This Seafood take-out restaurant need a face-lift. I order Fish & Chips long with fried oysters. The fish batter was too thick, French fries 🍟 were too dark. It seems the cooking oil for the French fries need to be change-out. Moreover, there was another customer that was unhappy about his order. Apparently, he order a dozen of crabs, but received like 7 🦀. They told him that they weight the crabs. Now, the last time I checked my math a dozen mean a total of 12. BTW: it took them 40 minutes to cook my.

I have always loved there crab cakes got to be under new owner ship. Today I brought 35$ worth of bread which was supposed to be jumbo crabs cakes. Last $$ they will ever get from me. And far as customer service goes after spending $127.00 didn't even offer me a soda after I bought the crab bread cakes back and didn't receive a refund even though I never left. Just fine another place to go this place sucks. And I stand on that

Today was my father's birthday so I thought I bet he would like some oysters and little neck clams. The price wasn't bad. Everyone seemed pleasant. So I took them to my parents, my mom called, and said where did you get those clams from , omg they were opened and they smelled so bad, Kimberly there rotten! So I was upset of course I called and said I wanted to bring them back and was told we just got them in we have been selling them all day, well maybe so, or maybe those folks haven't smelled there rotten little necks either 🤢 I won't be going back! Drive to Easton Folks 🙂 totally worth it. No decent seafood in Salisbury.

We stopped here based on the reviews. Got two seafood platters, two pc cod and the breaded shrimp. The two stars are for specific sides...the hush puppies and onion rings were pretty good, the corn nuggets, Cole slaw were all right. The rest of the meal was pretty bad. The fish tasted a little funky, the clam strips were all right (frozen out of a bag?), but the shrimp and the oysters were just bad...the oysters were suspect as spoiled....it seems like it was all fried together....and the fries were even burnt. Throw in that the platters we're $26 each and a total of $100 altogether.... REALLY disappointed. DON'T EAT THE FRIED OYSTERS.

My wife and I have passed by One Fish Two Fish many, often remarking what a delightful name and would say we would stop in someday. Today was the day I need a seafood fix. We ordered the Fish and Chips for two and It was great! 4 large fish filet, the cod was lightly battered, large flakes and cooked to a golden brown and the taste was amazingly light. Hands down the best I have ever had. Monte treated me like family. It is refreshing to be greeted with a big smile and a eastern shore Hello. I will be back to dip my taste buds into more items from the menu.

My only regret is that I only purchased one sandwich. I purchased it for my road trip back to Charlotte NC.The sandwich was amazing. Cooked to order, crispy and perfectly seasoned. I also ordered puppies which were the best I've had. The place is small and plain on the outside, who cares! Often that is where the best treasures are.

10 months ago: Fantastic crabs!! We got a 1/2 bushel of Large males and they were all fantastic! Amazing flavor! Thank you for always having consistently good and well-sorted steamed crabs! We've tried a couple other places around town but decided after this most recent crab feast that there is no reason to go astray again! 1 Fish 2 Fish is consistently fantastic! Today (6/9/18): another 1/2 bushel of medium males and 2lbs of shrimp for a great price! Delish! Excellent seasoning and cocktail sauce. Most of the crabs were very full. Friendly staff!!

Super friendly people, really fresh and unique food.... This place screams MARYLAND AUTHENTIC SEAFOOD!!!!!!. the staff is over the top nice and even showed me a live crab. I recommend literally every single thing on e the menu..... They even made me raw uncooked crab cakes so I can take them home and make them fresh at home!!!! Seriously... Who does that?!?!? These guys are great!!!

I eat from here at least twice a month but really look forward to the summer crabs! The mixed females I got last month was probably the best I ever had, but this month probably got the worst. Again, I say I order from there twice a month at the least so one bad experience in three years (since the last silly issue) isn't bad! I spoke with John when I asked for a manager and he was understanding, kind, and offered a reasonable replacement dozen. Well today I was really wanting some deliciousness but gunshy about crabs after last week. John was not in, but the gentleman who answered the phone was just as kind and professional and agreed to the fried oysters I was craving instead. And even added the couple slices of tomato we spoke about saving me a walk to the grocery store! A little over salty to me but I have been actively reducing my sodium so everything tastes over salted to me right now LoL everything was delicious, service was fantastic, and I look forward to maybe trying something new next visit :)

Ordered a seafood platter everything was fresh best it’s going get highly recommended

Great fresh rockfish, good hush puppies, good onion rings. The fries could have been cooked longer so they would be more crispy. Boardwalk fries is such an over used way to describe fresh cut French fries. Overall I enjoyed my meal.

I called in my order, got home to eat the 1pc fish sandwich was horrible, no taste, no season and had strong fishy taste. I called and told the person that answered, then was put on hold for manager and that person didn't come to phone. After a good while I hung up. I'm not worried about the money at all, I'm just tired of these businesses serving mess and taking people's money! I don't want tasteless food sorry! Be blessed.

They are more than happy to help, even getting a certain fish for you, and call ya when i'l r come in! I did buy a cod fish and it was tasty, nice and chunky, little salty for me I think but other than that it was pretty good! I may have salted it too much I don't know.

Great cod and softcrab platter....trally hood cream of crab soup...and the best onion rings around!

Ordered a dozen xlarge blue crabs, shrimp, and wings. Worst experience I have had. The crabs were supposed to be xlarge but was super light with a lot of dirt on about half of them and didn't taste good. The shrimp were over cooked and most of the meat stuck to the shells. The wings were ok.

Best cream of crab soup compared to other places around here! They make it from scratch on the premises. Delicious!! Friendly and talented folks!!

Delicious fried jumbo lump crabmeat sandwich with coleslaw. Will be back again! Decent prices and great quality food! Looks a little sketchy from the outside but that's okay

Worst steamed crabs in Maryland! They steam the crabs without Old Bay seasoning and after steaming, they roll each crab individually in the Old Bay! It’s the worst steamed crabs I’ve ever had. I rather go to Conrad’s Crabs in Parkville, MD about three hours away for delicious steamed crabs done the right way. Also Pappa’s in Parkville, MD has excellent steamed crabs. Just saying, One Fish Two Fish needs their team to take lessons from the places I mentioned in this review.

Looks like the place has new ownership. I would have taken a picture of my food but I ate it too fast! Crab cake and balls were moist and delicious. My son had the flounder sandwich 🥪 and I heard no complaints. He's 14... that's a big deal. Everyone was nice and order was ready fairly quickly. There's no use saying anything about prices. Everything is high nowadays but there, you get your money's worth. 👏🏽

One of the best seafood I've ever tasted. Fresh food, really kind staff and good prices :)

Flounder sandwich was fresh and delicious, hushpuppies are spot-on, portions are generous. Will absolutely be back and I'm bringing more people with me!