Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant image

Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant

Restaurant Pizza restaurant Italian restaurant

Family-run trattoria with pizza, including stuffed pies, plus subs, pasta dishes & Italian entrees. People often mention good, pizza, service, ordered, Italian, time, pasta, restaurant, order, great,


Address

1400 Walter Reed Rd #130, Fayetteville, NC 28304

Website

littleitalyfay.com

Contact

(910) 867-8700

Price rating

$$ $$

Rating on Google Maps

4.30 (1K reviews)

Open on Google Maps

Working Hours

  • Saturday: 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Sunday: (Easter), Closed, Holiday hours
  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Wednesday: 11 AM to 9 PM
  • Thursday: 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Friday: 11 AM to 10 PM

Featured Reviews


Frequently mentioned in reviews: good (14) pizza (14) service (12) ordered (12) Italian (11) time (11) pasta (11) restaurant (9) order (9) great (9)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.
  • 5/5 Laurent H. 1 year ago on Google
    Amazing food, authentic Italian! We went here with our dogs and it was take out only before 3:45 which was perfect for us! Would definitely visit again. We had the carbonara and the homemade lasagna. I would say the lasagna was better but both were yummy!
    5 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Elizabeth J. 2 years ago on Google
    We stopped in while traveling north from FL - totally forgetting it was Valentines Day. The restaurant was very busy & of course we had no reservation. The hostess advised us of the current wait (30 min) and menu changes for the evening. We agreed to wait and had some wine at the small bar. So Glad we waited because the food was FABULOUS! Courtney, our wait person was very attentive. We had a lovely Valentines dinner. All the staff were busy but friendly & smiling and greeted people as they arrived. It’s a very unassuming looking place in a strip mall but what a lovely surprise!
    2 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 4/5 Phlipper B. 6 months ago on Google
    The wife-unit and I have eaten here once previously and she's been here with coworkers a few times. She always spoke highly about the food. So we came for our second time together tonight. Wife had Seafood fra Diablo and rated it an 8/10. The presentation was quite impressive, also. So that's an 'above average' dish. I had the Chicken French, which is a first, for me. I have nothing to compare it to. I learned it's not really my jam, but I'm sure as Chicken French goes it's probably excellent. The side salad was pretty good. So many places serve it up with nothing more than iceberg lettuce and a cherry tomato thrown at it. LI serves a few cuces, pepperchinni, carrots, etc. And the ranch dressing is from a mix, not a squeeze bottle. Very nice. I did, however, find the mozzarella sticks a bit lacking. Whoever they order the frozen ones from does them quite differently from Hooters, Applebee's, et al. Thin breading, which I'm sure many prefer, and it's healthier. Just a different taste than I'm used to. Also gotta mention the shots ... I think they use a thimble for pouring house vodka shots. Kinda stingy. House vodka is like $2 per gallon but you'd think they were pouring Grey Goose. 😆 Like most places I guess. Service was very good. Our server (Theresa) was doubling as bartender so she was really hustling. Very knowledgeable, efficient, and personable ... and fast. 😄
    2 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 Ramon Y Torres A. 10 months ago on Google
    The worst pizza I have ever over paid for. I placed an order for a 16" cheese pizza with added pepperoni, garlic knots and hot wings. Asked for the wings and pizza to both be well done. The pizza arrived cold and plain, with no pepperoni. Super floppy and undercooked, with a sauce that is mediocre to give it a high compliment. The wings were ALSO undercooked as of they came from the freezer to a short lived time in some oven (maybe microwave) and tossed around some generic off the shelf sauce. The knots, seemed preheated just bathing in a puddle of disgusting oil and big chunks of undercooked-raw garlic. For a restaurant that has such high traffic, and over priced food, this was a terrible experience and if anyone is looking to get a bite of pizza, the best bet is a chain spot rather than this place. Overall? Garbage.
    2 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 3/5 Angel D. 1 year ago on Google
    The vibe was nice but the food was mid. Overall service was good, restaurant was clean, and the staff was very friendly. My bf thought his meal was very bland, but my pizza was okay!
    2 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 T C. 6 months ago on Google
    I went for my birthday and had the worst experience. Five minutes after we were seated the owner called our waiter outside to berate him. The waiter was doing a good job despite the interaction with his boss. We had appetizers and they were just ok but edible. My best friend and I ordered two pasta dishes I had the Mediterranean chicken (I added extra sundried tomato and artichoke hearts) and she had a chicken pasta appetizer. I took one bite of my food and was extremely disappointed the meal had no flavor. The only thing I could taste was the watered down white wine "sauce". I asked the waiter immediately if I could send that plate back and order something else. He spoke with the owner then returned and told me that I could order something else but I would have to pay for the dish that I didn't like. When I asked why the owner came from the back and began to fuss at me in front of other customers. He said that it was #1 seller and that no one ever returns his food. I tried to explain that it had no flavor. The waiter offered to take it to the back and add more seasoning. I declined of course. I informed him that I would not being paying for a nasty dish but I understand that I had added extra veggies and I would pay for them. My friend tried her pasta and it had no flavor as well. She saw what I had just went through and just opted to take her food home and give it to her dog. I ended up paying $36 and leaving hungry. I was thoroughly disappointed i the food, and saddened by the owners reaction to a dissatisfied customer.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Nat 2 years ago on Google
    Food was delicious and prompt. My husband cleaned his plate and he never finishes his food in one sitting. He also never eats desserts but I was forced to share mine that night. Lol. Waiter was awesome, friendly, and attentive. Says he’s from New York so that’s a surprise. Lol. Jk. Anyway, can’t wait to go back there again! ❤️
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 2/5 Justin C. 6 months ago on Google
    I have been a regular to this place for about a year now, ever since a good friend recommended it. We have a large family so we always would order the family platters they have available, one spaghetti and one lasagna. Food has always been exceptional, however; once we attempted to dine-in for the first time, our experience changed. After our orders was placed, our menus were collected and drinks were passed out to us and our kids. We ordered our usual as well as two other entree's. The waitress returned minutes later to let us know that she was informed that they could only do family platters to-go, per her management instructions. Moreover, she explained that we had to order 7 individual meals rather than the family platter because "it would take too long to cook." When in actuality, it has never took more than 25 minutes for two family platters when I order them to-go. Not to mention that is same amount of food, ordered together or separately. I would know, I order from here at least twice a month. All in all, we will find decent Italian food elsewhere from now on.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Ninet G. 1 year ago on Google
    When we are anywhere near Fayetteville North Carolina we make a trip to Little Italy. This restaurant is in a nondescript strip mall… But do not let that fool you! We have never had a bad or even mediocre meal here. We’ve tried a lot of things on the menu that were great but my favorite is the Mediterranean Chicken. Emily was our waitress and as we ended our meal we found out she had only been there for a few weeks… But she was wonderful! Loved her smile, her cheery attitude, and of course her service. See you on our next trip back through Fayetteville!
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Lars B. 1 year ago on Google
    Nicely decorated place in an Italian theme with real candles and flowers throughout. Our server Sam was great. She brought us warm rolls with herb-infused olive oil while we waited for entrees. We got penne with salmon and chicken marsala, both were delicious and the pasta was cooked to perfection. Portions were good sized so we had leftovers. Fair prices, great food and great service - we'll be back when we're in the area again.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 jason sizzle t. 1 year ago on Google
    The food was amazing Andrea was my our server she was amazing I will definitely come back to this restaurant!!
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 Jessica T. 1 year ago on Google
    Went for dinner and my husband ordered a “special” which was some kind of ribeye with shrimp. Upon tasting it, the steak was burnt with thick char pieces. We typically never complain nor leave reviews when they are not good. However, when we told our waiter, he immediately told us he would speak with the manager. We waited and the waiter came back saying the manager said it could be re-made. We never saw him until we requested to speak to him. He was not happy to come to our table and said if the steak was re-made it would taste the same because he cooks it on the grill and not on some kind of griddle, so that wasn’t an option. There is a difference, however, and burnt is not the same as charbroiled just like a smoke taste is not the same as overcooked. It was not a good steak at all, and his customer service skills were very poor. Sergio, our waiter handled it amazingly and got a great tip. The manager, Joe G., will never get our business again.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Dee W. 1 year ago on Google
    Ate dinner here tonight. Food was excellent— the homemade lasagna and Chicken Marsala were huge portions. We ordered the garlic knots—were hot to the table with a garlic buttery flavor that our taste buds smiled at! Will be back real soon!
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Victor R. 2 years ago on Google
    Today was my first time in this place and wao wao the best Italian restaurant I ever been, and Joe was amazing very kind guy and the chef deserve a bonus or something cuz that food was freaking good.. my wife and I loved it, we as Latino we are very demanding when it’s comes to food, definitely recommended …
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 4/5 SJ D. 2 years ago on Google
    Awesome experience! It was nice to eat at an establishment that cares about cleanliness, courtesy and customer service. This was our first time eating here. We were greeted as soon as we stepped in. The servers were attentive and answered our questions. The food was great! It's sad to say that I don't get this too often at other places. Will definitely return and spread the word.

  • 3/5 Angel G. 1 year ago on Google
    When I came a year ago it was a 6/5 star experience. The service, food, cleanliness and whole experience was amazing. When I came back again recently I feel like the service wasn’t as enthused and the food lost its passion and was instead rushed. The waiter only checked on us once while other tables got checked about 5 times

  • 5/5 Jesse H. 6 months ago on Google
    I absolutely loved this place, I loved the atmosphere as it what I needed on that rainy day. The food was delicious, but the two at the cash register were going back and forth with each about who's name was put in for my order. The lady was more persistent as she kept saying she didn't know how he did that? Ring me up under her name. Small issue but it shouldn't have been done in front of me. Overall.....PLEASE go check this place out you will NOT be disappointed.

  • 5/5 nick 6 months ago on Google
    Food is really good and fresh. Service is good. Decor is warm and welcoming.

  • 5/5 Danny M. 1 year ago on Google
    Wow! Is the best way to start this post. Me and my wife are from Virginia traveling through and we stopped at this beautiful restaurant. The atmosphere and beautiful decorations really make you feel like you are somewhere else other than fayetteville. We had there seafood pasta and ordered a pizza as well and let me tell you this was the best meal we have ever had and that is saying something because we have tried over thousand different Italian restaurants in our lifetime. The owner spoke Italian and even poured our first glass of wine before heading back in the kitchen to cook our meals. There's no other place that made us just feel at home! If your looking for a authentic Italian restaurant then look no further! Give it a try you won't be disappointed!

  • 5/5 Joseph L. 2 years ago on Google
    This place was awesome. We were heading north on I 95 and it was worth the side trip. Good traditional Italian pastas pizzas steaks. I had chicken Parmesan wonderful my wife had eggplant rollitinis also excellent. Two glasses of Chianti and excellent service made it memorable. Will definitely come back!

  • 5/5 Christopher B. 11 months ago on Google
    I love this place. My wife is 2nd generation Italian and her grandmother made the best Italian food. We are from the North East, and this is in the top 5 restaurants I've been to. From the fish to the pasta to the sandwiches, you won't have a bad meal here. When they have flounder I highly recommend it. Last time I was in I got the meatball sub and it was really good.

  • 1/5 proteauxtype 10 months ago on Google
    Bruschetta & fried mushrooms are great. Customer service not so much. Last time I was here, I was never greeted even though people saw me and the sign said to wait to be seated. Took it upon myself to never came back. Came back with my mother (a loyal customer) upon her wishes and ordered the special. The chicken was slimy, the sauce was giving Campbell Cream of Chicken, and the mushrooms are canned. I asked to switch out the meal and was told I’d have to pay for both if I ordered. At this point - it’s feeling like there is no desire to satisfy the customer. Why come ask if I like everything if my honest answer will leave me high & dry? Even an apology from a higher up would be nice. Third time is not a charm for me. I won’t be back & neither will my family.

  • 5/5 James B. 9 months ago on Google
    I hadn't been here in a long while. The food is really delicious! I like each & every thing I've eaten or drank. There are things on the menu you will not find any place else nearby. The service is also good. Besides the really good food, they also stay open an hour longer then alot of other restaurants in this area. I highly recommend anyone with taste buds to give this place a try. You'll be back! 🍅🍞🍷🍕🧄🍤🥗🦪🍄🥖🍰

  • 3/5 KungFuAsianYea 10 months ago on Google
    Haven’t ordered here in a while. Service was okay. We had ordered a double pepperoni pizza, and if this is a double pepperoni pizza, I’d hate to see a regular one. We also ordered the Joe’s Wings; too saucey, not spicy enough, no ranch or dips included. The pizza also was meh. Honestly, we’d prefer Elizabeth’s Pizza or Taste of New York.

  • 1/5 Debbie H. 2 years ago on Google
    Worst experience ever! Ordered for pickup almost $400. 1. Sauce taste like it came from a can 2. Ordered lasagna, chicken parmigiana, salad, garlic knots & drinks and dessert. To the turn of $16 per person. When we got back with food there was no pasta with chicken parmigiana. 3. Called to let them know no pasta with chicken parmigiana. They proceeded to argue and tell us the lasagna was the pasta 4. Owner came on very rude no credit if I wanted to drive 30 minutes back he would make me pasta 5. Never would I recommend this place EVER!

  • 5/5 Robert W. 1 year ago on Google
    First time going there. Stopped by and ordered take out. Everyone was friendly. Got fried calamari and three different pasta dishes for us to try.. everything was great. Will go dine in next time.

  • 5/5 Allison C. 3 years ago on Google
    I am visiting from out of town and i always need to eat pizza anywhere I go. The food is fantastic! The pizza has that New York slice feel with a crispy crust and the dough tastes homemade. Fresh mozzarella makes it supreme!!! The eggplant parm is delicious. Elizabeth waited on us and was quick, friendly, polite and everything you want when you dine out. Excellent service, food, prices and an amazing experience! Ask for Elizabeth-she will take great care of you!

  • 5/5 Sarah L. 1 year ago on Google
    I love this place! Very delicious Italian pizza and delicious drinks. Other than pizza we only had the bruschetta so far which was also yummy! The atmosphere in this restaurant is so nice. It’s not too loud in there - perfect for conversations and a relaxed time with friends and family.

  • 5/5 Michael 1 year ago on Google
    Visiting for business and stopped in to have dinner for two. Excellent cuisine in a quaint little venue. Lobster Ravioli and Eggplant Parmesan were a delight. Cream sauce on the lobster ravioli was perfect texture and consistency. Montebello!

  • 5/5 Mindy L. 1 year ago on Google
    Good food and service. A hidden little gem in Fayetteville, NC.


Call (910) 867-8700 Open on Google Maps

Amenities


  • Parking
    • ✓️ Free parking lot
    • ✓️ Plenty of parking
  • Payments
    • ✓️ Debit cards
    • ✓️ Credit cards
    • ✓️ NFC mobile payments
  • Offerings
    • ✓️ Beer
    • ✓️ Wine
    • ✓️ Coffee
    • ✓️ Alcohol
    • ✓️ Spirits
    • ✓️ Cocktails
    • ✓️ Quick bite
    • ✓️ Comfort food
    • ✓️ Small plates
    • ✓️ Vegan options
    • ✓️ Healthy options
    • ✓️ Vegetarian options
  • Popular for
    • ✓️ Lunch
    • ✓️ Dinner
    • ✓️ Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible toilet
    • ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Dining options
    • ✓️ Lunch
    • ✓️ Dinner
    • ✓️ Dessert
    • ✓️ Seating
    • ✓️ Catering
  • Service options
    • ✓️ Dine-in
    • ✓️ Delivery
    • ✓️ Takeaway
    • ✓️ Kerbside pickup
    • ✓️ Outdoor seating

Trends



Last updated:

Similar Restaurants nearby

Texas Roadhouse image
1
Texas Roadhouse
Steak house
Lively chain steakhouse serving American fare with a Southwestern spin amid Texas-themed decor.
$$ $$
4.40 (6.3K reviews)
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant image
2
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads.
$$ $$
4.10 (4.6K reviews)
Chick-fil-A image
3
Chick-fil-A
Fast food restaurant
Fast-food chain serving chicken sandwiches & nuggets along with salads & sides.
$ $$$
4.50 (4.4K reviews)
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen image
4
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Traditional American restaurant
Family-friendly chain serving American comfort food with a Texas twist, plus cocktails.
$$ $$
4.10 (4.2K reviews)
Gocha's Breakfast Bar image
5
Gocha's Breakfast Bar
Restaurant
😐 I have been wanting to go here for a while. Finally went and was not impressed. We waited for over an hour. I assume "the manager" was very good at communicating that there would be a delay and that they would get us in ASAP. I ordered the salmon croquettes, they were more like salmon balls. Very sm...
$$ $$
4.80 (4.2K reviews)
Last updated:
()