BEST PIZZA IN LEE COUNTY! NO, seriously! I'm an Italian guy who loves checking out local pizzerias. I have to say when I first tried McGregor pizza I was in awe with how delicious their pizza was. It definitely reminds you of a NY style pizza . Also the restaurant interior is very nice an modern style with pieces of Italy incorporated in the decor. The daily specials are pretty great! Been to both McGregor locations a handful of times and won't stop! Always telling friends & family to get McGregor's every time they mention pizza. Owner is a great guy who loves to get to know his regulars

Listen up! The pizza here was delicious! We ordered 4 large pizzas: the White, Green and Red along with a Summerlin Supreme, a Pepperoni and Sausage combo, and a cheese. Plus the bathroom has amazing art that has to be seen. We shall return for a sequel, no doubt.

First time trying and will definitely be back! Pizza tasted fresh, it wasn’t super greasy and had the perfect crispy, golden brown bottom. We got the bianca pizza with pepperoni and the authentic with pepperoni! Best pizza we’ve had around San Carlos area.

Absolutely love McGregor Pizza the food is amazing from the meatball sliders to pizza and calzones you can't go wrong!! Always amazing and fast service from the friendliest people. My favorite pizza place in SWFL!!!

To start I will say they have amazing customer service !! I called and they gave me the time of day to answer plenty of questions I had .. I told them if the pizza was good I'd be back , and here I am the 3rd time around and 3 different types of pizza later I have found my new and only pizza spot in san carlos let alone ft myers in general .. quality of their pizza is A+ with amazing taste and generous toppings .. food is also always fresh .. #1 pizza so far is the pesto pepperoni !! Thank you guys and keep up the good work 🙌🏼

Look at all the fresh basil! The caprese salad was delicious too. We spent $50 on knots, salad, pizza, and dessert. My new go-to pizza place!

So glad we came here! The pizza is delicious! And I love that they serve two slices and a can of soda until 4pm! This pizza place IS A MUST if you’re in the area!

1st time visiting and it won't be the last! We ordered a medium pie. The owner suggested to make a different kind on each side.....Supreme and red, white & green w mushrooms added. Absolutely delicious!!!! Fresh ingredients.....cooked to perfection. The staff was so so nice. We can't say enough about our experience! 🤌 can't wait to return!!!

New to the area but not new to pizza. Ordered the McGregor Supreme and will give it a 6/10. Also got garlic knots that are obviously not made in house and probably come from CBI frozen 1/10. Sorry for the honest review.

This was my first time at Mcgegor Pizza in San Carlos and the pizza was 10/10, we got the white green red pizza and garlic knots and it was SO good. The guy at the counter was really nice and helpful. Everything 10/10 will 100% be going there from now on !

Great pie, salads and more. I love their Red. White. Green. It has fresh ricotta, basil and garlic. My hubby can’t have gluten or dairy and they have good options for him too. I mostly get take out, but have enjoyed their cute atmosphere and lunch specials dining in as well. I’m so glad they opened this location in my neighborhood!

Eat here! You won’t be disappointed Best calzones I’ve had in a long time!! Fresh Greek salad on the side..perfect