Delicious and so reasonably priced! A great new addition to Prospect Heights. Try the grilled octopus (so tender, cooked perfectly, light), zucchini croquettes are my favorite with a side of tzatziki. The traditional Cretan Dakos salad with barely rusk, feta and tomatoes was exceptional. The restaurant bar had a wide range of perfectly crafted wines (many imported from the motherland, aka Greece itself. I would recommend the white Santorini. The atmosphere is cozy yet sophisticated. It's Modern Greek food at its finest.

Delivery came very quick. Ive been here a couple of times before and know the food is good. The spanakopita is outstanding. The lemon chicken is a large portion and delicious too. One recommendation is to ask them to wrap the container with the lemon chicken in foil or use a tighter container because most of the juices/sauce spilled out into the bag. They gave us 1 free baklava dessert which was nice and thanked us for the order. Great place!

UPDATE June 2021: I was so excited to get to actually eat at Underhill after enjoying their delivery food through Covid, but I have to say I was shocked to dine in and find the lamb burger was overcooked and dry, the fries seem to have changed, everything was just a bit bland etc. I’m not sure if there’s a new chef or just a very off night but it was super disappointing. My original review is below, so I am only writing this in the hopes someone at Underhill takes it to heart, as I know it’s such a great spot. 2020: If you love Greek food, don’t miss this place! We have only had their delivery but it always comes quickly and the food is delicious. You HAVE to get the lamb burger — non negotiable. It is so good with crispy cheese on the bottom. Mmm. The spanikopita was a bit soggy but flavor is great. We love this spot.

Inside is open air when windows are opened. and plenty of shaded seating outside. Delicious Greek salad (added grilled chicken).

Great meal and service! Octopus, ribeye, and shrimp dishes were all phenomenal. Free baklava for dessert was a really nice touch. Looking forward to coming back and trying more!

We had lunchtime there, and it was really good. the service is great. The waiter was very kind to adapt some options to my wife diet. We order a portobello burger, sweet fried potatoes, and a meat burger. Everything was perfect and quick service. If you like coffee, you should order. It was pretty good also.

I next to never leave reviews, and outside of a large collection of things in my $150+ order being delicious, this chicken entree we received was rediculous and shameful. I work in this city as a chef and have nothing but empathy for restaurants and their operators, but this portion size for an entree is embarrassing and unexcusable, please do better.

Loved it here! We came on valentine's day for the Prix Fixe menu which was $50 pp and we got 3 courses each and a bottle of pinot grigio. Bargain! Intimate seating area with a bar. The food was INCREDIBLE. We will definitely return. Authentic Greek feel, with an American twist to some dishes. Lamb shank was so tender I can't wait to return. The owner Lisa came over to us at the end of the meal and introduced herself which was really nice too - we look forward to coming back very soon.

The best Greek restaurant in Brooklyn. I am particularly lucky to have them around the corner from me. I used to live near Taverna Kyclades and adored their food, but it has gone downhill. I no longer have to travel for excellent food! Don’t sleep on the rib eye. Insanely good, and reasonably priced. Great service- attentive but not overbearing.

HIGHLY reccommended. The food is excellent. The all-day breakfast menu is very nice. The food is the kind of "just right" sort of perfect food. Looks good, tastes good. I savored each bite. The atmosphere is relaxed/casual but with a simple sort of refinement. The tall windows open to create a lovely breeze in. Plus, there's outdoor seating (at least, in the summer). Especially nice when the street is blocked off to car traffic mon-fri, 8am-8pm. Quiet, peaceful area, just a block away from the shops on Vanderbilt. Not too far from Atlantic Mall and Barclays Center too. Plenty of trees and greenery lining the streets around here. Service was simple, casual, polite, and subtle. It's not just a restaurant, it's a lovely, peaceful experience.

Enjoyed the decker chicken sandwich. Very well done. I had additional small salad...a bit poor. I did notice a few items on the menu were a bit pricey.

Very welcome Turkish/Greek/American bistro with good food and wine bar. Family friendly.

Excellent service and food!! Specifically the owner he made us feel like home

We had the soup special and the soup completely lacked flavor. The meatball dish was also meh it drowned in tomato sauce and felt very heavy. The dishes took a while to come out and the general vibe at the restaurant seemed like the waitresses were having hard time keeping up with the orders. I love greek food but I probably won’t go here again.

Amazing food and service. $1 wings were superb. The owner was very hospitable. Will definitely be back!

First time here, we had a great experience. It doesn’t offer only Greek food, you can chose among many different dishes and the food is amazing. The owner was super nice, extremely kind and friendly. We will come back for sure.

This place is open for lunch too...I hope they undate there hours.... great place we had a salad and shrimp ,cooked beautifully and my son had these lovely pancakes. Great place for brunch

Incredible food!! We got and enjoyed the Dakos Cretan salad, the feta in sesame + honey, the shrimp saganaki, the zucchini croquettes (our fave!!), and the eggplant dip. Everything was so fresh and perfectly prepared, and the staff was very sweet and brought us coconut baklava at the end. Excited to come back. A very chill neighborhood place

Delicious Greek! So good! Nice creativity shown with the burger and really great vibes. Perfect for a nice summer evening for food and cocktails.

So good! Big portions cooked well. We loved the lamb plate and the falafel plate

The food is phenomenal! And the owner along with his twin daughters are a gem! Hospitality at its finest!