Absolutely delicious! My fiancee and I ordered the extra large pepperoni pizza, and we were surprised at just how big it was. Such a great value for the money. Some people complain about there not being enough sauce, but we thought it was the perfect amount. The cheese was plentiful, and the crust was the perfect texture. It was overall a wonderful meal. We will definitely order again. I'm not from around here, and other places I've been to don't compare. Kudos!!!

Placed a simple order on the app. Delivery was fine but came in completely wrong. My calzone didn’t even have any cheese on it. My pasta barely had enough pasta in it to cover the bowl. Called and asked for it to be made right and was told I can pay more money to have my order fixed. Absolutely not what an already paying customer wants to hear. Currently not recommending.

I just wanted to personally THANK the employees who braved the weather today to open the shop and go far above and beyond. My grandparents have had 0 power since last night, we wanted to get them a hot meal to snack on until power comes back on(no telling when that’ll be) When my husband called the shop(basically THEE ONLY PLACE OPEN IN FERRY) they said “i’m so sorry but our delivery is limited and to pick up it’s about an hour waiting time. So we order, we wait… while sitting inside the shop the phone ORDERS WERE CONSTANT. Some cussing out employees, hanging up on them, asking for items they are unable to do at the time because of such high volume they limited the menu to basics and the pan fried pizza only. (Understandable to MOST) While waiting we saw employees going above and beyond, trying to keep a sense of humor as they’re literally getting BURIED in orders. Running into each other, laughing, slinging pizzas in and out of the ovens, it was SO HOT inside that building that they were stepping outside just to catch a cold breeze on their sweaty faces. I PERSONALLY want to say THANK YOU. Not only did my grandparents get a hot meal, they got something made with love that they can eat until the power is restored and THAT means more than you know. Thank you from all of us you so unselfishly served tonight! ❤️

I ordered 3 subs on Dec 1 at 7pm my total was 27.97 the subs where 6 inc I ordered 12 inc when I call the manager was very rude told me that's the way they come you don't like it go somewhere else the rudeness of the so called manager in martinsferry is rude and nasty I have been going there for years never had this problem

Food is great, employees are super nice we you come in. No complaints!

Called the store in Wheeling, they were rude and said they wouldn't deliver to the island and to call the store in Martin's Ferry.. Very very glad they directed us there!! Pizza and bread sticks were amazing!! Service was great and everyone was friendly!! I'm a pizza fanatic and they definitely deserve 5 stars.. My husband and I will definitely be ordering from her again.. Thank you .

A must stop when I come in to town! Always delicious! Was really excited that they now sell pasta sauce!

Normally an awesome experience. Had minor hiccups. The buffalo fries were undercooked and the sauce wasn't buffalo, it was just Frank's. The pepperoni roll was just very boring. I made my own calzone with capicola, mushroom, and kalamata olives with the Provo/mozz blend. The calzone was honestly the best I've ever had. It's quite small compared to what it used to be. Shrinkflation is real.

I love the boneless bbq chicken bites. I like the sauce but, just needs to be a little sweeter.

Food is great! But the delivery times are so slow!!

I Love Defelice Pizza, Their Steak Salad and Pizza is awesome, Great Job and Food. I have know the Owners for a long time, God Bless & keep up the great work

Love their food. Only complaint is they seem to use a lot of sauce, which I order "Lite sauce" and it corrects my issues. Great owner and workers!!!

Absolutely love this pizza shop. Their pizza is amazing. In my opinion the best in Martins Ferry.

Ordered 13 large pizzas for employee luncheon. It was delivered exactly on time and the pizza was awesome! Highly recommend.

Placed my order, for a large pepperoni pizza and a small garden salad with cheese. I was told it would take 60 minutes. I didn't receive my food until 2 hours later. Pizza was luke warm and I didn't get my extra dressing for my salad nor was there any cheese it was just lettuce and tomatoes. It was at martins ferry oh and I did contact them but only to be told they were busy and it would take even longer for them to correct it. It was already 830pm I went to arbys.

I went to the one in Martins Ferry. Everyone was real nice. They apologized because when I got there, I had to wait 4 more minutes for the bread. They gave me candy & a big cookie. They didn't have to do that at all. While I waited they were all joking around & telling one another how they did a good job. Felt good to see that...especially on a busy day like today. They were all smiling. Great customer service everytime we go there.

Ordered pizza through their online site, ordered 4 large pizza's at 6:30pm yes I understand it was new years eve. I get confirmation order will be ready at 7 I get a phone call from the martins ferry location 10 minutes after I place my order telling me they have no more large pizzas and did not offer to sub them for a different size since I already paid online for them. I go to the store to see if I can just get them subbed or get a copy of my refund so I don't get screwed and they tell me they are out of pizza period. I called st clairsville and asked if they had large pizzas and they said no but if you wanted to wait 20 minutes they can make the dough and I told them that was fine. Point is I will not go to the ferry location again there should be no reason that you run out of pizza at 630 on a night you know you will be busy.

Very disappointed and deflation Shadyside Ohio they treat their customers so bad we had ordered a chicken parm we received it it looks so nasty it was so soggy we called to ask if they could give us credit for it and order something else and they were very ignorant and rude about it and said no we can't do that if you want to treat your customers right you need to be a little bit more nicer about the situation because the food was very nasty and the chicken alfredo that I ordered was nowhere near a chicken alfredo chicken alfredo is supposed to have fettuccine not spaghetti noodles I will never eat there ever again