Absolutely ridiculous Overpriced. Which is a shame because the pizza is not half bad. I ordered for delivery one large pizza with one topping and one 2 L bottle of soda. The total was $32. Yes $32 for one pizza and one bottle of soda. Then add the drivers tip. I wouldn’t be as mad if the food was hot and the driver didn’t forget my soda. I’ll never order here again.

Best Pizza in Toms River!! No other pizzeria compares. Don't forget to say "Hi" to the brothers Luigi and Anthony.

Friendly & great service. Great selection on lunch specials. Fair prices

Pondrelli's Pizza and Kitchen is about as consistent as you can get. Everytime we get a pizza, sandwich, or entree it is always very good. We have never had a bad experience. It is nice to know that when we order food from here we know it is going to be good. That is the reason we keep going back. There are plenty of options for pizza out there and it says something that theirs is the best. Keep up the good work!

Checking out a new place for Pizza Slices. Today, Kit had a Sicilian Slice with Onions and Peppers. My slices were the Grandma, Sausage and Pepperoni. Fantastic crust, sauce, cheese and toppings.

I've eaten here since 2017 and have never had a bad experience. Pizza always tasted great. Wraps are delightfully filled. Appetizers are delicious. Staff is friendly and always great to talk to.

We ordered the catering special and added a few extra trays. Everything was on time, hot and ready to eat. The food was excellent and more than enough. Cavetelli and Broccoli, Sausage and Peppers, chicken francheise and more. Excellent!!!!

Probably, no most definitely the best pizza in Tom's River, with two of the nicest guys Luigi & Antonio

Great food, fast service and hands down the nicest guys working here!!

One bite, one review - 6.7 Not the best, not the worst.

Pondrelli's catered my daughter's college graduation party. We ordered food for 100 people. The food was excellent. Everyone raved about it. It also arrived right on time and was hot enough to serve immediately -- which we did. I highly recommend Pondrelli's if you''re having a big party.

We had food catered yesterday for a graduation party. it was on time and the food was delicious and everyone loved it and more than enough for everyone nice and hot will use them again The Best ❤️ Eggplant Parmesan, Chicken francese, cavatelli and broccoli, roasted potatoes, Caesar salad and very delicious cookies

Family owned! Owner soooooooo kind as were his boys who you can tell alllll take pride in the business Pizza options were unique to other local establishments and we enjoyed our date their (my lil nephew and i) Thank you so much Genuinely, Me

I've driven by this place more times than I can count but for some reason I never went inside. I wasn't expecting much from the outside but I was very pleasantly surprised. Tables tablecloths lay back kind of relaxing atmosphere. All I had was a slice and a small soda to try the pizza place out but I'm definitely going back to try to chicken parmesan the meatball parmesan sandwich and maybe some night of lasagna for dinner. I like the place and I'm glad I stopped in.

Great Pizza great service

The pizza is good but it's nothing special that justifies the price

Decent Pizza nice people

Was just there...bought ham calzone..very good ..ive been there before n the man,that makes it is always workin very hard...give him a raise

Great food. Friendly staff

Called Pondrellis Last minute to send food to My Grandkids parents house because we had a sudden Death in the family. They sent it within an hour. Thank you so much

Delicious slices Great to eat one or two before you continue down the road to Original Rich’s for Ice cream 🍦

Absolutely delicious will definitely be going back. The desserts were awesome. The owners and staff were very accommodating and friendly

First time here. Pizza is good

It's a shame that they did not only raise their prices properly to match today's inflation but yet they decided to essentially double or more some items you triple the price but offer the same standard size portions and intermediate ingredients. I paid $8.88!!! Yes, especially $9 for a pepperoni and a thin crust w/ vodka sauce ( which the dough was not fully cooked, was way over kneaded & definitely was no where near fresh enough to still be in display case as it should have been tossed) !! No where near justifiable nor understandable, not even a bit.. I'm actually flat out disgusted with that. Unfortunately, I will NEVER return here do to the greed.. I mean every other pizzeria within a 10-mile radius properly raised their prices to match the inflation which would come out to as high as $4 a special sauce that is with chicken parm or something not almost $5 per standard plane or pepperoni slice! I am upset but at the same time I feel bad because they are going to be the ones to close their own doors. Slowly but surely customers will drop off your consumer list and to go elsewhere. I understand they want to make more money but they have to understand that the public does not have more money to give them.

Best place to go and an excellent slice of pizza, or salad, guys at the counter are amazing, Very cool. The second we stepped in they all welcomed us, we felt at home. Amazing service! 10 ☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆

The best I have experienced in the area, everything I've ordered was great from soup, salad to pizza and burgers. Always friendly, quick delivery, is my always "to go" place

Horrible pizza. Threw that right in the garbage. Don't waste your money nor time stopping!

Really wanted to like this place as they’ve been around forever. Unfortunately, it was a let down. $33 for a Sicilian pie with sausage and pepperoni. Their menu and price online says $22.99, so I feel ripped off for the minimal toppings I have here for almost $10 more. Not sure if inflation has something to do with the price increase, but yikes. There was barely even any cheese or sausage on the pie. Disappointing. On a positive note, it was clean inside and staff was nice. Just can’t justify the price and taste.

We just moved to the neighborhood and ordered a large order from them. They were super polite, quick and food was great! Gave us free cookies to welcome us! Thank you!

So kind, quick and attentive every visit. Pizza is FAB, my favorite garlic knots around.

The best ever pizza I tried in NJ!.

Inside is small, but this is largely a pizza place. Service was friendly and there was a good selection of pre-made slices to choose from for my first time there. I had two meat slices and enjoyed both. Good enough to come back, but it wasn't that different from other places. Parking is sufficient along the side and back and there was no wait to order, but deliveries were going out pretty quickly.

Absolutely amazing!!! Everything was great but the Grandpa pie was outstanding!! Great customer service as well, will be back:)

2 slices for $6.00 highway robbery and cheap with the cheese

The pizza is magnificent! And the people are friendly. I've been going for years. Highly recommend, their food is excellent too!!

Love this place, but the wait can be long. Best to go with a +1. Bigger tables wait much longer

Came to tom'ss river and seaside heights for a bike event. Ordered pizza for delivery to our hotel room. The female who took my order said she didn't need my name or room number, leaving me wondering how she intended for the driver to find me for delivery. Paid 50+ dollars for 1 medium and 1 large pizza. Pizza was hanging out of the box at delivery with the box cutting into the pizza and one pizza wasn't even cut. Not the best first impression.

Went to Pizza Mozza after booking one month in advance! Forget the haters...this still has the best pizza. Unfortunately we live in Australia so our visits have been years in between. We have been 4 times. It has always been as good. Service,food,cocktails,friendly staff despite the fact it is always full with hordes waiting. The mushroom and taleggio pizza is my favourite with the tricolore salad or the cobb ( both great). Mario and Lidia when are you coming to Australia? Please. Can't wait to go back!

Foods are so expensive. Although the place was nice.

good food but the crew are so slow!

BEST pizza around!! Never had a bad pizza or anything else from here! Used to live 2 blocks away now I drive over from 2 towns away because the food is THAT GOOD!! Highly recommended, patronize if you live nearby, stop in if you are passing by ... You will not be disappointed 👍

*Not worth the price, food stalls outside are nicer

We ordered the half tray special for my birthday Sunday the food was absolutely delicious and the homemade cookies were delicious that come with the special I highly recommend there food for any event I was very pleased and would definitely order from there again

Way to expensive for soup.

Yum! They have such delicious food. My husband and I tried them for the first time on a whim because we drive past the location on our way home from my job. Everything we've had from here is awesome. The pizza garlic knots, the wings, the chicken marsala, the pizza... all fantastic! Definitely give this place a try.

This place is absolutely amazing. Their Pizza is top-notch and the garlic knots are seriously addicting

Really good pizza. Best in the area. AAA+

Delicious!!! Will be back!!😊

Very good food. Clean place also.

Always great food love this place.

Great Place to Eat

nice place but their food has a bit of expensive

nice place to meet and catch up with family. service is consistently great. bring your appetite because portions are large. kinda of like a place in houston that i enjoyed.

We made a special trip from our Santa Monica vacation location because we had heard rave reviews. We weren't disappointed. We visited on a weekday afternoon. We were seated right away and it wasn't too crowded. The pizza was excellent. But my favorite was the housemade ricotta appetizer with fresh peas and mint pesto - yum! Our service was very good, even with the servers having a shift change during our meal.

I sent my friends to this restaurant with my highest recommendations. I visit this restaurant often. I get very good feedback from my friends. The pizza they serve are tasty and the stuff is generous and cooperative. Every time we eat in this place we pass a pleasing time. highly recommended.

Pondrelli's is the best if you are on this side of Toms River or near Island Heights. The food is top notch and the employees always offer a warm welcome. Nobody can touch their Pizza... Great food Great staff, highly recommend

Best!! Everyone is so nice and the food is excellent!!

Get the grandpas pizza well done its amazing

Just picked up my pizza. Ive been getting food from here only this last year. It is so delicious. I wish i knew about this place before. Doesnt matter pick up or delivery always hot , fresh and delicious... Cheers

A welcoming place , with great food, you can get it all to go , except for the smiles..

The sauce was excellent and the pizza was amazing. We had a slice of buffalo, grandma, and chicken parm and all 3 were delicious. The staff was very friendly and absolute gentlemen. We will be back!

I wouldn't give them a 1 star rating. When ordering full trays they are really half trays. So half our guests at our Cub Scout Blue and Gold Ceremony didnt eat since half the order was missing. We called the restraunt and they said that was there trays. It was suppose to feed 60 people and cost 566.40. How ridiculous!