You're in for a slice of heaven, my pizza-loving pals! Vinny's New York Pizza is the pepperoni to your pie, the cheese to your crust – it's pizza nirvana, and it doesn't disappoint. Let's talk about their buffalo chicken pizza. It's not just a pizza; it's a masterpiece. The perfect blend of spicy buffalo sauce, tender chicken, and that gooey cheese that stretches longer than your last yoga session. It's like a flavor explosion in your mouth, in the best way possible. If this pizza were a superhero, it'd be the Caped Crust Crusader. But wait, there's more! The wings, oh boy, the wings. They're so good, they'll have you flapping for joy. Crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and with sauces that make your taste buds do a happy dance. Whether you like 'em mild or fiery enough to give a dragon heartburn, Vinny's has you covered. And the staff? They're the real MVPs. Friendly, efficient, and armed with the cheesiest jokes this side of the Big Apple. It's like getting a side of laughter with your order – who knew pizza could be this entertaining? In summary, Vinny's New York Pizza isn't just a pizza joint; it's a culinary adventure. Five stars for serving up slices of happiness and wings that fly you straight to flavor town. If you haven't tried their buffalo chicken pizza, you're missing out on life's cheesy pleasures. Go ahead, take a bite out of deliciousness! 🍕✨

Very nice restaurant. I picked up my pizza and the place was very busy at 2:30 pm on a Monday. Pizza was cooked as requested, very delicious (at little greasy). The large is huge and reasonably priced. We ordered the Vinny Specisl minus bell pepper add black olive. We'll be eating on this for 2 days!

The lady they have running the front needs to go! I've never had such rude service directed to me ever in my life, I ordered over the phone and was told 30 minutes, I arrive 30 minutes later and I wait in line another 6 as the lady in the front spends a good minute or two talking with every person instead of getting the line moving! I finally get to the front and am not greeted, just almost demanded if i was there for a dine in or pick up, I let her know I'm there for a pick up, she sighs and gets all moody with me as she can't find my name, she goes back and forth between multiple areas and comes back to tell me that its not ready and going to be another 30 minutes?? I try to question how or why that has happened, and instead of a answer I'm told "it's just how it is", and that "I need to move so she can help those behind me"! I simply could not find a nice way to respond so I simply go and I sit on the bench and wait another 30 minutes, and I get my food. the food was decent, but the entire customer "service" provided, was by far the worst I've ever experienced I've not left any form of review for this town till now I'm by far disappointed, and will never be returning due to this. I will also be informing my family and friends.

We went here tonight for the first time. We will definitely be back! We got wings, a turkey sub and a cheese pizza. Everything was SO good! This will definitely be one of our go to's. Loved all the photos and murals and restaurant was very clean. Friendly staff and good prices for the quality.

Unbelievably greasy. 1 small piece of sausage is placed on top of pepperoni, so it falls off. I think that its done to make sure a customer doesnt get too much. 10 years ago, this place was easily 4+ stars. The chain pizzas are way better now

Update Sept 2023: we've been back a few times and the first couple were fine but our most recent visit was disappointing. The golden tangy wings my husband loves so much were either over cooked or just old wings. They were rubbery and didn't taste right at all. The other food wasn't as good as before either so due to the inconsistency I dropped a star. We will probably try them again in the future and I'll update if it's better. As a local restaurant with a lot of history we want to support them but I hope they can improve their quality and consistency to avoid concerns like this in the future. OG review (July 2023) We've gone to Vinny's a couple of times now after a friend recommended their wings. My husband loves the GoldNTangy wings so much he called the restaurant back after we got takeout and told them they are his new favorite wings. We got a Mediterranean pizza that time as well and it was flavorful. The pizza is thin and floppy which we don't mind, it doesn't hold up for left overs well though, so eat it fresh! We went back to dine in and I had the baked ziti which was fresh and tasted good. I would have preferred more cheese but the sauce was nicely seasoned.and the garlic bread tastes homemade in the best way. My husband had the GoldNTangy wings again of course with a beer on tap which he said complimented the wings well. He also tried the Eggplant Parm sandwich which he enjoyed. I tried it and the eggplant tasted a bit like cucumber to me but the breading was tasty. It could have used a tad more sauce we both agreed. We had the same lady as our cashier on both visits and she was friendly and talkative but not inappropriate. She gave honest answers and food recommendations. The restaurant feels like a home town local pizza place with a lot of history, which it is. It's clean and comfortable enough. No real issues.

I ordered from Vinny's about a week ago, the large Carnivore. I added Jalapeños for a little kick. I travel for work and test pizza in the cities I travel through. This was a knockout. Every piece was the same; 4 pepperonis with a sausage in each, a nice fat slice of ham and equal bacon all over. The crust, even on the middle pieces, was light, buttery with just enough bite. It was amazing and took me 3 days to eat. My only complaint is that they don't send an email/text to ask how your pie was. I guarantee there'd be a ton of positive responses. Less than 20 bucks and good food.

I love this place! We had a salad and wings. The wings are really good and filling. She had mild and I had hot. Both were amazing. We may try the "Homocidal" wing challenge one weekend. The antipasto was really good and didn't contain "salad fresh" making for a comfortable ride home. We've had their pizza in the past and it was absolutely amazing. We weren't left with a "blah" feeling after finishing the pie.

Placed 2 SEPARATE to go orders. When we got there they had put all the wings together & told us we’d have to wait 30 minutes for it to be fixed. We ordered a total of 30 wings and a salad with EXTRA ranch & we received 2 & we were charged for the extra. Food was good, but the service and attitudes were not! This is my first and last visit!

I really don't like giving bad reviews, but this was an extremely disappointing experience. We ordered a pizza, baked ziti, side salad, and cheese bread. On the positive side the cheese bread and pizza were decent. On the negative, the baked ziti came with no cheese and wasn't baked, the salad was primarily just a to-go container of lettuce, and all the food arrived luke warm. My parents did have a positive experience the first time they ordered, but I'll never know if it's good since I'm visiting from out of town.

I had the Buffalo wings 😋 SO GOOD!! Service was fast and friendly. LOVE the home town atmosphere too!! Update... ate here again. This time we tried the "medium" sauce. Wow they were very flavorful. We nicknamed the sauce "the devils ketsup" 😈 😎. Very good and also very hot 🔥 🥵. Still one of may favorite places to eating SV. The gluten free crust was pretty good too!

We were looking for a restaurant that delivers, and decided to try Vinny's. I ordered the Carnivore pizza, Deep fried ravioli, Chicken parmesan, and wings. The food was very good, and the price was good, and you get tasty quality food. K.C. our delivery person was very friendly, and courteous. We will definitely order from them again, and try some other choices. Thanks for making our fist experience, a good one.

Picked up 3 specialty pizzas to take home. They were accurately topped with some minor customization we wanted, and were cooked just right. Service was prompt and friendly. The taste was good, and frozen leftovers reheated on a stone were as good as day 1. Good local spot.

Vinny's New York Pizza supposedly is highly rated for having one of the best pizza's in town. This business does not deserve to have the word "New York" in it because it doesn't taste absolutely nothing like New York Style Pizza. There was a lady with glasses who looked to be in charge. She admitted that the girl who took our order messed up and that was why we ended up getting double the food. We didn't want double the food. We wanted what we paid for. The lady with the glasses did not apologize. I explained to her how I was trying to be nice about the situation and rather than apologizing she got snappy. The lady with the glasses said "let me see what I can do" and never came back. I had to chase her. She brought two receipt explaining how two of the same orders went through but only got charged once. Once again She did not apologize. When the lady got snappy she explained how they were busier than usual which as a customer that is a "you problem" not mine. I shouldn't of been snapped at as a customer when we were allowed to be upset. Digiorno pizza IS WAY BETTER THAN Vinny's New York Pizza. It was my first and it will be my last. My first visit was a disgrace and an embarrassment. I will never go there again and DO NOT...RECOMMEND THIS PLACE AT ALL!

Stopped in to try the pizza, it was great! Staff was friendly and knowledgeable. Restaurant was clean even though it was after the lunch crowd. The bathroom was clean and stocked too!

We live in Tucson but this is my favorite pizza EVER! Gotta hit up Vinny's every time we're in Sierra Vista. The pizza is superb; super melty cheese and a delightful tangy sauce. Excellent wings too. I only wish we could get some in Tucson!

Pizza is great and wings were even better. Nice and crispy. The sauces are great as well. Service is self serve after you order ie. Get your own drink refills. Atmosphere was good and not crowded.

Ordered their hottest wings, tasted like second hottest wings. Picked up the order for someone else and had to explain the possible meaning of the word "cuckol" (correction cockol) written on the container. Homicide wings, remember them being hotter in store. Might be a store policy to write this infamous mix up everytime someone front or back of house mentions Doc Holiday. Vinnys good establishment, and good food. New York style, no lie herd on my part or spoken during the food run.

Best pizza and wings in town, period. Very casual place. Staff is always friendly. Wings are by far best in town!