nothing most customers can't look past.
4.60 (14 reviews)
Navy exchange lodge image
7
Navy exchange lodge
Lodge
👍👍 Great rooms for active and retired military to relax and enjoy Key West and the lower keys.
4.50 (71 reviews)
Key West Bahama House image
8
Key West Bahama House
Hotel
Relaxed apartment hotel featuring warm units with kitchens, plus free Wi-Fi & an outdoor pool.
4.50 (42 reviews)
La Mer Hotel & Dewey House image
9
La Mer Hotel & Dewey House
Hotel
Stylish, adults-only B&B with warm rooms, water views, afternoon tea & access to outdoor pools.
4.50 (40 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )