Delicious bagels, good ice cream, and fast service. Highly recommend. Definitely best in the area. The egg everything bagel is delicious.

So happy to have bagels in Sleepy Hollow! These bagels are delicious, and the flavored cream cheese is perfection! I’ll admit that I’m a bit relieved to not have to pull on and off Broadway to get in here! Can’t wait for more!

Absolutely love this place! Super convenient and the parking is great. The bagels are always fresh and everything is super quick. Everyone in there is always super nice and helpful and the place is clean!! LOVE horsemen bagels.

This place is great!! Bagels are so good and fresh! The bagels are made in under a minute and are always on point! Also it’s 2 in 1 because there is a carvel right next to it so you can have a sweet treat along with it!

The bagels were incredibly fluffy and the staff couldn’t be friendlier!

Stopped by here on a Friday morning and the bagels were fresh and delicious! The woman behind the counter was friendly and put just the right amount of butter on my bagel - on both sides after slicing it! I'm not in this neck of the woods often, but when I am I will be stopping by for more poppy seed bagels! There's a parking lot and they serve coffee and other delectable too.

The bagels are simply delicious. I had the spread with scallions and lox on a plain toasted bagel, while my companion had Strawberry cream cheese on a Toasted egg bagel. They were incredibly fresh, overstuffed, and every mouthful was delicious. Highly recommend!

I’ve found my new favorite place. This was only $7. Compared to a bunch of other places I’ve tried that are very expensive and not as good. Everything was perfect, it was well packaged, so it didn’t fall apart. 10/10

First time trying Horseman bagels location. Staff friendly. Bagels soft and very delicious. My Husband had an Everything Bagel, Egg and Extra Cheese. I had a Rainbow Bagel with scallon cream cheese. Two small coffee, great temperature, taste smooth. Highly recommend. Update 2/5/2024 Went today and had an everything bagel with Rose Cream Cheese. Highly recommend.

Place is clutch! very clean warm and welcoming and best part is the freshness of the bagels. You can tell it's made on the spot unlike a lot of other local bagel spots. This has become my go to I highly recommend the toasted BEC on a bagel.

The zaatar bagels are excellent, my daughter loved them. She uses the seasoning for cooking after having it in the Middle East. Many other varieties; also had the delicious croissants.

The yummiest bagel ever, i loved the rosemary garlic one, 👌 super

Really good! Prob some of the best NY bagels I’ve ever had! Warm & fresh . Pretty awesome

Delicious breakfast! I had a pumpernickel everything bagel with lox and scallions cream cheese. It was so good and filled me up. Perfect stop for a quick, easy breakfast.

My family LOVES this place. The food is great and the staff is good. The only reason I did not give it 5 stars is because the parking is a bit convoluted in that the parking lot is on top of the restaurant. Highly recommend this place though!

If you knew anything about this place you would know that it hasn't been open for 6 years. So hold your judgement and check it out because I'm claiming the best bagels in westchester.

This gem was well received when we came across it. A wide selection available for choice. These can only be described as delicious. Set us up nicely for the day exploring Tarrytown. Dessert after did also did not disappoint. Service was fantastic and very knowledgeable about local area and where to visit. If you get a chance definitely visit!!

The service is good for the most part, very kind but not so much attentive. Love their pizza and the food doesn't take to long. Drive about 20min just to eat their pizza.

Not bad but not great. It is very small and the food does take a while to come out. But the waitresses over there are very nice and attentive. A bad thing that happened is was that it took a while to get my order, but I didn't get mad, because I notice that the place was very busy that Sunday afternoon. And the server was friendly. I order a Medium steak on top easy going eggs with French fries. The Steak had a great taste, I love how the way my egg albumen, bathed my steak, and then dipped my French fries in it. I enjoy very much how my steak was cook it was perfect for me and the portion was so big I had to push myself to eat it all.

It’s often that when ordering three items, one might be wrong. Unfortunately, today, they messed up all three after repeated reminders. They also messed up the order of the woman in front of us. I assume it’s a new place and they’re still getting their legs under themselves. The bagels tasted good and I will give them another chance but what a disappointment today.