Very good pizza by Maine standards. While it's not New Haven level, it's still the best pie around and you can get it well done. Very reasonably priced, too. Don't forget to bring your own hot wheels and race them on the track.

Great place to get a pizza and a few drinks. The atmosphere inside is nice and friendly. Definitely my favorite pizza place in Naples. They have a great selection of pizzas and chicken fingers. I'm sure you could order a pizza and pull up with your boat as well. This is a good thing to keep in mind on the summer days 😀

I have been meaning to try this pizza for a while. Today was the day. It is the best I've had in Maine. Randy's will be our new go to for pizza nights!

Best pizza I've had in a really long time. My recommendation -- garlic, onion, and sausage.

We stopped by for a quick drink one evening on vacation, loved the restaurant and sat next to a couple who ordered a couple of pizzas and were impressed. We vacation for two weeks on Long Lake and always get pizza on our second Friday as a treat before we go home. We decided to switch to Randy's based on sight alone and were not disappointed. Highly recommend.

Wow! My family visited from NJ knowing little about this spot and it is a true gem up in Maine with authentic New Haven pizza. Food was the best of our trip and the view was amazing. Also, enjoyed the hot wheels for the kids (kid friendly). Highly recommend!!

By far the best pizza in New England! The Stratosphere and Jo-Jo's are our favorites. Great view of the lake too.

Only one Waitress but she was working really hard! The Pizza was delicious and huge! Definitely worth another trip!

We had the best server. Thank you Kim. Everything was downhill from there. The brucersstta was soggy, with canned rubbery olives and we actually had to send it back. My eggplant parmigiana was dry, lukewarm and arrived 15 minutes after our guest was finishing his 18 inch pizza. The pasta that came with the eggplant was decent, but room temperature. Randy's professes to be a world class contender, but this meal was Dismal.

Cool pizza joint with a hot wheels car theme going on. Pizza was just ok with bland sauce and overall lack of flavor. Ok in a pinch, wouldn't make a habit out of it.

Great food but takes forever. Called in 2 pizzas and they said 45 minutes so we waited then had to wait another 30 minutes when we got there. If your looking for something quick and easy DONT GO HERE!!!

Pizza Sauce was bitter and spread thin and the toppings had cooked down (reduced) right into the sauce so as to be mushy and indefinable. We were hoping for a good meal after reading so many great reviews, but it wasn’t good at all. My husband’s meal came out first and after nearly 10 minutes, my meal finally arrived.

Have been here many, many times. The food quality is very consistent and rarely anything less than outstanding. The entire Randy's experience is at its best in the off season. Be certain to make sure you get salads, dressing or dipping sauces if you take out! This can be a VERY busy place during tourist season and take out accoutrements are sometimes forgotten.