Hands down our favorite place now. We came for my wife’s birthday and everyone that came to our table said happy birthday to her. Food and service was excellent couldn’t have been any better. Corey, our waiter was excellent telling us the background story of the restaurant. Service was fast and management was also perfect checking on us. We will definitely be back!

The service was Excellent! The food was delicious. They will accommodate a large party but be ware it comes with a high price food and drink min of $1000 that they will charge rather you meet that minimum to the host credit card. It's not a hidden fee but be aware. I think they should change that because your guest will spend at least $50 or more per person. The place is very beautiful inside and inside for great pictures. We celebrated my husband birthday. They put his name on the menu which was really sweet! Thanks for a great first time experience

Me and my fiancé had a wonderful time last night dining here. The atmosphere is very calm and relaxing light inside gives you a nice glow without being to dull or bright. Staff are very punctual, polite and attentive. Staff will indulge you with some historical facts of this beautiful historical building while you wait for your food to arrive. Food is served very quickly with staff offering to place side items on your plate and box up your meal once finished. A few important things to note when dining here for the first time like we did…. 1. Portions of food can easily feed 2 people this includes main courses, salads, side items, deserts exc… 2. Dress casual/business casual I wore a nice dress my fiancé wore blue jeans and a button up. 3. Parking does offer valet for $3 or you may park your own vehicle. 4. Make a reservation before going as this restaurant fills up quickly. 5. Be prepared to spend an easy $200 plus for a table of 2 people. Regardless if you eat here regularly or are a one time a year just to say you went person this place is a must try and worth the experience. Thank you to everyone who made our date night and first time experience a memorable one. We will gladly return.

I had the best time at this restaurant! Our server Andrew was kind and knowledgeable. The entire staff made us feel like the only table that mattered which was a tough feat for how busy they were. The food was amazing. I have never had a steak so tender. The crab cake was amazing as well! I would definitely recommend you visit this restaurant!

Had reservations here tonight to celebrate my father's cancer officially being in remission. Our waiter, Cameron, was so awesome. He made us feel right at home, joked with us, told us the history of Carlo and Johnny, and answered all questions about the menu that we had and also had some excellent suggestions. The atmosphere here is incredible. My wife and I have also ate at The Capital Grille, and while an also excellent restaurant, I feel the atmosphere here edged out The Capital Grille. There really was such an awesome vibe here. The food was phenomenal as you would expect. I personally liked the mushroom crusted steaks at The Capital Grille a little better, but you still cannot go wrong with anything on the menu here. Large wine selection like you would expect as well. Don't give it anymore thought, book a table here ASAP!

A truly exceptional experience. The staff were very professional, and the cuts were worth every dollar. If you are looking to celebrate a promotion, accomplishment, or just see one of the finer staples of Cincy, Carlo & Johnny is a must. One of my favorite outings so far. Ribeye with garlic and butter, seared and cooked to med-rare perfection. Moody lighting and standout drinks offer a vibrant night out with your significant other or group. Join me in my brief moment of insanity when I felt like I could afford to go here and indulge a little; it is absolutely worth it!

Carlo & Johnny's is one of a handful of restaurants in Cincinnati with impeccable service, food and drinks. The atmosphere is elegant but comfortable. I typically get their steak but I tried the sea bass for the first time and it melted in my mouth, light and fluffy. My husband loves the Burrow steak.

Fantastic as always. Sat outside for the 1st time & had a wonderful experience.

Took my husband for his birthday, our server was Greg and he was amazing!!!! I didnt expect them to bring my husband a birthday sampler or to take our picture and print it for us! Such a great experience. The food was delicious!!!!!

Last week was the second time my husband and I have been to Carlo and Johnny...this time we brought friends. Everything from beginning to end was top-notch! Friendly service from the valet to the host to both our servers (thanks Jack and Chris!). Food - AMAZING! Great wine selection. And dessert... :) Beautiful place for dinner. Can't wait to go again!

First time trying this restaurant because we really can’t afford it. My best friend bought me a gift card for my birthday and when we looked at the menu, we decided to get their meal kits to go so our kids could enjoy it also. We purchased 4 steaks with sides, salad, and dessert for about $250. Got home and prepared dinner and the taste was amazing. My only issue is that two of the steaks had significant gristle that could not be chewed or eaten. Supposed to be $100 steaks, while taste was great, quality was not much better Texas Roadhouse. Glad I didn’t spend my own money, but was appreciative of the experience.

Their tree out front looked especially beautiful during the holidays. As far as the food and service, this is a 5 star (max. stars) restaurant. The new Steak Burrow was amazing. The raw bar was amazing. The staff was amazing. Social distancing was followed and masks worn. I felt very comfortable. I purchased the wife a Gift Card just so I'm guaranteed to come back.

Absolutely the standard for fine dining. My husband and I visited for our 45th anniversary. We were treated like royalty by several servers who were "Johnny" on the spot! Very friendly and servers very much on top of everything. They even took our photo, printed it out and put it in a frame and displayed it with a candlelit complimentary dessert. The environment is spectacular, warm and very inviting. The food was exceptional (as it was on a prior visit). We spent a wonderful, leisurely time and were not rushed at all. We were even given hot lavender towels after our seafood appetizer! Servers and the manager checked on us periodically, but were not obtrusive. If you are celebrating something special, or just in need of kindness, exceptional service, pampering, and that special something, visit Carlo & Johnny.

Awesome food awesome service very nice place

The very best restaurant in Ohio!!

Worst Filet I've ever had in my life (ponderosa steak house would put it to shame)!! They took it off my bill but I will never spend another dime dining there. I am so Disappointed....

It is not the food in itself. It is the whole entire experience. Attention to detail of every person we came in contact with. The food was what people come for, the experience was what they leave with. That is why people come here to celebrate the very special of times. Kudos to all.

The food doesn’t deserve its price. My kids ordered this hamburger was burned and full of carcinogen, and tasted so… salty! The price is also extremely high, not worth it.

This place is an amazing place to celebrate occasions and to be with Family. Eat excellent food and drink. To be served with excellence was rewarding. I will recommend this restaurant.

Excellent dining experience! Very good restaurant. Great service and attention to detail. Great menu and very good steaks. I had the boneless ribeye. It was one of the best if not the best steaks I have ever eaten. Sides are served a la carte. Good selection of wine and beer. Fully bar also. Parking was a little tough, but there is valet parking available. The restaurant is pricey, but equal the value and service. I would like recommend this place.

Atmosphere and service were top notch. The Mac & Cheese... Holy toledo, out of this world amazing! The dessert portions were crazy big and delicious.

As much as I love steak, it's shocking that I'd never been to a Jeff Ruby's restaurant . . . until now. Last Christmas, they offered a gift card sale, and my friend and I each bought $100 worth for $80. We finally - in September of the next year - were able to make reservations and go to Carlo & Johnny. We picked this spot over the downtown location and The Precinct due to it being literally in the backyard of my friend's childhood home. We were seated immediately and greeted by the assistant server who introduced herself to us. She offered us different types of water. While formal, the atmosphere and attitude never felt stuffy. Our server, Greg, came to the table to introduce himself, ask if we wanted any other drinks and promised to return with bread for the table. Greg was about as perfect a server as I've ever had. He knew precisely when to check in, was appropriately engaged - but never hovered, never interrupted, and had an air of professional confidence that was just lovely. He brought the bread, fresh from the oven, with both regular butter and mushroom truffle butter, which was actually quite good. We both started with a half-size Caesar Salad, which was huge. I can't imagine what the full size would have looked like. I had the 12 oz barrel cut filet, with blue cheese butter and mac and cheese. My friend ordered the petite filet and sides of both Brussel sprouts and mashed potatoes. (She was planning her menus for the weekend.) We finished off with dessert; my friend had the cheesecake and I had the creme brulee. The steaks, cooked perfectly medium, were so tender you really could cut it with a fork. Twelve ounces is a lot, but I ate every bite. The mac and cheese was rich and cheesy and decadent, with a crust of cheese on top and a gooey center. I didn't sample the Brussel sprouts, but the portion was gigantic. The mashed potatoes were nice, but I was pleased with my choice of mac. I asked Greg which he would prefer over the Peanut Butter dessert and the creme brulee and he didn't hesitate to say creme brulee. He was right. It was the best creme brulee I've ever had. It was a large portion, the carmelized top was delicious, and the raspberries were a nice accompaniment. The cheesecake was lovely, but not really special. Still, there was nothing wrong with it and if that was all they offered for dessert, we would both have been satisfied. We joined the Ruby's loyalty club after dinner. My friend had trouble making it work on her phone, but I was registered within minutes. Super easy, free, and the rewards seem worthwhile. I have every intention of returning to Carlo & Johnny, but I also want to try the Precinct and the new downtown Ruby's spot once it opens. The experience definitely lived up to the hype.

This is by far my favorite Jeff Ruby’s restaurant. I love the ambience, location, service, and food! My husband have been going to this place at least once a year for the past 9 years. They never disappoint. I highly recommend to anyone that is looking for a memorable dining experience.

Excellent food and service! Steaks were prepared exactly as ordered and delicious. The desserts did not disappoint, Butter Pie, phenomenal as always, as well as the Vanilla Bean Creme Brule!

Wow! What an exceptional experience. We were treated like straight Royalty for my birthday! Fine dinning at it finest. I've been to other Jeff Ruby's, but this by far exceeded my expectations and then some. Our waiter Carlos, one of the managers, Austin, was everything. From them escorting me to the restroom, taking my coat and walking me out! I truly felt special! This is hands down a place to remember! Oh and the food was beyond delicious! Everything was top notch and I er top and absolutely BEAUTIFUL! Thank you to all the staff that made my experience so memorable!

If you come for an amazing dining experience, this is the place. The history laid around the restaurant is a feast for the eyes. The best piece is the front door in my opinion. Recommendation: Freddie salad with Oyster Rockefeller. Steak Burrow and finish the night off with either a JR cigar or Ricotta Donuts. 5/5

CRYSTAL ROOM WEDDING RECEPTION Ranked a most romantic restaurant in America, how could any couple not want to host their intimate wedding reception upstairs in the Crystal room?! Our liaison Ashlee and service captain Jake, alongside his team, took care of us and each wedding guest like we were family. And bravo Chef!- the menu was exquisitely prepared.

Very high class and regal atmosphere. Definitely would go back. I advise you to valet because parking is packed even on a Wednesday! James, our server, was on top of his "A" game, and the people who helped fill waters and clear the table were graceful. Thank you.

We ordered one of the “Date Night” take home kits. It came with two ( 8 oz. filets), mac and cheese, four tiger shrimp, freddie salads, bread and butter, asparagus, and two butter pies. We were over the moon about how delicious and easy this dinner was for us to put together. They had an instruction sheet, that helped us the whole way. It was almost perfect really. To say we are impressed, is an understatement! The mac and cheese, was by far the best we have ever had! The bread, had the perfect crust and softness on the inside. The butter pies.. yummy! Whoever is making the mac and cheese.. killed it. Whoever is making the bread.. killed it… whoever is doing pastry… killed it! Thank you so much for this wonderful experience! We couldn’t have asked for better. We will definitely be back to grab another “Date Night” meal kit.

My husband and I visit at least 4 times a year so when I had family visiting from MN., I knew exactly where we wanted to take them. Due to the date of us wanting to visit, (Father’s Day) I reached out months in advance for reservations. Ashlee was very quick to respond, helping to finalize all the details and then to see that follow up emails were answered quickly. My family was awed by the atmosphere and appeal of the restaurant which is what we were hoping for. It was also my daughters birthday which Carlo and Johnny’s surprised her by placing her name on the menu. Every team member was kind, attentive and helpful in every way. Wyatt was our server and not only offered suggestions, but was witty and his personality shined. This memory for my kids and grandkids will be remembered for a very long time. My next visit will not be too far off in the future.

Plan your reservation well in advance, always popular, well set, and worth its high charges. This is not a cheap date place, and they know it. One of the first questions is if it is anniversary or birthday. The mix of service with well made offerings, and the atmosphere, it’s good. If you are a chocolate connoisseur the “JR Cigar” is well worth it! Trust me!

It was Amazing experience! Food is good, atmosphere is great! Love all the food, appetizers and Cowboy steak is excellent! Greg is very nice always checking on us! Dessert for birthday celebrant is good! I definitely wanna go back to this place and try other food! Recommended!

Amazing atmosphere, service and food. We had a larger group and the service was outstanding. Everyone was extremely friendly. Food came out fresh and correctly prepared. Portions are generous and delicious. Mac and Cheese was out of this world as was the JR Cigar dessert!

What a pleasurable experience. Celebrated an anniversary in The Liquor Room. Appetizers were excellent, wagyu meatball, prawns, and sushi tasted great. No great detail, but you won’t be disappointed. Main course were prepared to everyone’s liking. I had the boneless ribeye. Perfect seasoning and cooked to medium rare. As far as sides go, all were good. I liked the brussel sprouts. The Mac and cheese (recommended by server) wasn’t a good. Waaaay too much cheese. Asparagus was tender and flavorful. Lastly the desserts were amazing. The dark chocolate cake and a scoop of vanilla ice cream was split between 4 of us. Amazing presentation on the Strawberry Fields! The butter pie, is a must! Mixed drinks were well balanced. I’d suggest their signature drinks. You can get margaritas and a rum and coke anywhere. Only reason I did no give 5 stars: 1: being a private room (even with an an assistant) I would have liked more attention to detail. ( drinks not being filled and not checking in after meal for a while) 2: finding shells in the topping for a steak (Burrow topping) Overall a very enjoyable experience. If you would like an upscale experience, this is definitely on the list.

The experience I had last night was incredible. Our server Mike was amazing. The service is second to none. The steak literally melts in your mouth. The ambiance is soo unique and special. It was the best dining experience both myself and my fiance have ever had. Simply amazing 👏 I hope Mike sees this review. He deserves recognition for how good he is at his job. And the way he and another waiter were roasting each other towards the end of our meal really made it fun. Seriously. If anyone out there is reading this and you don't know if you want to step out and commit to an expensive dinner. Just do it. It's worth it. Thanks Mike! See you next time

Happy Birthday to me. !! The service was Amazing and Atmosphere was awesome the surroundings were absolutely beautiful!!! But the food was top notch !!!!

Legendary Ruby's food and experience. They opened the *crystal room* as a dining room to maintain social distancing while dining. Our server was too notch, wore his mask properly, and was still easy to hear and understand. Our food was prepared quickly and accurately, and was delicious.

Excellent food, service and ambiance!

Amazing!!

Exceptional staff, great atmosphere great food I would highly recommend it!

Jeff Ruby's ALWAYS provides a first class culinary experience whether at Carlos & Johnny, The Precinct, or the namesake Jeff Ruby's restaurants! Can't wait to go back!

Thr finest of restaurants in the area!

Exceptional service. The Liquor Room is perfect!

Great service and meal

Fantastic food and service!

Fantastic service, & the steaks are amazing!

Amazing experience, food, and service

Exceptional food and service!

The food was out of this world best steak in town if not the state, service was immaculate our server Adrian should teach service, rest of the staff very friendly the Mac and cheese specialty deserves all the hype.

Wonderful dining. Staff was 5 star all the way. Food was excellent, what we expected from a Ruby establishment. Highly recommend.

My wife and I would like to express our gratitude to everyone at Carlo and Johnny for an excellent evening. We wanted to dine at a very special place for my wife's birthday. The food and the attention to service was outstanding. They really hit it out of the park.

I had the best steak of my life while attending a wedding reception dinner here! The staff were all so personable, and the space was beautiful. I’m from Boston, but will be coming back if I’m in Cincinnati again!

The experience was amazing a lovely place comfortable atmosphere. Our waiter was amazing he knew the menu he told us the history of the restaurant. I have recommended them to several of my friends. Thank you all for a wonderful dinner.

Obviously, this steak house is top tier and priced accordingly. Best steak I've ever had. Cooked to a PERFECT medium rare AND still had gorgeous char on the outside of the meat. You can tell how fresh and beautiful the cuts of meat are... just amazing. We also got oysters and shrimp. The shrimp are almost as big as my hand (and $8 per shrimp) but so fresh and delicious. We took a chance on the pork belly appetizer and it wasn't our thing but it was cooked perfectly and I can see why it's a favorite on the menu but we personally wouldn't order that again. Last, but not least, we indulged ourselves with a chocolate cake and boy oh boy was that slice HUGE! Also delicious! Highly recommend coming here for special occasions. It is quite expensive but of the best quality. The overall experience was also luxurious and indulgent. So.ething we should all get the chance to experience every now and again.

Best food ever!

Great food. Great atmosphere for a nice night out.

My favorite of the Ruby's restaurants. Food is excellent, but the ambiance here is more my speed than Ruby's downtown or the Precinct.

The Best steakhouse in Cincy.

Great steaks, mac & cheese out of this world delicious. Great service from Sarah & entire staff. Super expierence

Fantastic atmosphere, great social distancing and seating. Steak was amazing as was service. And try the butter pie!

Delicious food and excellent service. Thank you Clay and Eddie, and the whole staff for wonderful evening out.

Great service, thanks Chris.

Food was fantastic, our server , Ashley was excellent

Absolutely amazing. Worth every penny.

My wife and I had a great experience. The food was obviously great, along with the cocktail selection. More importantly the service was excellent and our waiter went out of his way to insure we had a good time.

Very warm atmosphere with a great friendly staff.

We got carry out for our anniversary. Steaks (strip and cowboy rib-eye) and the wedge salad. The wedge salad was 1/8 of an head of iceberg and no seared pork. They placed it on top of the steaks and it wilted before leaving the parking lot. Steaks were good, but not worth the price tag. Sourdough bread was probably the highlight.

We ordered the 4x8oz filets meal kit for our Christmas Eve dinner. The steaks turned out AMAZING. The side dishes were amazing as well. The staff at C&J’s made the ordering and pickup process extremely easy. Thanks for the big assist in helping preparing a great Christmas Eve meal.

Great steaks, crab cake was awesome. Chris, our server was the best.

Great!!! It was our anniversary.