Fantastic Amazing Pizza Homemade dough crust cooked just right homemade pizza sauce AND local ingredients. Best pizza hands down, this pizza beats any in the Madison area. Staff are VERY attentive Owner came out personally to see how our food was. The cheese bread was loaded with fresh cheese. Definitely could tell cheese bread sauce was homemade tasted very healthy organic. LOVE the atmosphere

Fantastic pizza and atmosphere! Best pizza we've ever had! Our server and one of the kitchen staff (assuming the owners but not verified) both chatted with us and even told tales of their time spent in our town as well as about their establishment. Very friendly and personable. Will definitely visit and dine again when back in the area!

Love this place! The beer is very cold, the pizza is awesome 😋. Homemade crust and cooked right. We had tried a few of their other pizzas before, but jumped in for the muddy water this time. It has everything in it they offer. We were a bit worried about the crust being soggy, but it was perfect and all of the toppings worked well together. This is a place will be glad to come back to!

Best pizza we’ve had in a loooooong time! We had the BLT and Garden Joy pizzas, and both were packed with flavor. The BLT came with whole yellow grape tomatoes since they were in season, and had the perfect amount of mayonnaise. The Garden Joy crust was made with 6-7 secret ingredients and could be eaten on its own, but with the marinara sauce, tons of cheese and the toppings, the depths of flavor were endless! Atmosphere was cozy. Service was wonderful. Had a great conversation with the owner. Highly recommend!

AMAZING EXPERIENCE! We were passing through town and searched online for a restaurant with gluten-free options. We found Muddy Waters Pizza Pub and enjoyed the best pizza we've ever had! Great atmosphere and very friendly staff. I wish we lived closer. We'll be looking forward to our next visit to Prairie du Chien so we can eat here again.

This place is awesome! Pizza is delicious and the atmosphere is fantastic. Friendly people. If you are ever in the area I highly recommend stopping and enjoy the pizza of your choice! The fresh ingredients, homemade crust and sauce are out of this world.

AMAZING PIZZA! Wife and I had the chicken bacon ranch with added jalapeños and sun dried tomatoes, such a fantastic combo. Everything worked together and there was nothing that was overwhelming. The crust was thin but still thick enough to be the perfect vessel to deliver all of the unique flavors. We will definitely be back to try another one. HIGHLY RECOMMEND eating here if you are in the Prairie Du Chien area.

Wisconsin Tavern Pizza at its very tastiest... homage crust, homemade sauce, local veggies and local meat under a layer of fresh wisconsin cheese!!!! SK

Order more than you usually do, because you're going to want more of this pizza! Ordered pizza for carry out. It was amazing. Unique and delicious taste. Crust is phenomenal as is the sauce. Really happy we tried this place on our visit in town.

I decided to take a quick drive from La Crosse to Prairie Du Chien to check out the pizza here. It is amazing! I ordered a Hipster, Margherita, and the garlic cheese bread. All phonomenal! I brought home lots of left overs intentionally. I met Todd one of the owners, a very nice fellow. He takes pride in the food he makes and he most certainly should! For sure some of the best pizza I have ever had! The Atmosphere is great, even though I was the only one there (it was early on opening day of gun deer season), oh man how Wisconsin is that? I am most certainly taking my kids on a road trip down there soon!! Treat yourself to a gem of SW Wisconsin! I wish I had taken photos, next time I will.

Tried out this place and was not disappointed. The cheese bread was amazing. The pizza was good but highly over sauced (at least for me. Something I will remember and will ask for less next time). Good service as well.