I *absolutely L💚VE* citrus desserts, especially key lime & lemon, & I consider myself a bit of a key lime pie aficionado. So I was delighted to find this local little hidden-gem located just a short walk from our hotel! This was Key-Lime perfection! The best key-lime pie I've had outside of the Florida Key's!!! The graham-cracker crust was very flavorful, with a nice, crisp, crunchy texture. The meringue was generous, (but as a nice addition to, & not to the detriment ofú the key-lime filling), was perfectly toasted to a golden-brown. They key-lime filling was the perfect combination of sweet & tart (I hate when they're too sweet, & prefer a nice 50/50 ratio), & was chock full of lime zest- which I L💚VE! Most places skimp on the zest & pulp, & that's if they don't omit it completely. If you're a fan of sweet, tart, & tangy key-lime pie, you won't be disappointed! I *WISH* I had thought to take a picture of the pie before we dove into it, but I didn't.

We are staying across the street at the Westin. We’ve been down a few times to get a medium pie to bring back to the room and they’re just perfect. The ratio of filling to crust to meringue is perfect. Lovely spot for a pie.

I stayed at the Westin across the street and made the venture across the street after seeing it on the drive in. Damn, this pie was delicious. The bellman said it was the best pie in Cozumel, and though for me it was the only pie - I believe him. Great experience from start to finish.

Best key lime pie in the city….or maybe the world?!?!? You should try it and be the judge for yourself. All I can guarantee is will not be disappointed.

I’m not the biggest key lime pie fan, however, this was the best I’ve ever had!! If you’re in Cozumel, you MUST try it!!

I’m not the biggest fan of key lime pie but this one is really good! The crust alone could be eaten alone. Family of 4 and we shared the medium but still had left overs.

The best key lime pie we have ever had. Cute little shop with the nicest girl working there. We got a small one to share, and went back the next night and did the same thing. That's how good it was.

Amazing. We stopped here after dinner one night and took a pie back to the hotel. Outstanding!! I had a hard time not stopping every time I drove past.

Great food! Small with a few tables. Well worth the stop!

Best key lime pie we have ever eaten! We found this gem while staying at Playa Azul, and it was the best way to top off the end of our vacation!

If you are in Cozumel, you HAVE to try these pies. We went back there like 3 times! So good. Nothing else to say.

Great pies, you should def try them if you go to cozumel for first time!

Awesome hole in the wall place just down the road from El Cozumeleno hotel. The pies are in several sizes and taste incredible... Don't miss an opportunity for a nice sweet treat!

Best key lime pie we have ever eaten. This is to the north, away from the tourist area but it’s a must if you come to Cozumel This is a hidden gem!

Great little place, the key lime pie was excellent, and a great reason all by itself to go to this nice little area of Cozumel, (Hotel Zone).

We were in Cozumel for 4 days. We had a pie the first night in the next-door restaurant, and had to order teo more to go. Best dessert in the island, possibly the brst we've had in Mexico. Don't miss it.

Incredibly delicious. You can't stop eating. It looks and tastes fantastic. Sweet and sour combination. The taste is addictive

Awesome key lime pie! Neither my husband or I are big fans of key lime pie but this one was delicious. Quick, friendly service and so so good!