Dinner for two at 5:00 pm. We had a reservation and it filled up pretty quickly. Service was good and the food was prepared well a property seasoned. The only thing that could have been impproved upon is that the thin center part of the pizza was Luke warm. Possibly because of the plate being cold? The pizza was still delicious, just could have been hotter. The meal with an app. Salad and a pizza plus 4 glasses of wine was $95. We would certainly dine here again

Tried the meatballs and a pizza tonight. Everything was delicious. The pizza only took about 8 mins to make. So make sure you space the time between the appetizers unless you like everything to come out at once. The service Was phenomenal. The prices were reasonable. The parking is awful unless you park in the lot next door which was $15 to park tonight.

Pizza had good flavor, however the middle was soggy and very watery. Had an order for takeout and got my pizzas fresh, which was nice, but if they wouldve let the pizzas cook a bit more it would have been a lot better. Like some people on here have stated, it looks a lot better than it tastes. If you're gonna go for anything, I suggest to go for the desert, the tiramisu and cannoli's were really good.

I discovered San Giorgio pizzeria looking around on Google maps. Decided to go there since all the reviews were really good. I got there (party of 2) on a Friday night at 8.00 pm and there was no waiting time. Two seats were available right away at the bar. The pizza is excellent, the staff is great and the atmosphere is very enjoyable. Prices are very affordable too. I highly suggest to stop by this pizza place. The owner is a really nice guy and always ready to talk with his customers. Make sure you get a real espresso after a real Italian pizza! I will definitely stop by during my next trip to Milwaukee.

This spot was recommended by someone who is from Italy. I was told this is legit Italian food and authentic Pizza Napoletana. It did not disappoint. I had arancini for an appetizer and it was mouth-wateringly delicious. The pizza cooks in almost no time at all due to the super hot oven (I think it's at 900°). Our server was so friendly and came by multiple times. I would definitely come back. No drawbacks.

Food, drinks, service, bar tenders, host, atmosphere…fantastic!!! Just looking at the pictures make me want to come back. It was a whole new experience for me, going to a restaurant and talking nonstop about how good the food is. My best friend and I had a wonderful time. Photos by AC

The real Italian wood-fired pizza. Great Alessandro, it was a pleasure to meet you, if you pass by Las vegas remember to come to Farinata, Italian Style Pizza.

Best pizza ever. Always enjoy coming here. Love seeing the pizzas being made out in the open! Never disappointed. Always consistent quality and service!

Fantastic dining experience. Chef Robin is a master. Terrific Neapolitan pizza; however, it’s much more than a pizza restaurant. I could eat here once a day. Wait staff was personable and helpful. A must visit in Milwaukee. I will be back!

Best pizza I've had in a long time. Cannot possibly recommend enough. Great staff, great food, wonderful experience. A definite gem in MKE.

Neapolitan pizza, which has a soft and chewy crust. Best eaten with a fork and knife or folded in half, especially since the juices from cooking can settle underneath. Nothing like your typical chain pizza, so don't expect a crispy or thick crust. Do however expect fresh ingredients and lots of flavor. The San Giorgio is one of my favorites, with arugula and a fried egg.

We made a reservation here for two, and when we got there they asked if it's okay if we get sat at the pizza bar. At first we were hesitant, but it turned out to be so much fun to watch the pizza artists at work. It was like dinner and a show :) Cheesy, I know. Aside from the entertainment, we split the burrata and the Ilario pizza. The burrata was perfectly creamy, the olive oil was flavorful, the salt came through but not too much, and complimented the sweet ripe tomatoes perfectly. The pizza was also great! I wish the bottom was cooked just a touch more since there was a little bit of dough goo in the middle, but the flavors were great. The San Marzano tomatoes that SG uses for their sauce make a huge difference and add such a wonderful brightness to the pie. Go to San Giorgio and ask for a reservation at the pizza bar!

My friend and I visited the place for supper. Their individual-sized pizza were on a pricier side, but the quality of ingredients was excellent. They also have some unique pizza flavors. The desserts and service were great, as well. I would recommend this place. I wish they had some Italian sodas too, which did not seem to be the case.

Great service, atmosphere and location. A quick 5 min walk to the Milwaukee REP. The meatballs, calamari and pasta were delicious and prepared to perfection. The pizza was not, the crust was soggy and raw in the center. We'll definitely go back, but steer clear of the pizza.

This is the only Neapolitan style pizzeria certified to use quality Italian ingredients in its wood oven fired pizzas in the Milwaukee area! It was delicious and every bit a neopolitan pizza... chewy with a great, bubbly wood fired crust! I highly recommend the San Giorgio namesake pizza! Braised fennel and pancetta with baby arugula and Romano and mozzarella! Insert lip smacking sounds here! So, so good! We also loved the Arancini. Large risotto balls deep fried to crispy perfection outside and served with bolognese sauce. If pizza isn't your Forte, we would also recommend the gnocchi, served with a 12 hour sausage ragu! Oh man, was that tender and so filling! Service was insightful and gave great recommendations as well. It's small and cozy and great romantic dinner for two!

This is possibly my favorite pizza place here. I recommend it to everyone if they are looking for some pizza. The atmosphere is nice. These pictures are from last year but I remember our encounter vividly. Our server was so attentive and gave great wine recommendations. Literally felt like family when I was here. Food was great--atmosphere and people were great. I hope to return soon.

Very pretty restaurant in Downtown Milwaukee that has a modern aesthetic. Ordered 3 pizzas and Caesar Salad for takeout. Pizzas were excellent, but pricey. Definitely high quality so I do not feel I overpaid, but this is more expensive than many other pizzerias. The salad was a bit disappointing because the romaine had started to wilt / go brown. The staff was very nice as I dealt with two women - the hostess and a bartender. I highly recommend if looking for pizza downtown or a special night out, but too expensive to be an every week place.

The pizza is Neopolitan style... so it has a crispy outer crust but the center of the pizza is soft and can be messy. But the flavors are good and the amazing Nutella calzone for dessert is a must!!!

The closest Naples style pizza that I have found. Absolutely great food and nice staff. This is likely the top restaurant in Milwaukee! Keep it up and keep the fabulous ingredients coming!

Everything was amazing!! The crust for my margarita pizza was soon yummy like no other place in milw. and this pasta dish with meatballs was Devine. We got so sit close to the pizza oven. Will definitely be back!

Awesome place. Would go again if I’m ever back in the area. Sat right at the bar and got a chance to watch all the employees make pizza, saw inside the oven while my pizza was being cooked. A really really great experience. Pizza and dessert was fantastic.

The BEST pizza napoletana I've had in the US. We visited the pizzeria after 4 years, and the quality was exactly the same, if not better. San Giorgio reminds me of the pizza in Naples, Italy. The staff is great and very knowledgeable. The menu is so good that it's hard to pick one thing. The people leaving bad reviews have no idea what a true pizza napoletana is. Grazie for bringing a piece of Italy to Milwaukee. 😊

First time here. If you are looking for fresh, interesting, and delicious pizzas, this is the place. We all ordered a different pizza, and shared them. Each pizza is a general "personal" size and has 4 large slices. I had the San Giorgio and it was amazingly good (it has a sunny side egg). We all enjoyed our choice of pizzas. It was a busy night and they told us when we were seated that they needed the table at 7:30 (1.5 hrs). I get that they want to turn over tables. We might have stayed for dessert, would have been rushed (we went to "At Random" for ice cream drinks :) The dining room was a packed, but we had plenty of room at our table. The server did a great job (thanks Josh). It was a bit noisy, but we were able to have a conversation. We would definitely go again.

A great tasting pizza, friendly staff, and good vibes! Will definitely recommend!

So fantastic. Service was awesome from the hostess, server and kitchen. The food? Perfect. Can’t wait to go back. We had Margherita pizza, gnocchi and the Nutella calzone. Cocktails were great too. My husband said it was the best Old fashioned he’s ever had. High praise!

We ordered the burrata app and the Ilario (pictured). Both dishes were good but not mind-blowing. Crust was very good and was hoping that would be used for the burrata instead of the artisan bread that was served with the dish.

You have to try San Giorgio's Authentic Italian Cuisine. The Chefs are trained in Italy. What comes out of the wood fired oven is delicious. The service is excellent and the atmosphere is classy. Follow the restaurant on social media to stay up to date on their rotating specials!