Peter Pan Diner hits!!!! Crazy grilled cheeses, ONION RINGS, and great service. Also, incredible playlist on a late summer Sunday night.

Excellent Diner, Delicious food and Spectacular service. Highly recommend!! Roxy is one of their best waitresses.

One of the best diners on the Island. I have been dining here for over 15 years. There are lots of regular customers. Favorites: Belgian waffle with fruit salad, matzoh ball soup, turkey bacon Runners up: chicken noodle soup, omelettes Staff is friendly and professional. Highly recommend

Way better than your average diner. Selection of dishes was almost overwhelming with some non-run-of-the-mill selections. The food was also really good. Each person in my family completely cleaned the plate. We will come back here when in the area

Great apple cinnamon pancakes. My husband loved the Greek omelet. Coffee was very hot. Just the way I like it. Definitely going back again!

An all time favorite of mine as they transport me back to my childhood with their Chocolate Chip/Peanut butter chip Pancakes which are amazing. Every other dish I’ve gotten here has been just as good. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the prices are reasonable.

Very good, I always saw many vehicles outside and it made me curious. The experience was really very good.

Came here for dinner on New Year’s Day!! What a great staff and great way to ring in the new year. We especially appreciated our waitress, Shari, who warmed our cold hands with warm mugs. She was inviting and friendly and very attentive to our dining needs. Wonderful vibe at Peter Pan Diner!! And food was amazing too…

Always fast delivery! Everything delicious. The French dip sandwich w/aujus and their burgers are fantastic! Varierty of fries to choose from. When you order from their website they give great discount plus reward points. Customer service and manager are always awesome!

It's one of my favorite restaurants on the island! Great food, reasonable pricing for the amount you get! 10/10

No reservations accepted - We had a group of 8 and there was a 20 minute wait to get in. Parking in their lot - spaces are tight. His & Her restrooms. They have tables, booths & High chairs. Everyone was nice & friendly from servers to management. We ordered coffee, OJ, Apple juice, Pepsi, various omelets, burgers, sandwiches with dip, London broil steaks & various fries - all were delicious. Kid friendly too.

This place has been here for as long as I can remember. Possibly the best diner burger on Long Island, and I don't think anywhere has more diners than Long Island. Great place to head to after a long night out. I'd give it 5 stars but parking is not easy.

Love their Hamburgers! Good selection with moderate prices. Great place for eating in, take out or delivery Extremely friendly owners and personnel. My favorite restaurant in Bay Shore since early eighties.

This place is amazing! The food is absolutely delicious and the customer service is great! It is worth every penny they even gave us rice pudding and we didn’t even order it! I highly recommend eating here !

Petter Pan Diner was a much more than pleasant surprise. First off that they were open for inside dining was great. Next, the interior was immaculate the decor warm & welcoming & the staff very friendly & top of their game in serving. Now the food? Oh man the food! Both my wife & I had burger deluxe platters. I got mine with sauteed onions added to the burger...YUM. Everything was cooked to perfection, the burger just right aaaand juicy. The sweet potato fries, the onion rings crispy on the outside & delicious on the inside! Even the Cole Slaw & pickle were super fresh & delicious. My wife ordered a slice of Lemon Meringue & I ordered the Chocolate Cream pie. We both were over the moon how fantastic these.two desserts were! When we left we were both thoroughly full & very happy! This diner really delivered two completely wonderful, lip smacking good meals. Go visit them!

Delicious waffles and chocolate chip pancakes. The ice coffee was also very good. The staff is so friendly!. Lots of parking !

Best diner on Long Island! Great service great food.

Great comfort food..always fresh...Nicky and Peter are always there to greet you with a smile ..highly recommend

Food was really delicious. Service was great ! Nice inviting atmosphere. Love the birthday celebration style. Overall was a nice place to sit and enjoy my meal .

Never order the liquor. First, let me say the food is wonderful. The servers are quite kind. But again, DON'T ORDER THE LIQUOR. I asked for an Old Fashioned at first; I saw they had a collection of whiskey, so I figured it wouldn't be that big of an ask. Unfortunately, neither the server nor whoever they had working behind the counter seemed to know very much about making drinks. So instead I just ordered a Jack & Coke. $12.95 for a freaking Jack & Coke. That's insane! They'd make back the bottle in 3 drinks! Jack Daniels is NOT pricey. I've paid less for elevated cocktails in the city. And had they given me a good cocktail, I would've said that was a fair price. But no, they gave me a splash of jack with a heavy dose of soda. That's $8 max, not $12.95. I should've known better than to order it when I didn't see the liquor menu, I guess. Aside from that, the food is some of the best on the Island and the service is phenomenal. Tip 'em well, they deserve it.

Wouldn't go back to this diner anymore! While eating a busboy is sweeping the rug by our table. I proceeded to tell him I didn't appreciate him cleaning the floor while we were still eating. While paying I told the older gentleman at the register and he proceeds to tell me that if the dining room wasn't cleaned he'd get complaints. No customer service etiquette at all! Not even I'm sorry or I understand and it won't happen again. This place doesn't get my hard earned money anymore!!!!!!

This diner has been here for years! This is a beautiful and immaculately clean diner. All staff is great. The food is delicious. No matter what you ask for. This is a win win for us. Food portions are huge. Desserts are to die for. We have been coming here for over 20 yrs.

The food is very good, there is a wait of 15 -20 min . The down side the menu has no pictures :(

What a surprise find!! You can pass it by easily if you have never been there before. Food outstanding selection. Staff upbeat and funny. Atmosphere-- all decked out for Halloween AND very clean. Looking forward to returning!!

Peter Pan diner is the best diner in Long Island!!! My family and I always go here and enjoy it every single time!! Service is great every single server is wonderful! Food is delicious and always comes out hot!! Only thing bad about Peter Pan is the parking lot is kind of small

I've been away from Long Island for a year. It was so good to visit and eat great food! Also nice to see Peter! My late husband and I started eating here in the 6o's. Always a good experience!

I absolutely love this place. The staff is awesome and love to chat with customers. The food portions are huge and their desserts are out of this world. If you never been here, give it a try, you won't be disappointed.

Nice place clean good food and a little something for e everyone. The service was fast and polite. I try to stop any chance I get and you should also reasonably priced menu

YUM! I love a great diner. The burger was simple and delicious, cooked perfectly. I love jazzing up the side of fries and making them ✨disco✨ with melted mozzarella and gravy, and it was great! The onion rings are great too. I've heard the sweet potato fries are amazing, so I'll have to get those next time. Plus, the free Famous Amos cookies at the front of the diner are a nice added touch. Excited to come back!

Love the place. Always feel as if something can be better but stull a place I love going back to

Waitress and hostess were very warm, courteous and professional. They even remembered my Mom (we just buried her the day before) who would come a bit with my sister. Love the burgers there, pickles, fries with gravy, dessert, everything! Yum! Highly recommended!

A very nice simple breakfast that was served very quickly! This service is great, and the atmosphere is nice.

Great food! Great service! Great experience everytime! Have been coming here for at least 30 years!

Everything was delicious. The portion sizes for breakfast were filling, not too big, not too small. Worth the price. Mid-range pricing. Not expensive at all but not super cheap. Waitress was friendly but not intrusive. I went with my dad and he is grumpy before coffee in the morning and even he liked the staff. He did complain that that he drank too much coffee. They were very great with keeping the hot delicious coffee coming. The place was nicely populated, not crowded but not empty either. There is ample parking for customers. The women's bathroom had 2 stalls, one of them was accessible. The wait time for a moderately busy time was very short. Our food was ordered and done in like 10-15 minutes. The menu had a much larger variety then I am used to from American style diners.

This place looks closed. Graffiti on the exterior. Plywood on the sign. It is a little tired and dingy. If you enjoy frozen Costco food cooked by Hondurans be my guest. You can tell nothing is fresh. The place could use a facelift

Great spot for breakfast, their pancakes and omelets are delicious! They also have a great selection of cakes and baked goods.

This diner has been around for over 35 yrs. The food is great. The staff is wonderful. I have been going there since I moved to Long Island. You can eat whatever you want, when you want it. Decorations for holidays are always appropriate. Love it!

Sharon is literally one of the best waitresses I’ve ever had and I’m so excited when she is my server. She is excellent and so is this diner. Great food and great service.

I went to the Peter Pan Diner on 8/27/2022. I have always enjoyed the food and service at this diner. I ordered The New Champ sandwich and everything was great. Shortly after receiving my food, the owner came to my table with another The New Champ sandwich. He told me he saw the sandwich as it was being delivered to my table and he noticed the sandwich was not big enough, so he brought me another sandwich to take home. I had no problem with the first sandwich, but it did not measure up to the standards of the owner. What a surprise! Kindness is always a wonderful thing.

Five course dinner for $24.99 each .A great deal in these tough economic times. Food always tastes great. I've been coming to Peter pan throughout the pandemic and have always been warmly greeted by the owner. Highly recommend..

Great food and plenty of it. Our waitress was excellent and anticipated all our needs. The Chicken Oreganato was delish. I had chicken noodle soup with plenty of fresh chicken. Also baked sliced potatoes and broccoli. Then dessert! We had a bread basket, chick pea salad and beet salad. All for $25.

Great place to go eat with the family. The food is delicious

We love Peter Pan diner. The food and service is always great and it comes with a smile. It is not inexpensive but it worth the money every once in a while. The only issue is the parking lot is very tight.

the food is good reasonably priced and the staff was very courteous environment is very comfortable