Always great Pizza! and we always have great service, everyone here is so wonderful ❤️, this is our go to place in Pleasanton! They are also open late! The pizza sauce is always spot on and the dough is perfect every time! Great flavors!!

Wow, the pizza here is awesome!! The crust is the perfect thickness and just the right amount of crispiness.

Very thin crust pizza with amazing toppings at the heart of downtown Pleasanton. Party size pizza is sufficient for 4-6 people. Garlic Bread came like a little pizza which was really tasty. Tips: try some extra twists like their olive oil, Mayonnaise on top.

New York Pizza Pleasanton has unique toppings. I saw the "Gyro Pizza" and I knew I had to try it. There were gryo toppings sprinkled across the pizza with a mix of pizza's traditional toppings like tomato sauce and cheese. There were plenty of indoors seats when I visited on a Saturday night (-11:00 PM). There is also an outdoor table if preferred. Their online menu seems to have more options than their in-person menu, so be sure to take a look (or make your own). Overall, a good spot for takeout with some unique toppings. I'd swing by again to mix and match even more.

Nothing great about this place. The Pizza is ordinary. Too little sauce or toppings. Overly priced. Just the name is New York Pizza. I ordered two pizza. Meat combo and Margarita. The Tomato sauce was hard to find. Tomatoes were raw and poorly chopped. No presentation skills. Meat was not much variety... Except only on the ordering menu. It's operated by Afghan owner. I am not against discrimination, but to compete, I didn't notice anything above the crowd. The service was lousy. I asked for crushed pepper 🌶️ the response was we have them on the counter by the side.. you can take from there. I won't recommend. For your money, there are other better choices in Pleasanton downtown for Pizza 🍕 or to meet your appetite.

Please don't waste your time for pizza. We just order Half chicken and Half Peproni. The chicken was Old dry like a eating wood or rubber. Please look the picture below. I am very disappointed.

Good specialty vegetarian pizza! Great choice for a quick and nice pizza.

Love the pizza here! They also have several flavors of ice cream 😋 when you order pizza by the slice, they are BIG slices!

Calling this greasy abomination "New York pizza" is a crime: The crust has a cardboard taste/smell to it, sauce is basically tomato paste, italian seasoning + a ton of salt. Tiramisu's poorly made too.

At first my friends and I thought 6 dollars was a lot for a slice of pizza because we were used to costco prices. The portions are HUGE i ate one slice for breakfast lunch and dinner the next day. The crust was so good and I totally recommend this place, super cheap and very good!~

Top tier pizza. You can order a slice for a out 5 bucks and they give you a huge slice that is basically two. John Madden visited this place along with many other celebrities. They have Muslim friendly peperoni which isn't made of pork. Also, the same man has been working here for the past two decades and he deserves more attention. Highly recommended.

I have been here a few times now with my kids because they love NY pizza. It's always simple and good.

Everyone loves New York Pizza. They always have great coupons available, too.

They have the best pizza , customer service. And deals . I love their pizza

Cool place. Nice location. Friendly workers. Good food. Something about paying $30 for a small pizza and coke kinda ruins it for me.

I read the reviews before I came. Some good some bad. So I decided to try it out. The look: ....Authentic. As in, a little rundown and could use a little added paint. It captures the bizarre nature of now york through bizarre choice of artwork. The service: ....authentic. As in, a little underwhelming yet hospitable. Exactly what you want and find in NYC. Dont look into this too much the staff is great. The food: unlike the negative reviews.... I found my pizza stacked with toppings, perfectly sauced, and the crispy thing crust is unlike anything I have found in New York. Nevertheless, it was next level. It was floppy like your find in the city but had a unique crispness that made it that much better. Overall for a snack or meal under $10 this is a great place to start your food journey in Almeda CA.

I had high expectations, but very disappointed. I ordered the two slices of the pepperoni pizza and it took me back to my days in the elementary hotline lunch. My pizza looked completely different from the other pizzas that were being served. I couldn't even take a picture because it was so bad. I did take a picture of my brother's BBQ chicken pizza that looked and tasted pretty good. If you decide to come here, don't get a pepperoni slice.

I wanted to try this place to see if it was any good. I'm glad I only ordered a slice. Pizza dough was soggy and the pizza itself was just warm. How do you have just warm pizza. Tasted like the cheese barely melted. Not tasty or flavorful. I will not be revisiting this place.