Truly a 10 star establishment. This place is new to St. Thomas, and they have been destroying the wood fire pizza game from the first day they opened. They are family owned & probably some of the most kind hearted customer service folks I’ve ever met. My partner & I have had several of their pizzas, all of which have been incredible. They quite literally make the pizza in five minutes, right in front of you, whether you walk in or call in for pick up. Everything comes right out of the oven, right in the box and into your hungry hands. Its always a seamless process, they are so kind its insane. I cant even review them with enough justice but do it. Try them. You wont regret it.

Old school pizza is absolutely outstanding. These were some of the best pizzas my husband and I have ever had. I wish we would have found this place earlier, but very happy we were able to try them at least once. We ordered the bacon cheeseburger and signature pepperoni and both were amazing. They took the pepperoni pizza to the next level, and the other tasted just like a burger. The crust is phenomenal, perfect amount of toppings and cheese as well. The girl who took our order was polite and great to deal with, pick up was quick and it was neat to see the ovens. I plan on making a detour when we come back to the area as it will definitely be worth the drive.

Ordered from Old School Pizza Co. for the first time tonight and it was delicious. 5 stars was easy to give for creativity, freshness, topping amounts, flavour, presentation and customer service - awesome job and high fives to the guys working tonight! We ordered the signature pepperoni pizza which comes with ricotta and a hot honey drizzle - omg the drizzle is too good and if you like sauce or honey - get extra on the side as I wish I would’ve done! We also made a custom request with pepperoni, bacon, green olives & green peppers. We got 4 pops and a large order of the garlic cheesy strips - super flavourful too! The only thing I would say, is I personally would’ve like my pizza just a tiny bit more cooked to really taste the wood stove! You can taste it but am sure they’d take the request for more well done, if that’s your thing! Either way, it was a great experience, awesome service and even with take out - being 15 minutes from home, it was still delicious! Highly recommended from someone who values good authentic pizza, in a world where most pizza joints claim to do so but often fail!

Interesting take on a pie. The pepperoni slices were ok. Interesting sauce, different, very clean in flavor, true to tomatoes. Decent cheese. Dough was rather standard. Well cooked! - that's key. Proper time spent in over. The "wood fire" ovens are rather "electric", but I'll let that pass and blame the rotten state of society for the improvised marketing. Priced ok, order this if you're into something over typical big-chain pizza.

This was our first time ordering and we were extremely pleased with the pizza. Great crust and toppings combinations. We got the hot honey pepperoni and the buff both were so flavourful, the crust was nice and airy. I do prefer a thinner crust but that’s my preference either way a great classic pizza shop. I wish it was closer to where we live, but worth the drive.

Best pizza in whole universe. If you don't like the their pizza, then you have a problem in yourself. Humble staff and professional customer service. The owner always says you hi hello when he's around. Overall, best experience and if you don't taste their pizza, you might be missing something in the world. Highly recommend Will definitely order again. Thank you so much

Ordered the Creamy Dill Pickle pizza tonight. Pizza was cooked to perfection. You really notice a difference with the wood ovens! Toppings were plentiful and delicious. Added bacon as a recommendation and it was an excellent choice. Came with a side dill sauce that paired perfectly with the pizza. Service was great and prices reasonable considering the high quality of food you are getting. Definitely going back for more!!

Ordered take out last night -our first time trying their pizza and it was FANTASTIC. We just ordered a large Canadian and vegan brownies. The pizza was very filling and generously made with lots of toppings and cheese. The vegan brownies were also incredible. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Would definitely come back. Great experience all around!

I can't say enough good things about Old School Pizza Co.! The staff is not only incredibly friendly but also exceptionally helpful, making the ordering process a complete breeze. I've had the pleasure of trying several pizzas from here, and every single one has been a delight! The crust is flawlessly crispy, the toppings are consistently fresh and bursting with flavor. What sets Old School Pizza Co. apart is the commitment to freshness and quality—each pizza tastes like it was made with care. Without a doubt, this gem of a pizzeria is, in my opinion, the best in St. Thomas. I can confidently recommend Old School Pizza Co. to anyone in search of an exceptional pizza experience. Kudos to the team for consistently delivering outstanding pizzas. Keep up the fantastic work, Old School Pizza Co.!

Absolutely the best pizza ever!!! This past round, we tried the bacon cheese burger, butter chicken, and our usual creamy dill pickle. We come from 1.5hrs away to enjoy this. (Weekend stay) even time we plan our mini trips it's always old school pizza for dinner!!!