So I took off 1 star for each dish I felt was subpar. Ordered a pizza to start and I haven't been more disappointed in a floppy underseasoned wet pizza. The tomatoes on the pizza were pretty much raw and just oozing water over the pizza. Flavors were disappointing and lacking. Probably could also have used another 3 minutes in the oven. The chicken Parm was probably the most disappointing thing that I've ordered though. It was soggy where the water from the chicken soaked through the breading. I had more flavor from sucking my fingers after eating celery sticks. No salt, no seasoning. Nada. The pasta that comes with the Parm was worse than spaghetti Os. I think I would have rather eaten chef boyardee. Flavorless sauce with overcooked pasta. The Fazzoletti D'Aragosta was actually good and only saving grace. The filling was flavorful and seasoned. The past was cooked correctly and the sauce complimented the dish well. Lastly, the tiramisu was... Not tiramisu? No lady fingers... Just disappointing yellow cake with the flavors of tiramisu. Dry and tasted fake. Go to big Y and get crav'n tiramisu fro the freezer section. Half the price and infinitely better. The blueberry mojito does deserve a shout out and pretty well made. Overall, I think this place needs to work on the basics of an Italian restaurant or just take it off the menu.

We drive 25 minutes to get to Lucia. Great menu in a nice atmosphere. The staff is always professional and courteous. The deserts are made in house by the owner each week. Outside summer patio great for family gatherings.

Came here for drinks once. The bartender was great and friendly. Ate dinner last week and the food was delicious. My server was very attentive and knowledgeable. I will definitely be dining here again. FYI it's not cheap.

Had dinner last night with 3 other people. Our fourth visit in last 5 weeks and conceivably our last. Our server who i should have realized wasthe same young man the prior visit, was again almost non existent. I should have posted that one first. Bussing service was also scarce. The quality of the food was good other than my dish was not very tasty and was not what I asked for. Our server never approached us to see if we were enjoying our meal, needed wster or bread or anything additional until time for dessert. Other visits it appeared a manager or someone that was interested in our dining experience did not appear to be there. The bus boy it seems gave the takeout to the wrong individuals. Not sure what was up. Sorry about this as i thought they had great potential for a regular go to.

Our 1st Time Dinning at Lucia. What can I say? It was Fabulous !!! From the Owner to the Staff and the Food!! What a Wonderful Experience!! This Restorante is truly a hidden gem!

We were in New Milford yesterday for an event and decided to drive around a bit on our way home to explore (super cute town) and found LUCIA. They were completely booked for the evening, but Sophia who greeted us said “let’s take a walk outside” and she offered to set up two stools at the service bar counter so we could enjoy dinner! So sweet. Leticia took care of us, was personable, and mindful of my allergies. I loved the veal saltimboca and my partner enjoyed the chicken parmigiana. Refined classic. If not for the fact that we had to zoom back to Manhattan to return our rental car, we would’ve stayed in lingered to try dessert (and perhaps also enjoy an adult beverage). We will definitely return if we are in the area again.

We cannot say enough good things about Lucia—and neither can our wedding guests! Over the course of our year-long engagement, my husband and I came to Lucia several times, the first of which is when we fell in love with their food (and staff!) and decided to have them cater our wedding. We also held our rehearsal dinner there the night before, so what does that tell you? We just love them! Chef Tony is a delight, as is his wonderful wife, Renee, who bakes delectable cakes. Stacy and the whole staff are rock stars. Whether you’re looking to cater an event or just enjoy a meal, you’re in excellent hands at Lucia!

We have been frequenting Lucia for several years and they never disappoint. After a failed anniversary dinner at another restaurant we decided to try again the following evening at Lucia. The service was top shelf as usual. Stacy our waitress was personable and attentive. Our food and drinks were delicious! Our burrata appetizer was fresh and light. We will be returning of course as we can always rely on them to consistently provide an excellent experience!