I used to go to Thursdays all the time for their steak salads. I am a faithful Mario's fan and visit the Downtown Beaver Italian Restaurant a few times a week for the past almost 20 yrs. I had great expectations for his new restaurant. Well, after waiting close to 2 hrs for a table, we got sat down in a wobbly table in the corner that was surrounded by a ton of flies...we were moved a table away luckily...We ordered the stuffed shrimp to gauge the place...I honestly couldn't believe close to everything on menu had cayenne or spicy seasoning on it? Totally different than Mario's Dockside or Mario's in Beaver. I wasn't happy with the stuffed shrimp, unfortunately. It too was spicy! Nothing on menu stated this so I was shocked. We returned the meal and left hungry with ringing ears from the extreme volume in the building. Opening up the restaurant may look nice, however it caused no division in the bar, dining room, or stage. Not my vibe unfortunately as I'm not into loud bars. We ended up getting to-go from Mario's Beaver location instead.

So I came here on a Saturday night to experience "Mario's" new side project. I've been an avid lover of his Og restaurant in downtown Beaver "Mario's" for the past 15yrs. I love his pizza, mussels on Thurs & he has some of the best Gnocci I've ever tasted! So I had high expectations for Mario's 410 but they just fell short. I'm an avid foodie so I know better when trying new things. I always start out light. My wife & I ordered one order of the "Crab stuffed shrimp" that was it. We had to wait almost 2hrs for a table to begin with! We sat down & the very first thing I noticed was the noise levels. It was so loud & there was a band playing country music? It was like a bar, concert venue and wannabe high-end restaurant. Being an entrepreneur myself there's one thing I know best. You can't have all of this stuff & still expect to have a 5 star restaurant. It just doesn't work. It was way too loud. The noise actually hurt my ears. People had to talk so loud at their tables to over speak the band playing! Our food took almost an hour to arrive. Our waitress was anything but lackluster & the food was just terrible. The shrimp were fishy. The crab was mostly breading with backfin. The "lobster sauce" ontop of the shrimp was so spicy I couldn't even eat a whole shrimp. It's like someone piled in cayenne pepper? It lit me up I'm still dealing with a burning chest! I'm sensitive to spice but I can handle some heat. This was BEYOND a tolerable level. My wife said the same remark. We took one bite each & asked for the manager to adjust the check. The manager came to our table & he was very polite. He even agreed "yeah there's too much cayenne pepper in there." He agreed with us! He even stated that he has "told them that the dish has too much cayenne." His opinion & advice obviously seemed to have gone unrecognized. He removed the entree from our bill & we left. I had my wife call Mario's in Beaver & order our usual. I wouldn't ever recommend this place to anyone looking for higher quality food that is tasty & not loaded with spice & heat. The worse thing is their menu doesn't mention anything at all about "cayenne pepper" in the stuffed shrimp dish. I noticed quite few other dishes that said "Sriracha sauce" & "cayenne pepper". That's why I didn't order any of those dishes. That's why I chose the "Crab stuffed shrimp" because it said nothing about "cayenne" in the description. I couldn't wait to get out of there. I left hungry, annoyed & my chest is on fire. Hopefully my a**hole ain't next...🫢😲😫

The restaurant is always loud, very hard to have a conversation. The food is wonderful. The service is great. But I have gone home with a headache the last 2 times we went for lunch/dinner. Wish they could do something about the acoustics to less the noise level.

Hadn't been here in 30 years. Did not eat any food. The outside is a great space to see a band. Plenty of space with two bars plus table service. Small stage with a surprisingly good sound system. The parking lot is small for the total capacity. No complaints.

The food was great (I had a pizza, thin crust pepperoni). It’s not a ball of dough like Papa John’s, but not as thin as Apizza in New Haven. Our server was great. She was attentive, detailed, and pleasant. The only issue for me was the acoustics of the place. I fully understand that we had dinner on New Year’s Eve, and I knew there was a band, but damn! The band was inside, and the smooth hard walls and ceiling reflected the sound pretty intensely. A lot of people were having a great time. It was just painful for my ears. I would have been happy with earplugs, but I don’t typically carry them around. I did hear that it is the same when a band it there, so I am definitely going back for food on non-band nights. Great food place!!!

If you want pizza this is your place. Great pizza. Other than that the food seems to have gone down hill since they moved. The service is ok not the best but not the worst. Don’t bother ordering a appetizer unless you want it when your meal comes. That has happened the last 3 times we have gone. I really hope it improves like it was down the road.

What I didn't like was the red sauce has a noted green pepper taste too it, similar to what is more common down south in the USA. It's out of place here in the north. The pizza was not crispy in the bottom crust, it could have taken more heat to finish the texture. Overall, I was disappointed. We have Yolanda's sauce, Ambridge Frank's and Police Station Pizza and Monte Cello pizza that are all absolute top notch. Mario's sadly disappointed my hopeful expectations. The atmosphere and the presentation were fantastic, but it did not win me over.

Take value in their menu selection and drink choices. Our favorite thing to order is the lobster pizza. Sharing some good drinks while eating this is a must. I recommend going to this restaurant.

I and some friends went there for the Live Wire/Last Train to Ozz show. First time there and wasn't really impressed. The show was outside which was nice, but not enough seating. Had to wait for some to leave before we got a table and chairs. To order food, there was not enough staff to do so. Had to go inside, place an order to go, then waited and hour for it to be done and go back inside to get it and bring back outside to our table...and it was only a pizza. The pizza wasn't the greatest either, paper thin crust, when I picked it up it folded down and half the toppings slide off! The bartenders on the other hand were great! Always quick with drinks and no waiting around! They were tipped well. I'm mixed on coming back for any other shows.

Even though they were down a cook, service was timely. Food was spot on. Old -fashioneds were pretty good. Just need dirty cherries to put them over the top. Music on the patio was ear-drum blowing. Great night out. Cleaner and nicer than old Mario's. Thank you for all that you do for the community

It's honestly a great place but we were there on Thursday night after work and it was so hot in the restaurant. I know it was in the 90's outside but it was so awful that when we left we had sweat marks. We used the menu for a fan. I love what they did with the place but I would put some fans in to move the air around especially with the hot pizza oven in the area of the sitting area. It is also really loud inside. We were a table of 5 and we had to yell to hear each other. We ordered a bunch of appetizers and shared and the food was great!

Loud! Loud! Loud! Can’t have a conversation. Can’t hear the server. Can’t order verbally. (Had to point at the menu) but My ears may never stop ringing. My headache may never go away! The accoustics are terrible, add a band at top volume and it is unbearable. The food was good but not worth the pain.

First time at this restaurant and we had a great experience. The server was attentive and kind and the atmosphere was nice. Both my husband and I really enjoyed our meal, especially the French fries ☺️