I would have never found the place, hidden in the neighborhood, if the GameStop guy didn’t recommend to me. I ordered seafood pizza. Shrimp and crab meat flavor was spot on. The shrimp was the most tender I’ve ever had on a pizza. The cheese was perfectly melty and floating on Alfredo sauce. The dough was very light and airy, and magically crusty around the edge and the bottom. Would recommend whoever is in town. And if I have the pleasure to visit the town again I’d love to try the shrimp Alfredo pasta, as I’m sure they will nail the seemingly typical but can-be-delicate dish.

Husband usually gets Prime Rib, me I love the Shrimp and Crab Alfredo! Nice salad with your meal and good portions!

Impressive taste and quality...meals made the old-fashioned way....YUM...

Amazing food, HUGE portions, and our server was amazing. Unfortunately the food I ordered was dry and did not taste how it should and instead if comping it from the meal, they still made me pay full price. Rude management, will not be back.

The bartenders were great and I never had to wait for a drink. The owner is out and very friendly with the customers. Would definitely recommend going here

Despite the strange location, this is very good food and excellent service.

Very poor service. Maybe 10 people in there at best including the bar. 30 mins to get a refill on my drink and my meal was almost half way gone before the parmesan cheese was brought out. Pathetic.

Food is pretty good, restaurant is very outdated & needs a major overhaul. Very pricey for such a run down atmosphere.

Food is phenomenal, I've been there multiple times and never had anything bad. Still a great place to eat but there's a slight difference in the food since ownership change. Option of a bar setting or they have a separate dining hall, and party room for private functions.

They have really good food and service!

Service was pretty good, waitress was learning, polite & trying to get it right. Food was not so good. My chicken piccata came without artichoke. My wife's dish had so much marinara sauce that's all she could taste. They brought her a different dish & it was OK. They brought me artichokes but by then my dish was almost cold.

Excellent Food Amazing Service!

Delicious fresh made food. Great genuine Italian bursting with flavor and spices mixed with the perfect balance of sweet, spicy, and savory. Worth every penny

Awesome place. Great pizza and Fried Ravioli. They had a rock band from 8-12 last night too. The place was jumping!

Well. My sister & I ordered a plate of food to share. The server set the plates down & told us “they separated them in the back” for us. We got out bill & realized they charged us $4 to separate the plates. No one told us. The food was barely edible. This was supposed to be chicken piccata.

Eating at Stefano's was an awesome experience! They have a small fancy dining area, and a larger, very chill, bar room. My friends and I ate in the dining room and had a great time! The food was astounding, we had the option to get drinks from the bar, even if we weren't sitting there, and the service was perfect! 100% would genuinely recommend it!

The food is so good! You can tell it’s from scratch. And, gluten free options!

Food was delicious. Portion size was very generous. Server was newer but attentive and provided very good service.