We were so happy to find a restaurant that offered takeout. It was pretty busy in Port A when we went in mid-July. One evening, we just wanted to get some food and eat at the beach. We called our order in, and though you can tell it was busy, we weren't rushed. They even called us when the order was ready! My husband and I split a pizza and Greek salad. Both were superb! Lots of toppings on the salad. Good basic vinaigrette. The pizza was the perfect amount of everything. It was our favorite meal in Port A!

Upon sitting down I immediately noticed our silverware was dirty which pretty much gave me a bad feeling about this place. Pizza tasted okay but nothing special. For what it cost I expected a much better. The pizza size portions were not terrible I will give them that. Basically somewhat over priced thin crust pizza that took forever to cook. Casual atmosphere was the best part of the place as you had green space to walk around, enjoy the ocean breeze, come and go as you liked, etc. Waitress hardly ever came around to check on us, nor update us on why the food was taking so long. Maybe we just caught them on a bad day - but I wouldn't go back for what it cost and what I ended up with for the price. I have been to worse places...but I have been to better.

So happy they had vegan cheese ! The pizza was very yummy and the crust had a nice texture. Not too busy when we went. Plenty of staff who were friendly. We ordered the Greca and subbed the feta for daiya cheese. We also had a Greek salad which was tasty as well.

Superb pizza and spaghetti! I am very picky when it comes to pizza and this pizza is fabulous. It’s coal fired which gives it a delicious flavor. The spaghetti was also incredible. The staff was super sweet and attentive. The prickly pear Prosecco is a must as well. We loved this place so much, we ate there twice during our stay and also ordered enough to eat at home. The 12 inch pizzas are more like 15 inches and can feed about 2 people.

What a hidden gem! We watched an outdoor movie while waiting for our table. You would never know this place existed as it's tucked into a neighborhood. The pizza was the best we've ever had! We will definitely return when we are in the area again!

We had an excellent dinner. We were very happy with the drinks and definitely the service. When compared to our local coal fired pizza, this was head and shoulders above the other. If we are down this way again, we'll stop in.

The wait at Lisabella’s would have been over two hours so we hopped over to Dylan’s to see if the wait was better. Got sat right away but took 15 minutes to get a waitress. After we found it it was great from the service to the incredible salad and pizza. Mosquitos are HORRIBLE at Cinnamon Shore. Be prepared and bring bug spray. Do that and you’ll have a great time. We were sitting pretty while others were slapping bugs all night.

Hopping spot. We phoned in our order. The wait for food was 45-60 minutes. We ordered two pizzas, spaghetti & meatballs, and a salad. Everything was excellent. Pizzas are hand-pulled dough cooked in the coal oven. We got there before our food was ready and ordered drinks, and sat outside to wait.