Staff are rude and unprofessional. Could be heard making racist remarks about black and Asian people. Food is alright. I've seen middle schoolers put together better pastas, but if you want some low-tier Italian diner food or a crusty slice of cardboard pizza from yesterday; Stefano's has your back!

Owner, Staff, Meals and Catering are fantastic! Great homemade Italian dishes. We have been ordering for 10 plus years and have never had a problem. Try the Monday night pizza special. whatever time you order get a whole pie at that price.. 6PM = $6 🍕 pie

Stefano’s is fantastic! Great food! Great prices! Great portions! Items Ordered: -Fried Calamari -Jame’s Italian Garden Salad. I asked for Balsamic Vinaigrette. -Chicken Murphy w/ Spaghetti. Served w/ small salad w/ choice of dressing (Creamy Italian) & bread. -Veal Marsala w/ Linguine. Served w/ small salad &w/ choice of dressing (Caesar) & bread. -2 orders of Garlic Bread -Salami, Ham, & Provolone Sub w/ Extra Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Salt, Pepper, Oregano, & Oil & Vinegar. All subs are 9 inches. -French Fries Pros: 1. Very friendly when I called to place the order 2. Great prices. 3. The Calamari is a large he enough portion to have as a meal. It is served w/ a nice, sweet red sauce. 4. The Ham, Salami, & Provolone Sub was perfect. The bread was crispy. The sun was stuffed w/ cold cuts and flavor. They make a great sub. 5. The Jame’s Salad was really fresh and enough for 2-3 portions. It was hard to stop eating! 6. The Chicken Murphy has tender chicken w/ the perfect amount of sauce. 7. The Veal Marsala is light and tender w/ good, home style flavor. 8. Each entree portion is enough for 2-3 servings. 9. Fries are your standard crinkle cut fries, but I really like them. Cons: 1. I wish the subs were bigger b/c they are delicious and I cannot stop eating them!

Finally got around to trying this place and I was pleasantly surprised. My rating is currently based on my one recent experience - which was to order the Monday Pizza Special. You call in between 6pm and 8pm - and whatever time you call is the price you pay for a large plain pizza - great deal. What surprised me was that it was actually a really good plain pie! The sauce in particular was great because it wasn't sweet like some places - and I appreciated that. The flavor was perfect. From the looks of the pie - it's a standard, basic plain pie. For the Monday special price - it's an excellent deal - and I bet they are super busy on Mondays. That being said - even when they're busy, the people here are patient and courteous. I've seen pictures of their sandwiches and salads and they look really good - so I'm hoping to try some other menu items soon. Overall, I was really happy with my recent experience, and I definitely look forward to trying them again soon.

Does this look worth $17.70 to you? A grey burger, old shredded lettuce, grainy tomatoes, Vlassic pickles, and some Shop-Rite brand crinkle cut fries? Nah. The fries didn't even have a top on them, were just shoved in the bag with an open top. Maybe I caught a bad day, but...ew. Never again. Too expensive for what you get.

I’m writing this review because I just came here to buy food and I came knowing that I just looked at reviews and one of the reviews mentions the fact that the price was different using a credit card, however, there is a sign right next to the register that states clearly that there is a charge if you pay by card and the price posted is cash payment. Besides this I bought myself a Caesar chicken wrap and it was amazing. Below is the photo thanks, Stefanos.

Excellent pie, great sauce super crisp good crust and pretty cool people work there too stop there for lunch first time on January 3rd and I'm sure I'll be back if I cross paths that way well worth a try God bless happy New Year

Attended a birthday 🎂 party and we had a great time. The staff was friendly and responded to our requests. We had mozzarella sticks, garlic bread and chicken parm with pasta. Everything was delish!

First time trying this restaurant when I was on my lunch break. I was very satisfied with their pizza regular and white slices. I will go back there again.

Thank you so much to John and the staff for making my son’s birthday party a blast! All 22 of us enjoyed the food and service. We are coming back for sure!

Some of the best pizza, period. Great plain slice. And I’ve yet to find anywhere else nearby—or in some parts of NYC— that offers Sfincione slices. I hope they’re still making them. Also love spinach or broccoli with ricotta slices. Good garlic knots. Been coming here since I was a kid, when Sal was making the pizzas.

They are so nice here! I have been coming for over 10 years from working in the area and I no longer do but I stopped in the other day and the same guys are there. I’m not sure if it’s the owner with the accent but he is always so kind. I love their grilled chicken salad with a great portion of chicken! You guys are the best ❤️

Was in the area and had a craving for a couple of slices. I usually have my go to spots for pizza, but Stefano’s was convenient to the area I needed to be. The food and the atmosphere were wonderful. The owner was there and was as friendly as could be. And the slices that I had - 1 sausage and 1 Brooklyn - were excellent. Options to eat indoors or outside. If I am in the area again, would definitely stop back for some more.

We like Stefano's, especially for their "Pay the Time You Order" deal that starts at 6pm on Mondays. The pizza is fresh and the service is always friendly.

Although Stefano's is in a small stop mall, the food and service were great! They had some outside seating and the day was perfect for that! BYOB is a plus. I didn't feel rushed at all. We spent a couple of hours there. Very easy to get to with lots of free parking.

Really enjoyed my daughter's Graduation celebration with 18 family members! Steve went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect as did the entire staff! Everyone really enjoyed their dinners and it was nice having the room to ourselves. Thank you Stefano's! We'll see you next year for our Son's Graduation party! 🙂

Extremely average food and the audacity to charge the prices they do is a bit ridiculous. Ordered quite a few times because it's so convenient, but no more. Ordered a wrap and the portions were terrible, was still hungry after. Tell me how one wrap and the smallest order of "garlic knots" comes out to $15. The place really needs to evaluate the food quality and pricing associated with it.

I order food at 12.30 and got it in 30 minutes without utensils. I called back and they said they would send them with the driver but I never received them so I called back, then I was told we can send utilities 2 hours later and he said it was still eatable and hung up the phone

Consistently amazing food. Great salads, great pizza, great pasta! The eggplant parm is fantastic.

I placed an order at 3:52PM at 4:58PM I called back to see what was going on with my order The guy said he’ll be there in a few minutes, it was 40 minutes later when we got our food which was no longer hot. This place is one and done.

Pizza was tasty! Friendly service seems like a great family place. There is a park next door you can walk while you wait on your pie or maybe afterwards, lol.

Tried Strawberry patch salad with grilled chicken. Great portion even for two people. Food quality is fresh and light.

The food is amazing. The pizza is hot and crispy and flavourful. The staff is caring, and Steve's rice balls are a culinary perfection.

Ok my first east coast Italian meal and I have to say its good. The best was the Minestrone soup.

Our service was great and the food was amazing. The lasagna was so good I stuffed myself, it was the first time my teen boys couldn't finish the whole pizza. They said it was the best pizza they have ever had. That's saying a LOT since my boys live on Pizza.

Fantastic pizza, with an incredible Monday pizza special. My family and I order every Monday! Between 6-8pm whatever time you order is the price of your pie! My wife also loves the eggplant, top notch! Can't forget the amazing customer service, family oriented and our favorite in EB.