FEB 2023 Best New York pizza in Kentucky. It is worth it to come just for the perfectly browned crust. Add awesome sauce, excellent cheese, and fantastic fresh toppings, and it becomes more than a meal. It is an experience you have to have for yourself. Subs are great too. Michael knows how to do it like nobody else in these parts.

I have just one word for this pizza place,AWSOME. The staff,the atmosphere,and the food was spectacular. Could not ask for better

There isn't enough good things I can say about Michael's. I have been going there for many years, it is always the same. 😋👍🏽Mostly all the same friendly people working there, same great service, and delicious pizza. The location may seem out of the way for some, but definitely worth a little extra drive. 🍕👨🏽‍🍳👩🏻‍💼💯✅😍

Great food, great customer service. A real New Yorker owns the place. It's not one of those fake new York style restaurants. Opens at 3pm on Saturday.

As Brooklyn, Ambassador, this is not true Authentic New York pizza, it lacks cheese, great-tasting sauce, and oil dripping from the pizza, onto your clothes. Also, they don’t sale slices at night, which is disappointment. Customer service was excellent!

Busy little place. Menu does more than pizza. We'll have to go back and try some other things on menu. Pizza was great. Prices were reasonable. LOVED soda machine.

We tried to go to Pizza By the Pound first but there was a 45 minute wait and the staff was rude. We ended up at Michael’s and it was great. The pizza came out quickly and was reasonably priced.

Good local place for Steak and Cheese Subs with Breadsticks.

Michael's is hands down the best independently owned and ran pizza place in the area. I could eat pizza for every meal, and if I did (and could only choose one local pizza place to supply a diet consisting solely of pizza), Michael's would be the place.

The pizza is amazing! Super cheesy with a crunchy crust! The cheese sticks are also awesome. The staff are super friendly and always provide great service.

Best pizza in the region hands down. Authentic, nice char and snap on the crust, foldable but not flappy. This is the real deal folks.

My absolute fave pizza place in Paducah. Their homemade crust is to die for. Very NY style, they have a lunch special, two slices with one topping and a drink for 7 bucks from like 11-2 on weekdays and those slices are HUGE! LOVE THEM!

The spaghetti and meatballs with breadsticks was absolutely delicious. The staff were so very friendly. Definitely a wonderful place for delicious food. Can't wait to go back again.

They sexton know everyone's name. Food is delicious. From pizzas to salads to sandwiches...it's all good

We stopped in for a slice. They don’t serve slices on Saturdays. The menu board is missing prices, the outside side is faded. At 6 pm on a Saturday, 4 cars in the lot in downtown Paducah I grew up and spent 47 years in CT and we have great NY style pizza. Every pizza parlor has pizza by the slice available and it’s up front behind glass. It’s exactly like Little Italy in NYC, where you can see the pizza. Not impressed as most pizza joints I grew up in could just do slices and stay in business, it’s that good.

If you want the food service and atmosphere of a New York City pie parlor than this place is the place to stop in at while in Paducah Kentucky. A lil' rudeness (like the hotdogs place in Chicago & a many pizza joints in NYC) but all in great love and the rush to keep the line moving (customer service because NYC is a busy place 😃🙃). If you'd like a more southern hospitable place that serves pizza (because in the south ordering may take 10 minutes as many will gab- at- the- counter) there's a pizza place down the street (MM) that doesn't serve authentic NYC pies. If you want authenticity, stay here, have a seat, and remember what it feels like to eat a pie in a borough-like-parlor...

I have been following them for a long time. No matter where they move to, I will go. I have been fortunate to travel the south for many years. I have tried a lot of different pizzas and calzones, I will have to say we have the very best here in our home town. Michael’s Pizzaria gets 5 stars from me. The best Calzones around. Hands down!!!

We tried Michael's for the first time and were very impressed!! The lady that took our order was extremely helpful and very pleasant. The food came out in good time and was very good. I had the personal pepperoni pizza and a soda for only $10.05. It was delicious!! I could only eat half and that's not usually like me!! My sister had the meatball sub and said it was the best she had ever had!! Another table got a salad that looked great!! Might try that next time!!

Very good place to eat. Very friendly staff. Consistent quality and flavors. Lisa is always smiling. Best spaghetti and meatballs around. We eat here at least twice a week.

I ordered a gyros sambwich, it was the worse . 2 pieces of meat , you get more from arbys. will never ever order from them ever again !!!!!! also, they would not break down the bill for us .

Pizza was delicious and the meatball parmigiana was amazing. Delivery lady was sweet and my wife and I enjoyed the food immensely.

One of the best NY style pizzas I’ve found since moving to KY. It’s a little far from where I live, but I will definitely make the drive to eat this pizza again.

I'm from Chicago and finding a decent comparable pizza place was a chore until I found Michael's. I love it! The crust, sauce, cheese, fresh toppings...all I can say is, amazing!

Got 2 Pizzas( Pepperoni and Mushroom...and a sausage Peppahh(accent)...good pies...tasty ...cooked just right..I'm an East Coast guy from Boston....met Michae(owner)l, good guy from Brooklyn....also he called me as I was having trouble finding his pizza place with my pickup order...a nice courtesy call...love East guy attitudes. Anyway....he was wearing a Yankees hat...I commented on it...we could of gotten into it...I hate Yankees...but he seemed cool ..so I let it slide( this time Michael)....also.. girl at hotel front desk saw Michaels pizza box as I was coming back to room and said it was her favorite place ...she told me she loves his subs....I said do they have Italian sub with "the hots"....she said YEP! I'll be back for a Italian submarine with hots and no onions...thanks bud... Signed Derek (no ...not named after "The Captain"....was named after Derek Sanderson....a Boston Bruins....I hate Jeter...respect him...but hate him....just like Arod...Bernie...Mariano...all of them!

These 5 stars are for the lunch special they offer. $7.00 for two large slices of pizza and a drink. You can't beat that! I am not familiar with any other part of their menu, but this lunch special is worth a stop.

Pizza was good. Generous toppings, crispy crust, and service was quick. First time here and will be back again.

My 1st Time Eating Here Very Friendly Establishment Menu/Ordering Was Easy Prices Reasonable Quality Of Food Was Awesome Food Was Fresh, Hot, & Delicious. Loved The Crust 😍 I Would Refer/Recommended This Place Definitely Visiting Again In The Near Future!!!

I just went thru and picked up Supreme pizza, buffalo wings and 2 subs! Me and my wife are all about pizza and subs in Paducah but we just found our go to for all 3! The pizza was so delicious , the buffalo wings are second to none and I can't say enough about the super sub! You guys have gotten it figured out and I hope you don't change a thing! Trust me , no one in Paducah can touch you guys! Thank you for your hospitality and Great food!

Went in for a pizza. No wait to order even though the parking lot was full. They called every customer by name which says something about the quality of their food. The pizza was cooked perfectly. True New York style, no chain pizzas here.

M new favorite New York style pizza. Get extra cheese, it’s SOOO good! Their sandwiches and gyros are awesome also. I always want everything on their menu, but seem to be addicted to their pizza. Super friendly and the food is delicious. This is my go-to pizza spot!