I come to KW about 6-7 times/year. I dine at Martin’s at least 2 times a year. A friend and I had dinner at Martin’s tonight and, as usual, it was excellent. I ordered the Beef Wellington; it was, indeed, well-ingrown… perfect. My friend had the Grouper Meunière to which he gave me a thumb up upon taking a first bite. As for the service, our server Mark was very attentive, even funny, and prompt. Everything was superb.

Very nice & friendly staff. OK food. I didn’t like to complain, but noticed that both water and cocktail glasses need to be washed & cleaned properly. I had on my martini glass a pink glossy lipstick, (with a lip mark on the side) which was not mine as I wasn’t wearing any and didn’t even take a sip yet.( photo attached) Also, RaspberryTini tastes like kids syrup, VERY sweet, but not in a good way. Staff who works there are nice & I am sorry to say this, but I wouldn’t come in again and I wanted so much to like this restaurant since it looks very modern on the outside and full of people.

Food here is amazing ! Blake was our server and he did a phenomenal job! He was very attentive and made sure our table was squeaky clean! He also made me drink that was very delicious ! The lamb and the shrimp Alfredo was mouth watering and the apple strudels dessert was delicious! My only complaint was a they had an issue with the outside power and so the fan and the lights on one side were out however we did move seats to be closer to a fan and that definitely changed the experience. They accommodated us in every way. 10/10

Have been to Martin's so many times and was always happy with everything until my last visit... Went with 2 girlfriends on Wednesday for a happy hour and was soooooo disappointed with the service, I couldn't even believe that was happening but looks like if the server doesn't think that you belong to that place he's gonna make some mean comments and make the whole table feel uncomfortable... The guy was trying to get rid of us so hard. We still left tips but way more less than I would usually for a happy hour, soooo disappointed, would not recommend it anymore and would rather choose another place to eat, even though the martinis and food are always good there. P. S. If the manager cares I'd be happy to tell what exactly happened, don't wanna put names here. Thanks!

This is our favorite restaurant for dinner in Key West. I love the Tapas dishes - usually I just make a meal of them but this time we got just one and I got the night's special which was Grouper Meunière. My wife always gets the Yellowtail. Great service.

We live in Tampa Bay and are visiting Key West. Last night (6-2-23) we ate at Martin’s. The food was absolutely divine! We ordered a bottle of Prosecco and that was delicious as well. Our waiter was excellent, wish I could remember his name..he was a tall man, very very informative and nice. My only complaint is the bartender. We were a few minutes early for our reservation so we waited by the host stand for literally 4 minutes while our table was being prepared. I caught her looking at me and then making faces and cracking up with another employee, repeatedly. I caught her doing this, we locked eyes and she had no care that I saw this happening. It was extreme uncomfortable and she would be my only hesitation about returning. Sad, and that’s why I took points off for atmosphere.

My wife and I celebrated our 15 year anniversary at Martin's and we both enjoyed it. They didn't have any ginger beer or ginger ale (I asked for a Moscow Mule) so I just asked the staff to make something similar, and I wasn't dissapointed. I had the Grouper, my wife had the lobster, and we split the vegetables. The vegetables were pretty plain so I don't think I'd order those again, but everything else was good. A bit pricey here, but for special occasions, I'd recommend it.

It's an absolute pleasure! The best food on the island! Service was spectacular, and the happy hour was wonderful. Half price martinis were nothing short of top shelf.

Absolutely amazing service you would think every employee is a part owner , just great staff, the food was amazing as well ! I would say In the top 5 best fine dining in key west ! If you enjoy fine hand prepared meals you must check this out !

Hands down our best dining experience in Key West. Sat at the bar for happy hour. Be sure to arrive before the 4pm opening! Waiting in line was well worth it. Everything we had was outstanding! Bartender was kind enough to make me a mocktail since I’m pregnant. Can’t wait to come back and enjoy the martinis!!

Get there 10-20 minutes early and wait on line. Especially on the weekends. The tables fill up fast and the service works hard to handle the influx of drink and food orders. Once the tables are full, customers will be turned away. Doesn't seam like you can reserve a seat before 6pm. Both food and drink are super consistent. We been here once a week and the experience is always great. The pork is the biggest dish, the lamb is perfect, the tuna is pretty, and the brie is like desert. I'm looking forward to some crab cakes next time. We usually do about 6 apps 4 drinks and it's an 80.00 tab before tip.

Stopped here for dinner after a sunset and didn’t really know what to expect. Oh man, this had to be the best food by far on our long weekend on the island. When I saw the jager schnitzel I had to order it, just make sure you’re hungry cause it’s a good portion. My wife ordered the grouper schnitzel and that was another wonderful dish. The burrata, rosemary potatoes, asparagus, everything was fabulous. Our waiter Mark was all over the place and we never felt like he disappeared. He was on it. I would highly recommend and will be revisiting here in my next visit. Please stop by and try. You will not be sorry.

Loved this place. We ate a the patio it was pretty cozy in there. The service was good. The menu was excellent, nice to see a menu with a variety of food. And their martinis were amazing. I must go back in my next trip to Key West.

The meals were very good. I had the lobster and my wife had the filet, they were perfect. The Key West Sunset Martini, is highly recommended. I also had the snitzel for an appetizer and it was very crispy and tasted wonderful.

Our waiter made the evening perfect. Was so much fun to listen to him address each of his tables, telling the story of the history of the food prepared there. He was very attentive. We enjoyed many tapas / entrees / and of course key lime creme brulee. The lamb shop tapas was our favorite! The lobster risotto was so very tasty. Would definetly go again!

Impressive happy hour prices on drinks and tapas. The keys sunset drink was great. The scallops had aesthetic plating and were very tasty.

We were told by a local that it was the best restaurant in town and she was right. Delicious food, specially the lobster risotto. Service is the best we had during our stay in the US. A lovely experience and definitely will repeat in future visits to Key West

Your food choice and menu is amazing best part of experience. Your waiter was a bit snooty but the hostess made up for it. Also I saw a huge cockroach but it was outside at night in Key West in your outside eating area so what can you expect Also I put on reservation it was for birthday and snooty waiter did not even ask if we wanted to do something special for this. Overall everyone was nice and looked like they were trying.

One of the best happy hour I’ve ever try! Amazing food and great staff make the experience fantastic! Gaston was on top of everything the hole dinner. A must in KW!

Love the happy hour. Great food at great prices.

The drinks were good. The ribeye was super bland. Hardly any flavor at all. The lobster risotto tasted ok, but as far as I’m concerned it wasn’t risotto. It was more like rice with cheese. Not like any risotto I’ve had, including in Italy. The beef Wellington was good though the meat was not as tender as it should have been. The highlight of the evening was the mousse. It was perfect. Super delicious. I was disappointed, but I was hungry so I ate everything and didn’t send anything back because they were about to close. Otherwise the risotto definitely would have gone back.

Definitely not the younger atmosphere. Food was mid but did the job. We had a party of 6 so we tried a variety of food. The steak was cooked to perfection. Mash potatoes as a side was amazing! The lamb was tender. I specifically ate the shrimp Alfredo and the shrimp to the sauce was perfect! The yellowtail fish was fishy to me and had a scale, however the person who ordered it, liked it and ate all of it. My only negatives were a fly in the dining room, we shouldn’t be swatting away bugs from our food and drinks.

The food was absolutely amazing. Drinks were spot on. The waiter was patient, polite and attentive. Had the bone in rib eye. It was worth every penny! My sister in law had the bolognase sauce and pasta. It was my birthday and brought this out. It was so good.

This place was simply amazing! We ordered tapas for our dinner. We had driven 11 hours, so we wanted to eat, shower & sleep! I got the lamb chops & a salad. Oh, and a chocolatetini! Yum! My BFF got the fettuccine with vegetables which was different. Blake was our server, and his service was perfect! Our bills didn't seem high for what we got! I would eat there every day if I could! Highly recommend!