Frequently mentioned in reviews: good (12) service (11) time (11) ordered (8) salad (8) great (8)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.

5/5 Britt Around T. 1 year ago on Google
Every single thing we ordered from Pine Creek Inn far exceed all expectations….everything from the steak braciole down to the pasta salad and the salad bar. Even the service here was excellent! Fantastic dining spot along Route 6 in Galeton.
3 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 David Z. 1 year ago on Google
Fantastic place. People were very friendly. Unlike the log cabin in just up the road. Had a great meal and drinks. As we were sitting at the table. Looked out the window and there were four deer. Two still good n spots. Fantastic. Loved the place
3 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Brian M. 1 year ago on Google
Always have had a good experience. Food priced as it should be for current inflation. I have seen some people mention the prices are too high for the area. I disagree. Service has always been good and food has always been good. My wife and I enjoy stopping for a few drinks and a small bit to eat.
3 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Ellen S. 2 years ago on Google
Nicest servers and the food was amazing. Everything was homemade cooking at it's best. Sunday Buffet so worth stopping in for the meal. Shout out to Jackie and Debbie; thanks for a pleasant dining experience. Appreciate the wonderful cooking! We'll be back.
2 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Joe D. 1 year ago on Google
Just passing through the area and was driving part at lunch time. Glad I decided to stop. Great Rueben, very friendly service, decent prices. Definitely recommend!
2 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Alexandra S. 2 years ago on Google
Best martini I’ve had in a long time! Prime rib was excellent as always. I’ve also ordered their clams appetizer on many occasions and it’s one of my faves here as well. Service was great! We love coming to Pine Creek Inn every time we visit Potter County to hunt. Definitely stop by if you haven’t yet tried it; you’ll be glad you did! (I got to see Rudy again too!) 😉
2 people found this review helpful 👍
4/5 Robert B. 1 year ago on Google
Food was amazing. I sat at the bar and was served in two minutes. I got a stake and salad bar. The was perfectly cooked the salad bar was well stocked. I think if they had another server the service would have been as good as the food. The waitress gave me great service with as busy as they were.
2 people found this review helpful 👍
4/5 Laura P. 2 years ago on Google
There is an actual chef not a cook ( not that any of our local cooks are bad), but theirs is not afraid to create "out of the box" foods. If you want something that is not everyday fair that is delicious you have to try their specials. They are the 💣
2 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Kenny L. 5 years ago on Google
Spent the day antique shopping in Galeton and needed somewhere to eat- I’m so happy we chose to stop at the Pine Creek Inn. Broiled Haddock was absolutely delicious and the salad bar was actually very good, with a lot of options. Husband said the burger was fantastic. We will definitely be back!
2 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Kevin G. 1 year ago on Google
We had their pizza to go the first night and it was a big hit so we went back for the dine in experience. They only had two waitresses working the entire bar and dining area. They did a great job keeping up and were very friendly. We will most likely come back if we are in the area.
2 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Anne Lugg A. 1 year ago on Google
I don’t know how I’ve lived in the area so long without going here til now— wow! Was craving a reuben in Potter County and they did not disappoint. The fresh cut fries were just right. It was difficult to turn down the lobster bisque special and prime rib on the board out front. 😬 Reasonable prices and awesome atmosphere.
2 people found this review helpful 👍
1/5 Charles F. 1 year ago on Google
The prices are really high . I would not expect a bill of almost $30. for 2 beacon cheeseburgers and two orders of fries . By the time you leave you feel like you were just robbed !!! I thought I would give it a second try the first time I ordered prime rib we waited about an hour and a half , I ordered it medium well instead it came out very rare after waiting all that time . But they did make things right that time . Today was all together different their prices are really extremely high and not even close to what they are worth. I wish l would have gone to Red Lobster instead . At least I would have been eating lobster instead of hamburger .
2 people found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Scott C. 6 months ago on Google
Awesome food, great service, and very clean establishment.
1 person found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Marlin G. 1 year ago on Google
Great food and drinks. Server very pleasant.
1 person found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Victor T. 1 year ago on Google
excellent experience-went there for dinner about an hour before closing and the food and service were outstanding
1 person found this review helpful 👍
5/5 Dennis R. 1 year ago on Google
The food was great, but our waitress was OUTSTANDING.She was fun and very attentive. She made our lunch extra special 👌 We were at the restaurant Sunday, 5/15/22 @ 3:30PM
1 person found this review helpful 👍
1/5 Pam H. 1 year ago on Google
Prices are high for very poor food quality. I ordered shrimp dinner for almost $20. I got 6 very small in size shrimp that were as hard as a rock. Even put them in gray which did not help to soften them especially since gravy was cold. Then my bake potatoes were just as hard as the shrimp. They were made in the microwave.
5/5 Steven G. 1 year ago on Google
Always a great place to eat. The food is excellent as is the service.
1/5 Angie G. 1 year ago on Google
In town for the Woodsman Carnival. Not many restaurants to choose from and it was my husbands bday so we decided to try. Sadly, the peaches on salad bar were fermented. BBQ ribs were on the daily specials and 4 of us ordered them. Super tough slab of pork ribs with a weird tangy sauce poured over the top. Needless to say, we were very disappointed with our experience. However, the burger was good and the grilled corn on the cob was good but that’s all could say good with our group of 7.
5/5 Daisy C. 1 year ago on Google
Very good food and waitress was very friendly and made sure we had everything we needed.
1/5 William V. 1 year ago on Google
Overpriced poor service and horrible food. Unfortunately this place has took a huge turn for the worst with the new owners. Service was horrible 3 of us ordered food my burger was like a hockey puck the roll and chips were stale the onions tasted like fried fish. The cheese curds were under cooked. Fish fry and Mac and cheese bites were also terrible and you couldn’t even tell them about it cause the service was that bad. Along with the insect droppings on the plate over by the salad bar. Hopefully the new owners can make the correct changes and make it like it was. But that being said it was my first and last time going there with new ownership and probably the last.
5/5 Don S. 10 months ago on Google
Great food and great service, we visit every time we visited Pennsylvania this is a must stop for lunch!!
5/5 Susan T. 10 months ago on Google
Always enjoy the soup and salad bar! Great service.
3/5 Taylor H. 8 months ago on Google
Went for Father’s Day, first time eating here in a long time. Food was good but the steak came out unseasoned and was bland. I will definitely return but If I can make a recommendation would be to start seasoning the steak or at least marinating it. Even if it’s salt and pepper a good steak needs seasoning, helps create that crust we all know and love.
3/5 Jill B. 9 months ago on Google
Had the special Italian Stromboli Slice. It was a little hard to slice with a dinner knife. There were only 2 other customers in there for lunch. Not sure if I would go again.
5/5 Jennifer D. 4 months ago on Google
We went on Saturday night for prime rib and it was amazing !! We liked it so much that we ordered it the following Saturday for takeout. Would highly recommend !!
5/5 Rob M. 4 months ago on Google
They are so nice. Food was awesome. Service was awesome. Never waited for a drink. They were especially nice to my 13 yo son. Treated him like a king. Lisa is the best.

Call +1 814-435-2682 Open on Google Maps

Amenities

Parking
- ✓️ Free parking lot
- ✓️ Plenty of parking
Payments
- ✓️ Cheques
- ✓️ Debit cards
- ✓️ Credit cards
Offerings
- ✓️ Beer
- ✓️ Wine
- ✓️ Coffee
- ✓️ Alcohol
- ✓️ Spirits
- ✓️ Cocktails
- ✓️ Salad bar
- ✓️ Quick bite
- ✓️ Comfort food
- ✓️ Small plates
- ✓️ All you can eat
- ✓️ Healthy options
- ✓️ Happy-hour drinks
Popular for
- ✓️ Lunch
- ✓️ Dinner
- ✓️ Solo dining
Accessibility
- ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible seating
- ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible car park
- ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Dining options
- ✓️ Lunch
- ✓️ Dinner
- ✓️ Dessert
- ✓️ Seating
Service options
- ✓️ Dine-in
- ✗ Delivery
- ✓️ Takeaway

Trends

Last updated: 23 April, 2024

Similar Restaurants nearby

Perma Stone Inn

American restaurant

👍👍 Great place off 6 in Galeton. We came on a Sunday evening for dinner. The Subs and Burgers are massive, same with the personal pizzas. The pizza wasn’t cut but not a big deal. The lighting makes it feel like your in a diner not a bar. They also charged $4.49 for a bacon topping on the pizza. There i...

$$ $$

4.60 (488 reviews)

Nickel Valley Resorts

Restaurant

👍 Nice country bar. Friendly bar tender and owner. Has an outdoor pavilion and smoking is permitted as well outside. Drinks were a tad on the pricey side for being absolutely in the middle of nowhere. Stayed in one of the cabins after having a few drinks. The one we rented was around $150 and was very...

4.70 (111 reviews)

Wooden Nickel Tavern

Restaurant

👍👍 Our Jeep group loves this off the beaten path place. Great service and food. The Blue Gill sandwich is my go to.

4.70 (83 reviews)

View more...

Last updated: 23 April, 2024

PINE CREEK INN - American restaurant in Pike Township, United States

PINE CREEK INN

Address

Website

Contact

Price rating

Rating on Google Maps

Working Hours

Featured Reviews

Amenities

Parking

Payments

Offerings

Popular for

Accessibility

Dining options

Service options

Trends

Similar Restaurants nearby