Good pizza and nice to have an adult only place to eat. Also nice that the outdoor section accommodates those with furry friends. Parking is the only issue as there isn't much available.

Restaurant is pretty good. I struggled with a 3 or 4. Nothing overly impressed me to give it a 4, but nothing was bad enough for a 3. Solid 3.5! The staff is attentive and the food is good. They have a decent selection of food to chose from; a little something for everyone! For 1 Sicilian margarita and 1 small “Mother Earth”, add sausage, pizza the total bill was $40 (not including tip). They use locally sourced ingredient which is nice, but overall still kind of expensive based on similar places prices. Keep in mind, it’s 21 and over, so kids are not welcome. Staff wore masks, but there was no signage encouraging patrons to do so - at least none I saw. Overall, I would say no to going back, but it might not be my first choice.

Don’t skip the appetizer! Cheesy bread was so so good. The pizza options and calzones are all excellent as well. This is a fun adult atmosphere (no kids or teens under 21) that’s chill and quaint. Prices are comparable to other local pizza shops.

This place is WICKED GOOD! The cocktails are absolutely out of this world cool and delicious....and the pizza is too with very high quality ingredients. The vibe here is also very hip and relaxing and the service is top notch! Great food. Great drinks. Cute place. Perfect date or hang out spot. Love this addition to downtown Puyallup. Rustic, modern and mega tasty. Thank you wicked pie pizza for a great experience every time!

This may be the best pizza in Washington State, this place is incredible! Reminds me of NYC pizza which is so hard to find here! The staff is super nice and the Bloody Mary literally comes with a little mini slice of pizza in it lol. For pizza options, there are so many awesome combos to decide from and the cool thing that you can do is get half half on pies. We went with the Mob Boss (omg so good with the meatballs) and Flying Pig on one and then Say It Ain't So and the Puyallup on the other. Plenty leftover for us to enjoy again the following day for pizza breakfast :)

Tasty 21+ oven pizza place with a very chill vibe. Pizza flavors are really creative (recommend "Say It Ain't So!") and the service is phenomenal. It's definitely one of those "if I were to die after this meal, I'd be in a happy place" kinda places. A huge fan of the flatbread, also the thin crust to sauce to cheese to toppings ratio is perfect. Absolutely divine and classy place for a date night.

Really good pizza and wings! This will be my go to pizza place from now on. Edit: I don't know what has happened but the last couple of times the service has not been great. A few weeks ago I ordered online and they completely forgot us. My husband waited for half an hour then finally went in to see what was going on and they said "Oops, sorry we forgot about your order. Here's a free dessert." No biggie, it happens. Then, yesterday, I made an online order and my husband got to the restaurant to pick it up at the time it was supposed to be ready and he had to wait an HOUR past that for our order! Staff were apologetic, said they were very busy, and here's a free dessert to compensate you. Well, that free dessert was MOLDY! 🤮. It's too bad, because their pizza is some of the best, but I won't be going back.

The food was absolutely excellent (and not too slow) and the portion sizes were huge. The server was friendly and attentive, and the environment was very clean. The prices weren't too high, but we were glad to have visited on Sunday, when Wicked Pie Pizza has an all-day happy hour. I highly recommend their meatball calzone and the cheesy bread appetizer. (More sensitive visitors should know that the interior is quite dark and the music is loud, but we loved that!)

Pizza was delicious, service was average. I was waiting at the front near the sign that said wait here to be seated. The servers were busy, but a couple came in behind me and were seated immediately, while I was still standing there waiting. I finally had to ask one of them for help, and they stopped to assist. The two servers were busy, i am just mildly annoyed that people that walked in after me were helped first while I was ignored.

Supper good pizza spot!! The margarita pizza add balsamic vinegar glaze. So yummy! I also enjoyed the bloody merry the service was great as well. Super chill

Melissa provided fantastic service! Cheese bread and pizza were delicious! The crust was so good, and the sausage had great flavor. The *only* downside is that the music was really loud. We'll definitely be back though.

Wicked Pie Pizza never disappoints (the food is incredible, try it), but I want to leave a review to specifically talk about my experience yesterday. I was there around lunchtime as a party of three and we had Candy as our server. She was kind, personable, and attentive from the start. We had ordered multiple items and Candy checked in with us several times to ensure we didn’t need anything. Other staff came by as well to make sure we had what we needed and were very kind. Towards the end of our meal, we realized we hadn’t received one of the items ordered and had waited awhile for it. We notified Candy, who notified the cook, and they both apologized profusely for the miscommunication. They ended up offering the item to us for free, in addition to another item, and quickly prepared it for us. I appreciated the extent they went to ensure our experience was a positive one and for their kindness and generosity. I haven’t received that level of customer service at a restaurant in a very long time, if ever. Not only that, but the food is always top notch. Thank you for a memorable and wonderful lunch, Wicked Pie Pizza. Specifically to Candy, thank you for the excellent customer service and making our experience such an enjoyable one!

Wikipedia is always busy when I go in there and that's for good reason. They have excellent food and it's made fresh to order and it's hot when I go into either take it home and has take out or eat it there. They've got spirits and beers and any other beverage in my life. The staff is always really friendly the young ladies that work the floor the hostess or waitresses even the bartender very very kind and very pleasant appearance. I've never had to wait very long that most maybe 3 minutes. And the restrooms are nice and clean on Friday or Saturday evening it's very popular very crowded but it's exciting and fun it's just what you want if you're feeling like having a good time socializing with friends over good food. I'd go there I recommend it it's in downtown Puyallup and well it's a cute location it still has that Hometown feeling as opposed to Seattle's slick culture with wealth and money it's kind of sterile there. Anyway I would go try it out and meet your own opinion but I don't think you're going to go wrong.

I suggest removing the "family friendly" description as you are a 21+ establishment. This is the reason we decided to check this place out. Just to be turned away at the door. No thanks for time wasted. Two stars because the person who told us we couldn't dine there was friendly, but hated to waste my time.

Great place to unwind at the end of the day, or any other moment. Service and food quality were outstanding 😊.

Took waitress over 5 min to notice me standing at the door. She was sitting socializing at a table while myself and another group waited for her. It was decently slow so I can understand sitting with guests to chill but when people come through the door, maybe get up and help them. I then was given the wrong pizza. Shame on me for not checking the box. Very expensive for the amount of food. Quite disappointing. Won’t be back.

Went over the weekend for a date night. The atmosphere is great, nice and intimate. They had live music towards the tail end of our meal. Service was great but what was more impressive was quality of the food. We shred a large ‘Chosen One’ and it was fantastic. I couldn’t recommend this place more if you’re looking for a nicer style pizza.

This pizzeria and bar is such a great local find. Really enjoyed the pesto flatbread and I can't wait to come back and have it again. The staff is very kind and helpful and the atmosphere is very cool. Think wood with bricks rustic while chandeliers and rock music lay overhead. Great vibe to check out downtown and get some quality food.

Awesome pizza. If your in puyallup and over 21 craving some awesome food check this place out. Nice atmosphere but it's small so it does get busy quick. Staff is nice and friendly and quick. Have been here quiet a few times and it's always good. Parking is all on street on meridian or side streets, so not always easy to find a spot.

Delicious pizza! I recommend the garlic bread. So good. Our host was also very friendly and greeted us fast.

I love this place. It’s my favorite pizza south of Seattle. A great crust and quality toppings. For about a year a friend and I were hitting all the top rated pizza places in Seattle. I always get the margarita pizza at each place so I’m doing a fair comparison. Wicked pie is right there with the best in Seattle IMO. There are a couple in Seattle that I prefer TBH.. but why drive to Ballard when Wicked Pie is great! The flying pig is our go to for football games. The cheesy bread is great. The pear salad is so good I sometimes go there just for that. The atmosphere is simple yet kinda hip. They play great music.. just love the vibe.

For a margarita, pizza. I came in to sit at the bar and enjoy a beer and wait for my pizza to get done. I waited at the bar for about 10 minutes before the bartender so graciously came up from what I feel like threw a menu at me and walked away. Then came back about four or five minutes later from standing on the end of the bar, playing with the cell phone and chatting it up with a coworker came over and asked me what he could do for me, I asked for a pint of Mack and Jack’s and for my to go pizza. The best part of this was the beer and pizza. If this is the service that you’re looking for I’d give this guy a promotion, but if this is the service that repels people from coming to your business because your staff are not attentive, I would fire him