You can spend the same at Pizza Hut or dominos, and in some cases you’ll get better pizza, but they offer a higher quality of toppings and a selection of sauces that the rest don’t. They aren’t gourmet, and you could definitely grab something at the rock or Fat Zack’s or the like, that will feel fancier and have different ingredients, but it’s just what you are looking for. If it’s easy good pizza then Pizza Time is a good option. We got a deal with two large three toppings and a medium cheesy bread. It was more expensive than I thought it would be/should be. One was a bbq sauce, chicken, bacon, onion and it was great! The regular crust was so/so, but the pizza itself was great. The other was red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, and green pepper. There wasn’t a whole lot of sausage or pepperoni, and all in all it was a mediocre pizza. The cheesy bread was fantastic, though, full of flavor, tons of cheese, I highly recommend grabbing that with your order. All in all, there’s better pizza and there’s worse pizza all in the same price range.

I was very excited to try pizza from here and I ordered through Doordash. I just highly suggest Pick up because our pizza was so cold.. other than that the pizza was good. I will pick up next time.

So I have been going to pizza time for quite some time now. I have to give a glowing review because the owner is absolutely amazing. I had requested for them to get separate cooking sheets and such for gluten free pizzas long ago, and they actually do have that now. They are careful with gluten allergies when you ask them to be, and their staff is very attentive and helpful. It's wonderful being able to get a GOOD gluten free pizza. Thank you so much for giving me a great option for pizza! Pizza time is awesome!

I am an OTR truck driver and was doing a 34 hour break in Sumner. I read all the reviews and decided to give Pizza Time a try and I am so glad that I did. Everybody from the person who took my order to the delivery driver was friendly and courteous. I ordered the PT perfection and I was impressed by the pizza ingredients and the size. My only regret is that I won't be in the area long enough to try their other offerings. But the next time I'm in the area, it will be Puyallup Pizza Time for sure!!!! Thanks for a great meal experience!!!!

called my pizza in for delivery and the young man and young lady that answered the phone we're very professional. Unfortunately it took 55 minutes for my pizza to be delivered and it was cold my wings were cold not a lot of toppings on my Hawaiian pizza We have ordered many times before and the pizzas were always great nice toppings so maybe I just got them a bad day ☹️ I will order it from them again and give it another chance and hopefully my pizza and wings will be a little bit warmer and the toppings a little bit more Thank you Adrian for the update.I will definitely be coming back. It's nice to hear from the store and know they care.

I tried the new dry rub buffalo wings and they are addictive!! I think I’m done but then after a minute, maybe I’ll have just one or two more! Pizza and cheesy bread were great as well! Trust me though, you gotta try these wings!

always have had great experiences from delivery and take away orders. very friendly and professional staff. tasty pizza and yummy salads. we love this place and we order it when we have outta town guests so they can have a taste of the local pizza place. the PT Perfection is our favorite…a little bit of everything! the deluxe pizza is great for those like me who like everything on their pizza. great job yawl!

Pleasantly surprised. We moved to the area about 9 months ago and have been gradually checking out the local pizza options. Pizza Time was easy to order and arrived exactly on-time. Everything we ordered was a crowd-pleaser. In terms of big chains, this is more on the Pizza Hut end of the spectrum--classic, comforting, and tasty.

First time here, went off reviews. Let me say, it was delicious. No greasy pizza. I bought 8 pizza for work the next day. Everyone continued to praise the pizza! Awsomen crew, awsome place. DELICIOUS PIZZA!! Delicious was here!

I'm just going to say I choose this place over any other pizza place including pizza hut and dominos. It's so good it's the only place I go now. Very friendly staff btw, even the delivery staff.

I blast from the past! Didn’t know they were still pizza times. This was nostalgia because we always ordered pizza time back in the 90s. This is my second time at the Puyallup location and both times I have forgotten to take pictures and do a video review because I always dive headfirst into it. I highly recommend ordering over the phone for the best deals and then picking up in person so it’s piping hot. I live far down Canyon Road and still the pizza was perfect by the time I got home. Order the deluxe!

My daughter and I stay in Puyallup every year for a couple of nights and enjoy the fair (our tradition). We have always ordered pizza for delivery from the hotels flyers. This time we decided to choose ourselves, and go pick up. I wish we would have found you years ago.Your pizza is amazing, your customer service is impeccable! My 3 grandkids said this was the best pizza they got to eat on their beds at the hotel (another tradition). We will come see you again next year, or anytime we are in Puyallup. Thank you for making our pizza night a great one !!!

This is the best takeout pizza, it never disappoints me. it is always super fresh & the cheese they use on their pizzas is always good quality. I also like that they stay open later than most places!

Grew up with Pizza Time being the go-to joint in West Seattle. It was a nostalgic joy to have the same flavors I remembered from my childhood replicated from this location. Can't wait until we can order from here again!

I ordered takeout from Pizza Time a couple of nights ago and it was the best pizza I’ve had here in Puyallup thus far!! I was greeted when I came in by a woman and she was very sweet! I told her pizza was my favorite and I was excited to try since moving here!! The food was incredible to say the least and I know for a fact I will be making this my regular spot!! ❤️

This is a great Community Based Business!!! Dough is fresh, pizzas are LOADED me and my 3 kids can NEVER finish a full pie they are so filling!!! Stop here and grab a bite! It is mostly to go though they have some limited seating and outdoor picnic benches!!!