Excellent experience at this restaurant. Angelina treats you like royalty, and the food speaks for itself. Delish 😋😋 Ihh and it's BYOB. So bring your best wine to pair with their delicious food.

Absolutely the best spot in town. We had dinner last night with our family and it’s our new favorite. The food is amazing and the staff is so friendly. New owners know their stuff about a good meal. Order the salmon, mussels or penne all a vodka, you won’t be disappointed!

I work in a doctors office and we get lunches pretty often. One of the pharmaceutical reps that was doing our lunch gave the office manager a budget and allowed her to place an order for what we wanted. We have never had food from Bella Maria before and needless to say we won’t be going back. As I was eating my food I was going to cut my chicken and found a roach on my food I almost threw up when I saw it. We called the place and of course they apologized and offers to bring us a new tray of food which we didn’t take. We just wanted a refund. When there’s one roach there’s more and this place must be dirty for this to happen. Won’t be going back here again

This pizza was so delicious! The place is clean, the workers are nice. It is under new management - what an upgrade! They heated our slices so fast and it was so fresh and hot and tasty.

Let’s support local businesses Must try: mozzarella sticks, house salad, eggplant parmigiana, linguine and clam sauce

This used to be a good place to go for a halfway decent slice, when you needed someplace close and quick. The new ownership cooks the pies in advance and keeps them below the counter. If you’re only going for a slice or two, you’ll get a stale, greasy slice that was cooked hours (who knows maybe days) in advance and reheated. Might as order from Dominos.

Since under new ownership I have visited several times, the pizza is delicious and always fresh. I have sat down and had dinner with my family and it was spectacular. We love the chicken Marsala, chicken franchese and the clam sauce spaghetti.

I’ve gone multiple times since it has come under new ownership and absolutely loved it. I’ve dined in the dining room in the back, service was amazing and the food was incredible. I’ve also stopped in for slices at the front and they have a huge selection. Most recently I went with a Buffalo chicken slice, a pinwheel and the Buffalo garlic knots… get the Buffalo garlic knots

I tried them one night after my usual pizza place was rude. Their food was excellent, the girl who answered the phone was patient and took her time making sure our order was correct, and my husband thought the inside was very nicely kept. Definitely a repeat customer here.

BEWARE…. Ordered chicken parmigiana on their website and subtotal came to $24.50 plus tax $2.11 for a total $26.61. I go pick it up and I get charged $29.26. When I asked about the different prices I was told that I was being charged 4% for paying with a debit/credit card. When I got home and looked at my receipt it said subtotal $26.94 and tax $2.32 for a total of $29.26. Nowhere was there any additional charge, it just had two different subtotals and tax amounts? I think it would be really nice as well as transparent that they post that on their website. They also “automatically” add on a gratuity to your total when you place an order for pick up. Not sure why, I was not dining in or getting delivery. When I got home and looked at my receipt I would not have even bothered wasting my time to review them, but on top of all of that the chicken parmigiana was horrible. Small thin little strips of chicken that were tough and chewy. Looking forward to having a nice dinner, instead threw it away. P.S. before I wrote this review I glanced at the other reviews and was absolutely disgusted to see a review from four months ago with a picture of a roach in the customers food.

Saying this with 17 years in the pizza industry . Great food and price . Second time I had the food here . And both times I was more than impressed with the flavors and presentation. Can’t go wrong with this place as a the local spot . All the staff is very nice too . Will definitely be back for more .

I ordered the stuffed mushrooms, homemade lasagna and rustic pasta, for delivery. No napkins or utensils. Pathetic. Am I in East New York or Port Jefferson - I can't tell. Good luck to this business. $60.00 with tip and no napkins or fork. Sooo effed-up.