I ordered a pizza and 2lb wing combo . My pizza was supposed to be half pineapple and this is what I got, you could literally count the amount of pineapples pieces on it . The wing looked very pale,not flavored and not appetizing at all!! No one ate the wings . While the pizza did not taste bad ( hence the 2 stars),I'm disgusted by this my first and last experience.

One of the best places to order pizza in the local area; affordable consistent quality. The owner is great person involved in local activities, they also own Olee's beside this establishment, give that a try, it's also a great place. A local staple!

We just moved to StCatharines and trying every pizza place. First time order from this place through Skip. Cannot track order, because they manage their own delivery. Ordered 8 slice with 1 pound hot wings. ($43) The facts: Delivery was over an hour. Food was barely warm, wings less than a pound, pizza ok, nothing special. Taste good, but not the best. Overall: we tried, we ate, but isn't gonna be our pizza place.

Pizza is consistent and tasty. Wings are a good size. Neighbourhood pizza staple, best for takeout, not sure if anyone eats in there much anymore. Good food is all that matters.

They have a great pizza and wings! The price is pretty average to today's pizza and wing prices. The quality you're getting is very good. The toppings are of high quality. The wings are very flavorful and a good size but wish they were a little heavier on the pound. Inside could use a little update. fixtures seem dated. It's also dark and pub-like, unless that's the motif they are portraying. Overall best pizza on this side of St. Catharines.

I have read many reviews on JERRY'S good & bad. Ì have three places I order from and this is one of them. I can't believe some of the bad. First of all the girls behind the counter are great, I love the atmosphere I could look the memorabilia all night and I have never, ever had a bad pizza or experience at JERRY'S ÀĶA Pete's. Añd will continue buying pizza there. Have what you like on your pizza they have a great selection of ingredients. They know how to make delicious pizza. 313 Merritt Street. Ròb Jean

They charged me $6.80 more than what the menu said. They counted this as a slice for a 12 slice pizza. Pizza is very this not very filling. On the upside, they found my address. 3 other places we tried ended up in St. Catharine's rather than Thorold even though we specified Thorold. Approximately 30 mins for delivery on a Wednesday. Not bad.

Very good pizza. A lot of pizzas now a days aren’t worth it. You can get a small medium or large and somehow they’re always the same size just cut more. NOT HERE. Very good pizza and proper size. Good quality ingredients on the pizza, friendly and polite staff when I go in to pick up. Great bang for your buck.

Horrible service Pizza over cooked with no sauce Wings dry and burnt Have a 1 because I couldn’t go lower Owner back his employees over returning customers. Failing bad in the pizza world

A Wonderful and Incredibly place in a historic in ( Meriton ) St.Catharine’s Ontario. The pizza is Beyond Wonderful. True craftsmanship and Taste. Bravo Owner Jerry DIPIETRO Again Thanks for the Enjoyable Experience. Martin Sarkisian

The pizza was delicious. cooked just right every time. no bad pizza. at least for us. the service was great. the wings are big but overcooked. only had the wings one time. hopefully, that was just an oversight. not much for parking but I get mine to go because they don't deliver to Thorold.

Soggy day old slices. Can get better slices from an avaonadale. Edit: Is asking for the pizza to be heated required? Because I didn't want crispy pizza, warm would have been nice. Most places serve it hot, or they heat it back up when it's been out long enough to become soggy and look day old.

We absolutely 💯 love the food it's our very favorite place to order I highly recommend the service is great the staff is absolutely amazing and the drivers are fantastic not once have we ever had a problem with the food we give a 5 star rating

We order from here pretty frequently, and the food is always different quality, but today was the worst. Fries completely undercooked, some with bad black spots and a foul taste. Paid way too much for two orders of chicken fingers and fries when half the meal is close to inedible. So disappointing.

Great place, GREAT pizza and great staff. Would recommend at anyone. 👍🏻👍🏻

Always a delight to get pizza from here. Very consistent from visit to visit, and very consistently just a great pizza. Whole family loves it, even our picky kids. I find the crust is a little crunchier than most places, which isn't a bad thing at all, just an observation. If you're averse to crunchy crusts, maybe get your pizza just a little less done. Also: a nice bonus is they have anchovies as a topping. I find a lot of places have stopped with anchovies which is a shame: king of toppings for me, personally.

We are long time customers. Jerry is an important part of our community. There aren't enough words to say how much we appreciate him. And GREAT pizza

I have bin ordering from pizza Jerry's/Pete's pizza for years and it was always the best of the best and for get about the rest but as of late my pizza and wings were the worst. pizza burnt and dehydrated wings just don't work for me especially when you pay 70 dollars I will be thinking twice about ordering again

Some of the best pies in town. Guy knows how to make damn good pizza. Staff is great and accommodating. Highly recommend

My go-to for pizza & wings, they never get it wrong! Amazing quality, can’t recommend (Pete’s) pizza Jerry’s enough!!

nice place, decent prices... if you order a 24 slice make sure you get 3 toppings... if you ask for pepperoni or cheese they're gunna charge you the same anyways.... buy won't give you extra....other then that the place is good and consistent, we have been ordering for our pizza nights for a few weeks now.

Pete's Pizza on Pleasant Ave and Ontario is better than here. Ordered from here to see if was the same and it wasn't nearly as good. They didn't get the toppings right that I even paid extra for. SMH. I should have checked the tray before taking it home.

A little hidden gem in st catharines. Very good pizza and wings for the price you'd expect at some cheap pizza place. Staff is always in good moods and super friendly. Looking for good food and service, you will quickly become a regular there.

I called at 6:45pm Thursday, April 6th, 2023. Been buying pizza from Pete's Pizza on Merrit Street for decades. I have ordered many different items. I have on several occasions ordered a 4 slice pizza with three items always had the third item instead of a pop. Never had a problem until this evening. She said no you have to pay for the third item. I'll take my business else where.

tastes just like my favorite childhood pizza. So happy I was recommended here.

Always good pizza and the panzoratis are amazing, my husband and I always order from Jerry's! Ordered one today and was very messy, wasn't closed all the way but probably because there are so many toppings stuffed into it, just so yummy anyways♡

Great tasting pizza, wings were good. Great prices and service.