Very mediocre Key Lime pie! We checked Google and saw good reviews but it’s so disappointing. We tried a few bites and threw it in the garbage. I wouldn’t recommend it to anyone!!! And to respond to the owner’s response: It may be that not many people enjoy Key lime pie but I do!! I know what great Key Lime pie tastes like. The crust should be thicker and have a more complex taste, and the filling should be creamier and more citrusy. Your Key Lime pie tastes overwhelmingly like sugar, with very little tart lime flavor. Sadly, it’s mediocre and forgettable.

The have key lime pie on a stick with chocolate, or individual slices. If you have a lot of people buying the whole pie will save you some money. Whole oies are frozen or refrigerated. I bought the whole pie and biked it back to the hotel to put in our fridge. It was perfect the next day. Love all the items you can buy in the shop as well, or miscellaneous snacks. Nice seating inside or out.

A must try Keys Lime Pie!!! 🥧 This version is delicious. The best I've tried so far. A balanced amount of sugar and the pleasant sour lime taste. Staff is nice and prices are average. The bakery sells many unthinkable products with Key Lime Pie flavor. 🤔 For the joy of tourists!!! Two tables and a couple of benches are the only options for those who want to enjoy tasting the pie seated on the spot hoping these aren't already busy. 🔝

Decent key lime pie and trust me I eat this every chance I get anywhere I go. This place was highly rated and wasn’t a disappointment, but wasn’t the best. I expect better for the birthplace of key lime pie.

A bit too sweet for me, and not a fan of the crust at all. They also have their hours until 11 pm, but then when I got there at 9:45 they had a sign they close at 9… the lady still got me a piece, which is much appreciated !

Must stop for key lime on a stick dipped in chocolate. The chocolate is of high quality. Every pie is made and baked in house. Definitely worth stopping by.

The BEST Key Lime Pie shop in Key West. Also the only one that makes their own pies. You can sit and watch them make pies while you eat a delicious slice. Very clean atmosphere and friendly staff. Highly recommended!!

Best pie in Key West of the three we tried. Got an original whole pie. Others were sweet (almost cloyingly) but this one was tart. Whip cream, no merengue. Really tasty crust. Firm pie and crust - not soggy at all. They have whole pies, slices,ice cream, and key lime candies and souvenirs. Easy walk from Duvall Street and our hotel in Old Town.

I am not a fan of Key Lime Pie (I know, shameful as a Florida native), but everyone i was with that had a slice said it was fabulous. And the people in the shop are incredibly friendly. A definite must do when in the Keys.

The very best key lime pie I ever had. Amazing place to get souvenirs for key west. I would say $5+ a slice is a bit pricey

Extremely disappointing because of the attention. The women in the cashier was extremely rude, she completely disrespected us and when we asked for forks to eat the keylime, she literally threw them at us. The guy preparing the coffees was kind, but this women ruined the whole experience. There’s also only one table for sitting, so definitely go to another place

EXCELLENT… What can I say? They make a great piece of key lime pie… Great flavor and value. I tried others and they didn’t compare!

Cute spot, clean, key lime pie was average. I’m a Florida native and had high hopes for it. Got a slice, the crust was thin, filling was alright but nothing special.

Fresh dessert of Key lime pie, cheesecake and coconut cream pie all around $5.95 a slice or $24 a whole pie. Lots of tourist trap trinkets and souvenirs. We came for the KLP as we enjoy to indulge. It is a bit on the premium side, however made on site and tangy delicious. I was considering bringing back some key lime juice in a bottle but decided against it as it is not as easy and did not feel like checking a bag for my flight. Worth the stop. Happy calories!

What can I say, I ate Key Lime Pie in Key West! A bucket list check off for me! This bakery has 2 sides to it, 1 side that prepares the Key Lime Pie, and the other where you order, and a gift shop. Well worth the drive, and so worth the yummy goodness of the key lime pie. Before my trip, I googled places that served Key Lime Pie, and this bakery was obe of them, We went here because i was atteacted to the pictures of the store front I saw online. So worth the drive. 10 stars**********

Nice little bakery and souvenir shop by Greene street, $5.99 for a slice of pie. The shop has other items sold like key lime taffy, everything key lime, shirts, magnets, drinks and ice cream.

It was a bit too sweet but it has tasty and rich cream and good lime flavor. If you come to key west, you definitely want to try it!!,

Got a coconut lime pie and regular lime pie, each around $6. Both are great I preferred the coconut one It's also a shop where you can stop by to buy small key lime chocolate or sauce gifts.

Guided by the good reviews we took our chance with this place as there are so many options for Key Lime pie in this town. We went for the whole pie and the staff suggested that we take a frozen one as we weren't going to eat it right away. Well we just had out first slice and it didn't disappoint. Very good and recommended!

Yum! Never liked key lime as a kid so haven't had in decades. Add chocolate to it and it was amazing. Tasted like a creamy mousse covered in chocolate with that crust.... honestly it was amazing and before we leave this Airbnb a couple doors down from it we will be getting one more.... fun interacting with friendly employee... He suggested the mini pie as well so we will be having it tomorrow... definitely stop here!!! Its apparently a Key West must :). And with good reason... cool and beachy light flavors