Top rated Restaurants in Key West


  1. 5.00 Key West Food Tours   (701 reviews)
  2. 5.00 Mayanjali Organic Cafe   (65 reviews)
  3. 5.00 CAFELITO   (35 reviews)
  4. 4.90 Kaya Island Eats   (748 reviews) Island-inspired food in an outdoor spot
  5. 4.90 The Gardens Hotel   (468 reviews) €533
  6. 4.90 Red Shoe Island Bistro   (229 reviews) Informal spot for seafood options
  7. 4.90 The Garden Cafè Key West   (33 reviews) Dogs allowed
  8. 4.80 The Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory   (5603 reviews) Tropical habitat for butterflies & birds
  9. 4.80 The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.   (700 reviews) New American fare with creative twists
  10. 4.80 Key West Cuban Coffee   (576 reviews) Latin caffeine cafe with daytime dining
  11. 4.80 Santa Maria Suites Resort   (409 reviews) €412
  12. 4.80 The Jerk   (331 reviews)
  13. 4.80 Mam's Best Food   (284 reviews) Brunch
  14. 4.80 Lola's Bistro Key West   (267 reviews)
  15. 4.80 Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market   (212 reviews) Snug staple for organic vegan cafe bites
  16. 4.80 Corner Sandwich Shop   (157 reviews) Comfort food
  17. 4.80 The Artist House   (153 reviews) €196
  18. 4.80 Chart Room Cocktail Lounge   (134 reviews) Fast service
  19. 4.80 VIV Wine Bistro   (125 reviews) Cool hot spot with cheese & charcuterie
  20. 4.80 Key West Harbor Inn   (110 reviews) €219
  21. 4.80 Riviera Coffee & Sandwich Shop   (96 reviews)
  22. 4.80 Taco Grilla   (69 reviews) CLOSED
  23. 4.80 Mile Zero Cafe   (53 reviews) CLOSED
  24. 4.80 CD Anchor Food Truck Sigsbee   (52 reviews)
  25. 4.70 DJ's Clam Shack   (3184 reviews) Lively outdoor stand for lobster rolls
  26. 4.70 Better Than Sex - A Dessert Restaurant   (3170 reviews) Sophisticated dessert-only venue
  27. 4.70 Cuban Coffee Queen   (3015 reviews) Funky take-out spot for Cuban fare
  28. 4.70 Paradise Restaurant   (2684 reviews) Latin American cooking & a tropical vibe
  29. 4.70 Harpoon Harry's   (2307 reviews) American diner with a playful vibe
  30. 4.70 Santiago's Bodega | Key West   (2253 reviews) Global eats & sangria in cozy digs
  31. 4.70 Garbo's Grill @ Hanks!   (2187 reviews) Food stand for eclectic tacos & burgers
  32. 4.70 Latitudes   (2100 reviews) Stylish restaurant with sea views
  33. 4.70 Cuban Coffee Queen Downtown   (1575 reviews) Neighborhood cafe for Cuban eats
  34. 4.70 La Grignote   (1451 reviews) Artisanal French cafe, bakery & bistro
  35. 4.70 Square Grouper Bar and Grill   (1449 reviews) Casual stop for seafood & cocktails
  36. 4.70 The Lobster Shack Key West   (933 reviews) Classic seafood joint with beer & wine
  37. 4.70 "Off The Hook" Grill   (902 reviews) Snug bistro with seafood & American fare
  38. 4.70 Clemente's Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria   (890 reviews) Pizza & comfort food in old-school digs
  39. 4.70 Seaside Cafe at the Mansion   (674 reviews) Drinks, seafood & pizza with ocean views
  40. 4.70 Key Plaza Creperie   (674 reviews) Modern cafe for French & American eats
  41. 4.70 Goldman's Deli   (668 reviews) Casual Jewish deli known for bagels
  42. 4.70 Bien   (658 reviews) CLOSED
  43. 4.70 Sandy's Café   (600 reviews) Dogs allowed
  44. 4.70 Keys Coffee Co.   (541 reviews) Cheery cafe for coffee & sandwiches
  45. 4.70 Mo's Restaurant   (503 reviews) Caribbean-Creole soul-food kitchen
  46. 4.70 My New Joint   (404 reviews) Creative American fare in a modern space
  47. 4.70 Smoked BBQ   (399 reviews) Scenic, easygoing grill housed in a boat
  48. 4.70 5 Brothers Grocery and Sandwich Shop   (360 reviews) Longtime Cuban sandwich & coffee joint
  49. 4.70 Vinos on Duval   (259 reviews) Dogs allowed
  50. 4.70 PESCADO   (247 reviews) Upbeat food truck with seafood options
  51. 4.70 Bliss Restaurant Key West   (223 reviews) CLOSED
  52. 4.70 Peppers Of Key West   (212 reviews) CLOSED
  53. 4.70 Poké in the Rear   (199 reviews) Seafood bowl snack bar with a patio
  54. 4.70 The Roost   (187 reviews) Fast service
  55. 4.70 Key West - Sunset Key Ferry for Latitudes Resort and Restaurant   (156 reviews)
  56. 4.70 Yahman's Authentic Jamaican Jerk Shack   (95 reviews)
  57. 4.70 Souperhappy Noodle and Sake Bar   (64 reviews)
  58. 4.70 Hangover Hospital   (58 reviews)
  59. 4.70 Henry and Eli's Side Street Pub   (57 reviews) CLOSED
  60. 4.60 Blue Heaven   (7754 reviews) Floridian-Caribbean fusion-fare icon
  61. 4.60 Hogfish Bar & Grill   (5667 reviews) Bustling seafood shack by the harbor
  62. 4.60 El Siboney Restaurant   (4618 reviews) Homestyle Cuban cuisine & sangria
  63. 4.60 Irish Kevin's   (4058 reviews) Festive pub with live music
  64. 4.60 Green Parrot Bar   (3426 reviews) Landmark saloon with frequent live music
  65. 4.60 Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe   (2131 reviews) Breakfast
  66. 4.60 Moondog Cafe   (1942 reviews) Cottage cafe for eating & drinking
  67. 4.60 Ocean Key Resort & Spa   (1796 reviews) €518
  68. 4.60 Smokin' Tuna Saloon   (1645 reviews) Open-air bar with seafood & live music
  69. 4.60 The Cafe   (1392 reviews) Creative vegetarian eats amid local art
  70. 4.60 Mr. Z's   (1323 reviews) Lively no-frills pizza & sandwich spot
  71. 4.60 Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant   (1268 reviews) Seafood sandwiches & fried fish
  72. 4.60 Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden   (1144 reviews) Traditional & new pub fare in busy spot
  73. 4.60 Duetto Pizza and Gelato   (1141 reviews) Pizza, sandwiches & gelato
  74. 4.60 Kim’s Kuban   (990 reviews) Compact joint for Cuban & Mexican grub
  75. 4.60 Tavern N' Town   (927 reviews) Big, sleek tapas spot with open kitchen
  76. 4.60 El Siboney Restaurant ( Stock Island)   (891 reviews) Comfort food
  77. 4.60 Mary Ellen's Bar & Restaurant   (860 reviews) Cool tavern & grilled-cheese specialist
  78. 4.60 Flying Monkeys   (851 reviews) Frozen drinks & pub fare 365 days a year
  79. 4.60 Azur Restaurant   (727 reviews) Serene stop for Mediterranean dining
  80. 4.60 Sunset Key Cottages   (724 reviews) €1,286
  81. 4.60 Sinz Burritos   (679 reviews) Low-key pick for Mexican grub
  82. 4.60 Misohappy Sushi and Thai   (672 reviews) Upmarket nook for sushi & Thai dishes
  83. 4.60 Ana's Cuban Cafe and Southernmost Grocery   (666 reviews) Dogs allowed
  84. 4.60 Blackfin Bistro   (617 reviews) Seafood & burgers in swanky digs
  85. 4.60 Glazed Donuts   (582 reviews) Donuts in a chill robot-theme space
  86. 4.60 Little Pearl   (559 reviews) Tiny seafood restaurant with a warm vibe
  87. 4.60 Old Town Bakery   (535 reviews) Quaint outpost for bread & pastries
  88. 4.60 The Southernmost House Hotel   (456 reviews) €401
  89. 4.60 Fisherman's Cafe   (450 reviews) Casual walk-up seafood sandwich window
  90. 4.60 Date & Thyme Organic Cafe and Market   (435 reviews) Organic veggie eats in old gas station
  91. 4.60 Florida Keys Cafe   (434 reviews) Brunch
  92. 4.60 Kojin Noodle Bar   (415 reviews) Intimate noodle & ramen outlet
  93. 4.60 Sunset Tiki Bar & Grill   (410 reviews) Cocktails & live music in a buzzy resort
  94. 4.60 Frenchie's Cafe   (368 reviews) Daytime French cafe with outdoor seats
  95. 4.60 Stock Island Yacht Club & Marina   (364 reviews)
  96. 4.60 Key West Fish & Chips   (334 reviews) CLOSED
  97. 4.60 Milagro Restaurant and Bar   (332 reviews) Chic restaurant/bar for surf 'n' turf
  98. 4.60 Cafe Marquesa   (296 reviews) Elegant bistro with New American cuisine
  99. 4.60 Veterans of Foreign Wars, Post 3911   (290 reviews)
  100. 4.60 Agave 308 Tequila Bar   (265 reviews) CLOSED

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

What's a Top rated?

The list is sorted by the average review score for places with more than 30 reviews in Restaurants category .

This page was last updated on Dec 12, 2022.