No way is this place is 4 stars, no freaking way. I can doctor a frozen pizza to look and taste better than this. This pie is a sauceless, cheap cheesy disaster on a semi translucent, dried out piece of cardboard crust with toppings that look like they came from the dollar store throw away section. The wings we ordered look like they used chickens starved for several weeks, then dehydrated, and fried until there was only skin left to peel away from bone. And oh my, look at the photo of the blue cheese… it’s yellow and resembles the consistency of snot mixed with a vinaigrette. All we ordered was a pie and wings, costing us over $40… so we thought, wow, must be great! Wrong. We were starving when we ordered this and decided to throw it away and eat cereal for dinner.

Last night I ordered a side of meatballs and small pizza. I bit into the meatball and bit down on something hard. To find out It was a SHARP piece of glass about the size of my molar. I emailed them right away and went down to the pizza shop to show them and all they offered was a refund. Now my tooth hurts and I have to go to the dentist. I have been a loyal, repeat customer since they opened. I will NEVER order from them again.

ACTUALLY BAD!!! As a local living up the street, I wanted to like this place. I gave them 3 chances. It gets worse every time. This is cafeteria pizza, served at outrageous prices. Luigi's in Breck pays south main rent and provides a far better product for less. IF YOURE VISITING: Welcome! I know it's tempting to eat here since it's close, but DO NOT DO IT!! You will regret it. You can order Pizza 101 (BEST!) from Keystone, Windy City from Silverthorne, even Domino's is 10000% better than this dreck. To the staff: DO BETTER! If you wonder how they have 4 stars, see my 2nd photo and remember we love beer here in Summit.

Scrappy wasn’t here today but I did get to meet Helen. I would of loved to have given this place a five but it barely gets three. Really sad because I did love Helen and the place is cute. Pizza wasn’t cooked very well, toppings were poor, hardly any sauce and it wasn’t cut, argh! YOU ALL NEED TO KICK IT UP A NOTCH!

I ordered pizza to-go with a friend. To my surprise, this was actually the BEST, closest thing to NY style pizza I've had in the entire state of Colorado! I've seriously been searching high and low for a good NY style pizza around Denver and nothing is as good as Scrappys! Every time I drive through Dillon, I'll have to stop here. The flavor is fantastic and the crust is exactly what you'd expect. Highly recommend!

We were lucky enough to get to enjoy Scrappy's 2x in one day on our recent trip to the mountains. We stopped by and grabbed some subs to take to Dillon Reservoir for a picnic then had their pizza at Dillon Amphitheater at a concert. Both were fresh, homemade and incredibly delicious. Can't wait to go back and try more menu items! The owners are great and the staff is very friendly. Highly recommend!

This unassuming pizza joint will make you feel at home while having the best cheese pizza from here to Mississippi. The crust is just the right thinness while the cheese is tasty and toasted. Friendly owner and staff complete the picture.

Loved it! It was my first time trying and eating here. My dad has ate here many times and I couldn’t wait to try it. I recommend a side of marinara 😉 they have twisted tea on tap which is always fun. Food tasted fresh, Nick is the owner he’s GREAT. This was my dads first time meeting the manger but the other staff he said is great too. Definitely recommend checking it out if you like pizza !

Came up for a wedding and dropped by this spot since it was close to the hotel. It was an absolutely fantastic experience, the staff and new owners were delightful and welcoming in conversation. The food was good if a bit pricey but the experience was all in all fantastic!

We strolled up to place tired and hungry after a ride at tenderfoot mountain that went a little too long. We sat down gratefully outside on the front patio and someone came out immediately to serve us and bring us ice cold waters. The pizza was great and hit the spot. The fresh tomato and broccoli on ours really went well with the cheese and crispy crust. We even got a locals discount! Definitely will come back. FYI we came down a great jump trail on snake bluffs and connected to the rec path and a little uphill to town if anyone wants to bike there before biking back up to the parking lot at tenderfoot

Food good, prices are outrageous, I ordered through Uber eats and paid $11 for the salad pictured in my review, this is like ¢0.50 of lettuce and a little meat and cheese, not an $11 salad. GF pizza tastes good but again, tiny (pretty much personal size pizza) for $21 really outrageous pricing for ok/kinda good food

I wish there were half stars because this place would get three and a half. Great pizza crust, good amount of toppings and flavors were good. The pics show a $12 “large Ceaser” salad…hate to see what the small order looks like. Salad barely served two. The side of marinara is two bucks…each slice needs a side of sauce; figure an extra $16 for sides (14-inch) of red sauce and the pie would be perfect.

I ordered delivery through google storefront that used door dash. I am in the area visiting and the pictures looked good. I ordered a cheesesteak with mushrooms pizza and meatballs. The pizza was basically burnt on the bottom and the cheese in the middle barely even melted. The amount of raw onion on it is disgusting- because cheesesteaks should have grilled onions. The meatball I tried was okay- for the first half. The second half I couldn’t even chew through. It’s where it was stuck on the pan and definitely incredibly overcooked. Never had a meatball too tough- usually it’s the other way around- too mushy. Overall very disappointed. Just wanted a quick and good pizza delivered after a drive down for the weekend from Fort Collins while staying at an AirBnB. Maybe go there directly? And get one slice? So you don’t have to have it ultimately get cold during delivery? I don’t know- the choice is yours.

I stopped in for dinner and a pint after a long drive. The Scalia Italian sandwich was delicious. The bread and ingredients were fresh and the deli meat was cut for my sandwich. My only regret was that I didn't get to try the pizza and garlic bread. Both looked and smelled amazing. Staff was friendly and they had a nice selection of cold beer. Well worth a visit if you're in town.

This might be a top 5 all-time pizza for me. The crust is a perfect chewy dough with a crunchy bottom. Buttery cheese and creamy white base was fantastic with garlic and jalapeños

Had a Tree Hugger Pizza. Vegetarian but definitely not vegan. Mozzarella broccoli mushroom and tomatos made for a fine toppings on a pesto sauce. The baker with us was especially impressed with the crust. Slightly chewy on the edges and thin center. For me the pesto sauce with the mozzarella was the center. Pretty good view eating outside.

The coolest pizza shop I’ve ever been to. I can honestly say I never leave reviews but the pizza was THAT good. I ordered a cheesesteak and I’m from Philly and this one even tops Jim’s.