Yikes..$75 for two pizzas? I have celiac disease and there’s an $8 up charge for gluten free crust. I’d suggest checking out somewhere else with more reasonable prices.

Great place for a quick slice of pizza in Inman Square, Cambridge. Slices are big, and the crust is on the thinner side. They have drinks and sell beer. $3.75-$4.75 per slice depending on what you get.

3.5 stars I recently ordered takeout from here and the plain pizza was decent. I've tried some of the speciality pies before and those seem to be much more flavorful and popular relative to the classic cheese pie. If you're looking for a classic pizza place, I'd probably look elsewhere, but for more exciting flavors I'd go here. I did have to wait longer than expected, despite ordering on the phone beforehand. I was told someone new was working on the pizza and had burned it. I was in a bit of a rush, so this was frustrating. Not a typical experience, though, I'm sure. Last thing is parking here can be challenging, because it's a very busy street.

LOVE the atmosphere here - every time I'd come in for a slice or two, I'd notice a new character on the wall... the pizza slices are a great size for the price. My partner and I would always get two slices of cheese, and a vegetarian slice! Wish we could've tried more of their unique pie options before we moved... but All-Star is my All-Time favorite pizza spot in the greater Boston area, it was an honor to have it in my neighborhood!

Mostly very good pizza but we were pretty surprised by how salty the broccoli rabe was! Generally pretty salty sauces anyway. The GF broccoli rabe Pizza was $38 so I called to see about getting a refund. They offered me 5 - 10% off my next order. Three of us couldn't handle the salt content so we wound up throwing out most of the topping. Also, $8 Xtra charge for gf? Whoa..

Last time I was here, I didn’t really like the pizza But today was my 3rd time. And they said 3rd time is the charm. The pizza I got today was So Fresh!! Juicy too. No burnt back-side. Perfect! Also, Cooked with care. The receptionist was very welcoming. This place definitely gets 5/5 today.

SPO (Sausage Peppers Onion) is a go-to. Their cheese pizza is also delicious - their marinara sauce is on of the best!

First time having All-Star pizza and I got to say it didn’t disappoint. The Duck confit was really good, Iv never really had a pizza like it. Solid flavor and a good amount of duck but unlike some other pizza shops it wasn’t overfilled with toppings.