This pizza is truly defined by its crust. The texture and taste is very good. The $2 slice is big and full of value. Tons of cheese, but could use just a little more sauce. Or maybe that is their intention because the crust is so good? People on the phone were very nice and were very gracious at the counter. This is a solid slice of pizza in an impressive Sussex County Pizza division on the Pizza Hunters App. I know that their crust can hang with anyone. Good Job Johnny Jrs.

After waiting 10+ mins for some slices to be heated up , I headed home ,$6.15 for two slices: one plain & one BCR. Alright I guess ,wait wasn't too long , however after I got home I realized the pizza was dryer than dry , the bottom of the pizza has little nubs on it like it was cooked on a mesh plate ? (Pic #1). I've had pizza all over the greater Netcong area and it's safe to say ANY place has fresher pizza (Pizza Express for instance)... For the record I was there @5pm on a Sunday. If you read all the reviews they are very generic and almost seem faked , not sure how this pizza place stays in business when there are two other pizza shops down the road with better pizza .

Ordered a cheese steak and was quite literally just meat and cheese no onions or any other toppings and meat was extremely dry. On top of that the hot sauce was buffalo sauce.. completely different things.. never again 10$ for the meat and cheese on a roll

We order from Johnny Jr’s at least once, or twice a week. The food is consistantly excellent. We order many different items, and the food never disappoints. Highly recommend!

Sigi pie off the charts! Light as air, chewy, crunchy, tasty! Sicilian pie, that is.

Pizza is consistently good, disco fries also. Pepperoni roll I ordered recently was a disaster, not filled at all. Tuna sub was very good. Ordered an Italian hotdog, got a sub not pizza bread with chopped up hotdog, peppers and onions but no potatoes. Called in and they were pretty surprised but helpful.

I ordered from here multiple times through Grubhub. I am a huge fan of their personal pizzas! I also recommend the fried raviolis.

Got the pizza order completely wrong. They pizza we got was terrible. The chicken fingers were over cooked and thin n dry and the fries were horrible that came with it. Disco fries were the pits. So disappointed.

Johnny's @ GrubHub: Watts with Johnny? Double Ricotta Pizza with no ricotta at all because Johnny Has Gone Phishing!...He called my home,very chatty and long winded too and then he deliberately delivered the wrong order so I would have something pleasant to remember him by.He enjoys prevaricating and changing orders .

It was my first time trying this pizza parlor. The staff was nice. It was not the best pizza I've had. I got a combo and my favorite part was the chicken fingers. I thought it was a good deal but will probably not return since I did not like the actual pizza.

Called to place an order for delivery at 5:07 pm and the order never arrived until 6:43 pm! After calling twice to see where the driver was, they said they didn’t know.. when the food finally arrived the delivery driver drove away and was sight seeing!!! The food was good, not the best. The staff was irresponsible by not even calling us to let us know they were lost which we would have been more than happy to help assist with directions. Not a great first ever experience with Johnny Jr’s Pizzeria!

OK pizza. Big slices and cheap. Lots of middling cheese. Interior is slightly dirty and the vibe is kind of weird.

Awesome place to eat people are friendly and food always made fresh... 1 word for their crust that they make for their pizza.....Delicious!.....😋

I’ve ordered from them at least 40 times and never had bite of food that wasn’t great!

This place has really gone downhill. We decided to give them another try after many orders being wrong or just not great in the past but we won’t be ordering from here again. $17 for a chicken dinner that was basically a heated up breaded chicken nugget, not real cooked chicken like it should be. Pasta sauce was oily and huge waste of money!

Always consistently great! This is our go to pizza place. Highly recommend Johnny Jr’s!

Very good pizza, just a drop too oily for my taste, but you deff check it out, nice and crispy and very tasty

These guys are my pizza heroes! Their food is delicous, and they have the lowest price gluten free pizza in the area! Everyone who works there is super friendly. I've always had a great experience with both delivery and carry out. Plus, they have a little spinning TARDIS from Doctor Who on the counter, which is super cool. I would go to war for their french fries.

I ordered from them two days in a row!! The wings are seasoned & my salads were great portions . I will be ordering from here whenever I want some good wings & salad !