What an amazing gift they help me create. We took a beautiful tennis bracelet of my moms and turned it into 2 bracelets (1 for each daughter) and a single stone necklace for her only granddaughter. It is perfect in so many ways. Larry had great ideas to help me plan it and the ladies in the shop were so compassionate and empathetic in seeing how important this was to me. Turnaround time was outstanding and the fantastic jeweler sized it for me as I waited.

My mom was looking to get her engagement ring re-set. They did an amazing job. They sat and helped her pick out the just right setting. It turned out beautiful! So grateful, my mom is so happy!

If you’re looking to sell your jewelry or in the market for something new, this is the spot!! My husband and I travel all the way from the city to Great American Jeweler in Massapequa and it’s worth the trip. We got paid top dollar for old gold jewelry and diamonds that were just laying in our jewelry box. I got a great deal on a new pair of diamond studs with my trade ins. So happy we ended up at Great American. Great customer service and super friendly. I also ended up getting an old ring sized to fit me and am so happy I can wear my ring again!! I can’t say enough how happy we found this place. Thank you again, Marilyn and Greg

Great American Jewelry was recommended to me by a family friend because my fiancé and I were looking for wedding bands. Janet was super patient and helpful with us. We both got beautiful wedding bands. She really made the experience so nice. I went back a few weeks later with my Mom who wanted to make a necklace out of her ring and my grandma’s ring for me. Janet helped us design the necklace and really saw the vision of it. The necklace is so, so beautiful and I can’t wait to wear it on my wedding day. Thank you so much again Janet!

My daughter and I had a wonderful experience with Janet at Great American Jewelry. I brought in my mom’s wedding band and mine, and Janet designed a beautiful necklace for my daughter to wear on her wedding day. Janet is so sweet and patient, and she made our time with her so much fun. I had a necklace made for myself, as well, and Janet advised me on that beautiful necklace, too. It was such a special experience working with her and we enjoyed every moment of it. I will definitely use Great American Jewelry in the future.

Highly recommend Great American Jewelry. They have gorgeous high quality pieces and their customer service is top notch. Mary helped me with my order. She is lovely and goes above and beyond for the customers.

My sister and I had some old gold pieces we were interested in selling. We went to Great American, based on other reviews. We were just going for a quote. We were so pleased with the quote, there was no reason to go anywhere else. Thank you Laurie and Mary for being so professional and friendly. You both made the transaction so easy and you’ve gained 2 more customers! Nancy & Lorraine

I went to a jewelry store in Oceanside to replace a missing diamond in my wedding band. I shared with my friend what they quoted me and she told me to get my ring and bring it to Great American in Massapequa Park where I was charged less than half. Very professional, lovely staff, great quality work and prices are reasonable. So happy to have my ring repaired and back on my finger! Thank you!

I had the best experience working with Larry and Great American Jewelry. Picking out my sisters engagement ring was an extremely special time and moment and Larry made sure he did everything he could to find me exactly what I wanted and that I left as happy as could be. I would recommend working with him and the rest of the team at Great American Jewelry any day and couldn’t thank him enough for the seamless and exciting experience we had in finding the “perfect” fit for her.

Hands down, the best jewelers we have ever met. Firstly, Laurie and Larry are extremely personable and we always felt welcomed and at home whenever we walked through the doors of their quaint shop in Massapequa. We highly recommend them for their expertise, guidance and unparalleled customer service. They listened to what our wants were and did not disappoint. They helped me design the most spectacular engagement and wedding bands possible. Laurie went above and beyond and even delivered it to my location in person! Moreover, they helped us find the most perfect gifts for our bridal party. For my wife and I, this is only the beginning of many more visits to their magical shop in the near future.

After 35 years of marriage my husband surprised me with a new engagement ring and wedding band. Our experience with selecting the diamond and setting was incredible. Mary and Laurie took us through the process of putting my wedding set together with ease. My rings are amazing. I would highly recommend Great American Jewelry.

Searched on google for a jewelry place to have my fiancé’s mother engagement ring redone. I must say, I am very pleased with how it turned out. They exceeded my expectations with the work done and it came out basically perfect. I was also worried about pricing. It was VERY affordable & no sneaky fees or increased prices after I came to pick up the ring. The price given initially remained the same price to purchase. Thank you Great American Jewelry.

I brought a sapphire and diamond ring to Great American Jewelry that I inherited from my mother to have it reset. I had a couple of ideas in mind. Debra worked with me to design the new setting. She even brought out different rings to give me ideas. I’m so happy with my new ring. With this new setting I’ll be wearing it much more often. Debra, it’s perfect. Thank you for your help and all the time you spent with me.

A diamond is forever! For me, so is the love that was attached to mine. After losing the love of my life, I struggled with what to do with my engagement ring. Words cannot describe how grateful I am to Jared & Janet from Great American Jewelers for creating this exceptionally stunning piece so that I can carry that love forward with me forever!

If you are looking for an honest, reputable jeweler, look no further than Great American Jewelry in Massapequa. I inherited my mother’s diamond heart necklace, and it’s been in a box for several years and I wanted to make something out of it that I could use. The lovely ladies, Mary and Janet, were so friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable. They took the time and sat with me and answered all my questions. They ended up making me the most stunning, gorgeous pair of custom diamond hoop earrings. They are perfect, exactly what I wanted. The quality and craftsmanship is beyond compare. Thank you ladies, I couldn’t be happier with the results! I highly recommend Great American Jewelry! Paula

I came into Great American Jewelers on the recommendation of a friend to sell a ring. Lori and her staff were very helpful, professional and knowledgeable. They were able to secure a selling price well above the other estimates I received, including one from the jewelry store where the ring was purchased. They were also able to get me a hard to find watch I’d been shopping for. Needless to say, Great American Jewelry will be the only store my family will give their business to!

Awesome experience, amazing staff, perfect prices. Extremely friendly patient and helpful. All in All perfect place to purchase a ring! Thanks again guys!

Had an amazing experience getting an engagement ring here. They are so warm and inviting. Customer service is impeccable. They took care of every last thing, down to writing up an appraisal for insurance and making small last minute adjustments. Prices are reasonable and it's great to support a local business.

Janet was a dream to work with when shopping for an engagement ring! She was extremely attentive and quick to respond to any questions I had. Buying an engagement ring is always a little stressful but Janet actually made this a very fun and exciting experience. She’s a true professional who knows exactly what you’re looking for. All I had to do was send her some examples and she was able to put together the ring of our dreams! Not to mention the quality of the diamond is unmatched. I couldn’t be happier with the service. Thank you Janet and everyone at Great American Jewelry!

Laurie made the experience of finding an engagement for my fiancé so enjoyable and easy. She is very knowledgeable and invested her time and attention to me in ways other jewelers did not. She stayed with me until past the time her store closes to make sure I was satisfied with our sit down. She was available the next day to review my options again and make a decision. She provided so much value and helped me pick the perfect ring. We could not be happier and I can’t wait to work with them not in the future.

I went to Great American Jewelry to sell a piece of jewelry. My mom’s bracelet. She passed 9 years ago. It has taken me a long time to sell it. Everyone there is very friendly. Larry took a good amount of time looking at it, and evaluating the piece. He gave me an amount, and I went back a week later to sell. He remembered and also the amount he offered . You can tell he cares about jewelry, but people too.

Had a great experience at Great American Jewelry. The staff was very pleasant and helpful. Janet went above and beyond helping find exactly what I was looking for, and the final product came out better than I could have imagined. They do a fantastic job here and would go back for any jewelry related needs.

Great American not only made me one but two pieces of amazing, high quality jewelry. They took my vision and exceed my expectations. They were able to take my grandmother’s engagement ring and make me a new engagement ring and also a wedding band that are absolutely beautiful. Would highly recommend their staff is extremely helpful and friendly.

This place is the best! Every time I went in here looking for an engagement ring everyone was so helpful and engaging. I worked with Janet who was simply above and beyond and exceeded all of my expectations. Worked with me on pricing and didn’t rush the sale at all. Very personable and flexible to your needs and I had a great experience. I’d definitely recommend this place to anyone !

I have been dealing with LARRY at the wonder shop since 1981 and I would never buy jewelry anywhere else. I only live three months on Long Island and the rest in Florida and I wait until I’m up here between June and October and purchase anything I need or get anything I need repaired at Great American jewelry!

Review Our visit to Great American Jewelry was an absolutely positive experience. We were there to sell old family gold jewelry and an old watch. The prices quoted were reasonable and we were totally satisfied with the results. The staff was knowledgeable, helpful, and considerate. They were able to fix a locket, that I had been told by others was unrepairable, and they were also able to identify an old ring as being my grandmother’s engagement ring. We will now be able to pass these down to our children. Beyond that, we were engaged in friendly conversation as if amongst old friends. Stopping at Great American Jewelry was both profitable and pleasant and we would not hesitate to return.

Going to great American jewelers was an excellent experience. From the moment I walked in I was very well taken care of and the people helping me were extremely thoughtful making sure I made the right decisions since I am not really a jewelry guy. Also I only met him briefly but I loved their dog.

Amazing experience. I was always skeptical of small jewelry shops, i always thought i was going to be over paying. Well not here!! When i came here back in june i came in looking for an engagement ring, Marie did not disappoint me or try and up-sell me on anything, which made me so happy. She worked with my budget and actually had the same exact ring i had in my phone saved for 3 years. I will not be shopping anywhere else for my jewelry in the future. Thank you so much for making my experience the best and helping me execute my day with the perfect ring!!

Great American Jewelry workers are so friendly and kind, and they are willing to do custom designs! They finished my order quick and they created a beautiful necklace with my mother's old diamond that they polished up to look good as new. Amazing experience here!

Everyone is super nice, helpful and very knowledgeable. Highly recommend. We will definitely be back for future purchases!

Such a great jewelry store. We went in looking for a christening gift and Mary was so helpful, she helped us pick out the most perfect gift. It was fast and easy and she wrapped it up for us. Such a great experience. They go above and beyond. Highly recommend.

My forever jeweler! The sweetest and most helpful jewelers! My now fiancé and I came to Great American in 2019 to get an idea of what style engagement ring I like and they were so helpful and knowledgeable. We also purchased our wedding bands from Great American Jewelry and OH MY they are stunning. So many beautiful options to choose from, as well as customs. You will not be disappointed! Thank you Great American Jewelry. You guys are truly one of a kind and amazing!

Sometimes you have to share the Truth . I had a terrible experience with this Jeweler . About 2 weeks ago I Went in to Have my Christian Ring resized as I had Lost Weight . I thought this was a Normal thing for a jeweler to do so I trusted this Jeweler and After Wearing this ring for a Day I Realized it was to tight as I had paid 70.00 . So I went back and the Jeweler made it Bigger . I then went home and Later on I realized my initials were buffed off so I then went back a 3rd time and Left it with them to please have my initials Reengraved . 4 days later I returned and Picked up the ring and it seemed Different ( Lighter and Shaved Down ) but i could not be sure so I requested a Copy from the original mold and brought it to a Several Jewelers and they said the same thing that the My Ring while perhaps slightly Lighter had been Stretched , Buffed and Hammered Out to excess and no longer Same Ring I had brought in . I Then went back to to Great American at there request as I had Left a 1 star review and They Could Not Understand Why ? They tried to tell me it was the Same ring and when i had it made from the Mold it was Smaller and I By Wearing it , it was worn down After 5 Years They Blamed Everyone Else and would Accept No Responsibility I was Polite and Left as It was my perception according to Them . No that was not the case as i brought it Back the the Original Jeweler and he saw the Difference so to make a Long Story short I have to have The Ring Remade . My Cost based on What they did will be over 600.00 . 70 I paid them for Bad Sizing and around 500.00 Dollars more to have the ring remade Based on Mold and Cost of Gold after I Sell the ring they Ruined for Scrap for about 700.00 Depending On what I can sell it for when My New replacement Ring is Made . Just Compare The Photos as well as My estimate from the original Jeweler who made The Ring to make this Right . Never Again They Could have at Least Reimbursed me for a Very Bad Sizing . Just Compare The Photos .