Nice place, wide variety on the menu. Food and service is very good.

Delicious French toast. The coffee was hot and the waitress was friendly. The restaurant was clean and modern. I would definitely come back.

NOW OPEN TO THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN WAITING!!!!! Absolutely AMAZING food!! Such awesome variety of food, true to the core coney island for sure! Wait staff and manager were so friendly and welcoming, everything that could be made from scratch was! Place was packed but comfortable. So glad to see a new place to eat in town!

Take your money and go right down the road to the Robins Nest!! For the same money, you’ll get a decent meal!! This place is WAY over priced for what you get! The food is less than mediocre!! Trust me! Don’t spend your money here! The Robins Nest is 50 times better for the same price!

Atmosphere!!! Couldnt eat today because the waitresses only seemed interested in arguing and fighting about who was "first". In their defense i wasnt waiting long but i wasnt interested in waiting for their drama to unfold. I was a regular for lunch, probably not now since i ordered and left. Sorry about the 2 coneys!! (Maybe next time not in front of the customers?)

Great small town breakfast/lunch restaurant. The service was great. The coneys were messy but tasty.

Stopped in for a quick brunch. Food was delicious, and served promptly even though they were busy and appeared to be a little short staffed. We always ask ourselves why we don't stop in more often.

Way over priced to me! Food is good but the prices are primo! Do not order coffee Starbucks cost less!

We eat here occasionally as it's close to home. The food is good but nothing unique or spectacular. Prices are 30-40% higher than comparable establishments. A family of three has to order carefully to eat breakfast for under $40 before tip. Oh, and don't forget cash - there is a surcharge for paying with card. It's surprising this place has survived as long as it has.

I have been to the Coney Island several times since they’ve been open and as always never a disappointment! Friendly staff, great food (especially the breakfast) , Plenty of coffee and I even caught an episode of the Golden girls on One of their few TVs they have in the diner. I’ve even seen them put cartoons on for the children. And the owners always make it a point to come out and say hi. 😊 I don’t live in Eaton Rapids but I always make it a point to stop there when I pass through.

Service was amazing. Everyone there obviously cares for their customers and all. However, I think their prices for food is RIDICULOUS. I know food cost has gone up, but common. For average diner food, I wouldn't expect to pay like I was going to a steakhouse. 😅

Food isn’t bad (tho quite overpriced) service is okay, but the rating would be much higher if I didn’t have to constantly swipe at flies/nats while eating my food .

My wife had their Coney Dog Special. She said it was the best one she ever had. I tried the Coney Sauce, It was so good. I ordered the biscuits and gravey special, and it was marvelous.