Huge selection! Had large sizes in plugs (which was what I went there looking for) & he measured my current plugs to make sure that I was getting the right size. Also had a huge selection of extra long eyelashes for a hell of a price! I've gotten soo many compliments!

Amazing customer service! I like the one hot Asian babe. Beautiful jewelry. And beautiful worker if ya know what I mean 😉

This place is AWESOME I love their jewelry and anyone who says otherwise is a butthead

Thier great people and a great help in helping me select tattoo supplies. I really do appreciate them.

AMAZING customer service I’ve gotten all 4 of my facial piercings done earlier this year and I hadn’t changed any of the jewelry. I wasn’t sure the correct bar sizes for my eyebrows or the hoop size I needed for my nose and she picked out the perfect sizes for all my piercings and helped me find exactly what I wanted for vision I had when getting my piercings I’m so excited to go back and get the jewelry I’ve been waiting for my next few piercings because they have it!

Most definitely a hidden gem for sure! The inventory is absolutely incredible! And the prices are fantastic! If you’re looking for any type of body jewelry jewelry or anything else they’ve got it for you! Not to mention, the service was awesome! Super friendly and very helpful! I’m glad he found it! I’ll be back for sure!! 😊👍

A gem of a place. Excellent selection and best prices in Utah. The owners are super kind and honest. Love this place

I go to this location a few times a month. Highly recommend any of the merchandise. Great customer service

I've been loyal to Incredible Toy for a long time. They are the only place I can rely on to have both quality, and quantity when it comes to affordable jewelry. Not to mention a great selection of tattoo equipment. I only do special request tattoos on the side, so it's really convenient to stop by here for a few of the odds and ends. Highly recommend this place, even if you're just browsing.

Very nice store and fun to experience they have a great selection of anything you can think of as an adult that you might need. The pricing is very reaonable.

I was surprised to discover this shop has moved, as it's been in the same location almost my entire life. I was more surprised to see what an amazing choice it was. This new place they have is amazing. Plenty of space, more inventory, I cannot recommend this place enough! Thank you for providing such great service. Looking forward to visiting again!

This store is absolutely amazing. They have the biggest selection I have ever seen. They have everything you could want when it comes to body jewelry. Not only do they have a HUGE selection, their prices are great and their products are high quality. I am used to buying my plugs for $40. I picked up a pair for $15! I would highly recommend this store.

Great store. Great prices. They had all I needed and way more. Will be returning very soon.

I love this store. The State St location is great. They have a big selection of product. The owners are always so nice.

Does not do piercings, but has a large selection of jewelry to choose from.

Amazing jewelry quality, and the prices are good