The Good: We were seated quickly, and our waitress was very pleasant and nice. The establishment was clean and comfortable. The Bad: I've heard great things about Squires which is why I was surprised that my pizza was just "fine." My wife ordered the chicken cacciatore and she also described it as "fine." This is highly disappointing because of a $60 price tag (granted my son had food, too), it definitely was not, at all, worth it. As a matter of fact, the more I think about it, the more I got ripped off. The quality was just not good. I can make a pizza of the same quality at home. Just get some flatbread, marinara sauce, cheese, etc. and you can make the same pizza at home. There is nothing special about the pizza here. For the gravy fries, it tasted like the gravy came from a can. Judgment: Overall, I don't recommend this place at all.

Pizza looked better than it tasted. But everyone enjoyed it. The wait staff was very pleasant. Nice size space to accommodate 20 people

Parking was a breeze. I waited to be seated way too long as servers walked around me like I wasn't standing there. My server, once I was seated was the sweetest, very nice and great customer service. The calamari was not bad. The sampler, however, was terrible. The lasagna was old, the meatball was tasteless and the sausage was more of the same. The garlic bread wasn't horrible. Ice tea machine was broken so no unsweetened iced tea. Overall will not return.

My dad and I stumbled across this place after getting lost and I’m so glad we did! This place is very clean and organized. It has a nice quiet atmosphere. The service was great and the food was hot and fresh. Thank you squires and keep up the good work !

Good service Great food spacious dining area oh and did i say great food definitely going back cant wait to tell my colleagues

I must say this place did not live up to expectations.. I drove 15 min just to get carry out because I was tired of my usual delivery place. I paid 15$ for a small pizza and got the smallest pizza I’ve ever seen, not in any way shareable.. taste is basic. I looked at their online pics and saw what the wings looked like and decided to order them.. they did not look like the Pics very far from it. They gave me all drums and the wings were fatty and soggy and barley had sauce. The only okay thing was the garlic fries and even they weren’t worth 7$. Won’t be returning

This is, Hands Down, the BEST Pizza!! Period! The only, ONLY, reason why I sometimes deviate and get pizza from another place is because I like (LOVE) Red Peppers on my pizza, and Squires only has green and banana peppers. If Squires is reading this, Please add red peppers to the toppings list, God that would be the best pizza Ever and I'd never have to go anywhere else for pizza again!!!!! Oh, and ricotta cheese would be a great addition to a pizza as well. But Definitely the red peppers!!! But Squires, by far, has the best quality ingredients and the Best tasting sauce!

Squire's has been one of the go-to places my coworkers and I order from during our grueling 12 hour weekend shifts. The food is consistently good. There is a wide array on the menu ranging from pizza (World renowned pizza may I add) and great italian dishes, as well as the staples found in most sub shops. And the restaurant is a place I am proud to take my lady friends, its always clean and there is never anyone creating a ruckus. I highly recommend both the carry out and the dining room. This establishment has become a Baltimore institution.

Second visit and it was perfect, we was a group of seven. We all enjoy our food and drinks. We even had the pleasure to enjoy life music on a Saturday night. Waitress/Bartender was on very friendly and attentive. Will definitely will come back.

Dined in the bar area due to time factor. The server was attentive and we did not have to wait long. The meal was very fresh with generous portions. The salad was excellent, crisp and fresh, with a tasty house dressing. It was great to have a salad without a bunch of recycled looking lettuce and a bunch of core mixed in as filler to stretch the portion. I love the individual pizza size... perfect just enough. The women restroom very clean. The resturant at the end of the evening was being cleaned and you could smell the disinfectant and witness the sanitizing of the restaurant. The floor had a clean fresh look. Squire's earned the 5 🌟 rating easily. Thank you for such a wonderful dining experience.

Food wasn’t the best I’ve ever had but it was acceptable. The pizza and the fries were bland, the fries had no salt but the deserts were good. Delivery was fast. For the price and taste it’s nothing that would make me go out of my way to get.

October 2022 I used to come here all the time, probably 300 visits in about 20 years up until the mid 90s, but I haven’t been here since 2016 and maybe only 10 times overall over the past 20 years. The food and service have fallen off considerably which is why I haven’t been back, as well as not being local anymore. I was here in 2016 for a visit to the area and everything was very forgettable, I was so disappointed. So I stopped in for a small pizza while in the area for another visit and I was again not impressed. The cheese was good and the crust was exactly like I remember from all the pizza I ate here as a kid, but the sauce was beyond terrible. It tasted very generic and was too salty, as if cheap ingredients are going into the sauce. Living in the Philadelphia area for years now, I have come to know absolutely exceptional Italian food, and Squires is not that anymore. The magic of the 80s is lost here, and this place is living off an old reputation and its iconic name in the area. But for pizza that tastes like the Squires from the 80s, when I’m in the area I’ll stick to Pizza Johns. Not the best but much better than here.

Excellent!! Get the Squire's Special pizza! Fresh ingredients, sauce, and toppings! Beautifully decorated with ample dining room, bar, and carry out.

I was with a huge party so I didn't get anything extravagant but I can at least say the onion rings were banging, and the Maryland crab soup was delicious!! The waitress said she had been there for 20 years or so and she really knew her stuff! She knew how long each item cooked and appropriate times to order when we were still waiting for others in our party. She was very attentive!

Not like I remember. Squire’s used to be THE place to get authentic Italian food and the best pizza in the area. Came here tonight after about 20 years and was very disappointed. Food was “meh”, server was quick but not personable at all, and the ambience has changed. They went from cloth napkins to napkin dispensers on the table. One of our bread plates was dirty. Nothing here seems to be made from scratch anymore either. I feel like a meal at Olive Garden would have been better, and this is coming from an Italian girl who knows good, authentic Italian food and would never even recommend Olive Garden, but by comparison, it has to be better than this.

Went on 09/17/23 Went for a family gathering. We were seated in the small room at the front. The room was bright and clean and well set up for a party of 17. We ordered several salads and pizzas. The food was good. General feedback- The server seemed to stop checking on us for drinks and refills after the first half of our party arrived. We often had to go to the hosting station to request food and drinks. Overall, I would host a family gathering here again and for date night.

Been here a few times. The pizza is great and the vegetable lasagna is great. The margaritas are also very strong and taste just perfect. The service on the restaurant side was pleasant and fast. The second time I went we sat at the bar the bartenders are so efficient and attentive. Very relaxed feel at the bar. Never too crowded and get great service highly recommended.