🔔Update Sept 2023: Cuginis is open again with signs saying under new management. Had the same thing I’ve had here for the past 15 years and it’s just as good as it was before the place changed hands. Long live Cuginis 🍕 Been going to this place for over half my life, starting from when I went to high school across the street. The quality over the years has stayed the same, and they make a great deep-dish style buffalo slice. I challenge you to find a better buffalo slice on Long Island, as I have yet to do so. Other slices are great too, with plenty of variety if you don’t feel like getting the same buffalo slice for 15+ years like I do. The guys who work the counter are super cool too! Tip: try the buffalo slice, rice ball, meat pinwheel. The chicken bacon ranch slices are tasty as well!

I don't know about this place, every time I seem to go, the kitchen is closed. They're only doing pizza or it's closed completely. 7:47 tonight I walk down with a friend to get food and the place is closed up completely. Yet it's open in the early afternoon not sure but they might as well just lock the door is completely and quite a business because every time I pass by you wanna come here it's closed.

I was out with my grands and looking for a place to have lunch. Cugini is a moderate size Pizzeria with a restaurant dining room attached. I had the Pasta E Pagioli soup as a starter. I told the server that it was years since I had this soup with such great flavor. The portions were generous. I will will have to return to try their pizza.

I would stay away from this place if you like New York style pizza. The pizza crust was more deep dish style and was hard like it was cooked on a cracker. Two bites in a realized I’ve eaten frozen pizza that’s taste better than this. It was so bad I couldn’t finish it..

The staff was super friendly and the pizza was delicious. It tasted fresh and it was the perfect ratio with the sauce and cheese.

Wonderful pizzeria and restaurant! The BEST local pizza with a nice variety of special slices! Also, in the back is a wonderful restaurant area with waiter service! Pablo is the waiter and he does a tremendous job! The prices are very reasonable and the food is excellent! Cugini reopened under new management and they are doing a fantastic job…The food is even better than before with polite and highly attentive counter staff and a great waiter in the restaurant. Unequivocally highly recommended! Before Cugini reopened, I would travel to Umbertos for pizza…but, Cugini’s wonderful pizza and food dishes are equal to or surpass Umbertos. Cugini is the BEST local pizzeria/restaurant. Again, highly recommend!

I received a 20% discount and felt compelled to use it. 2x pies (plain/pepperoni) thick, fake, frozen style mozzarella sticks, small wings, all still around $75. I also had to write down this code for them which also just wasn't good service. I understand inflation, but this is just a rip-off.

Great pizza. The buffalo chicken is my go to. They gotta put back up the autographed picture of Ralph Maccio aka the karate kid 🤣