I have been to Pegasus a number of times with my husband and been pleased with the food and the service until yesterday. A server spilled an entire ice tea on me. Never apologized, never offered a towel to me. Was only interested in cleaning the floor. Food was good but they don't care about customers.

I had an overall excellent experience at this restaurant. The service was fantastic and the price point was exceptional! The quality of the food was magnificent, and the portions were larger than I expected. I ordered CHICKEN PICANTE: Chicken Breast Lightly Coated in Gluten-Free Flour, Sautéed in Virgin Olive Oil, Sliced Mushrooms, Capers, White Wine, Lemon, and Butter Picante Sauce. My friend ordered STEAK & EGGS, 12oz N.Y. Strip Steak, Three Eggs Any Style, Home Fries & Toast

Today we enjoyed the special s Chicken & rice with balsamic. Penne pasta with sausage in a blush sauce. Both are very good 😊

My daughter and I love it here! Restaurant has been here for a long time and they’ve managed to keep the menu varied but tasty with a large list of specials. My daughter loves their chicken parmigiana which is a HUGE portion. I went with the surf n turf (prime rib cooked a perfect medium rare and seasoned just right, broiled stuffed shrimp which was fresh and delicious and a stuffed mushroom. For my sides, pickled beets and sweet potatoes). The staff is all friendly, our waitress tonight was terrific.

Best restaurant in the area, good prices and specials. Very clean and nice decor. You will get your money's worth and have an enjoyable meal.

Dinner atmosphere, great service, very good food. See my videos for the visuals. Tasted like it looks. Enjoy!

Great breakfast specials if you arrive before 11am for $9.99 or less. Our food was hot and the coffee was good. Good breakfast selection. We all enjoyed our food and got a full plate! Nice bright atmosphere. Good service and waitress did not rush us to leave. Would recommend to family & friends.

Horrible take-out experience!! Ordered take-out on June 2022. Chicken Francaise to be precise. When I got home, I didn't realize that the sauce had spilled all over my car seat because the staff had not sealed the container properly. I called the establishment to speak with the manager and there was none. So I explain to a young lady what had happened & her response was that these things happen when you order take out at any place. Yes, go figure!!?? When I told them that I was not happy because my dinner was ruined and that my car seat had stains. The girl in charge was quick to judge and told me that they couldn't detail my car. In the first place, I had not asked for that. All I wanted was that my situation be corrected since I had no meal. As I waited for a response, they told me the manager would call me back the next day. They didn't call. So, I had to call them back 2 days later. When I called the manager asked me what happened and then said that the next meal would be on them. She took my name, my phone number and my address. I came back 3 months later, placed my order and drove for about 30 miles; so they could tell me that they remembered me but they couldn't find there slip and couldn't give me my meal!! I was and still angry because they had me drive a long distance to tell me this!! I have eaten at this place for many years, never had a complaint and the manager was aware of this. I will NEVER come to this place again. Such poor customer service!! Manager & staff should take a course on customer service & satisfaction. And don't be surprised if your place goes out of business. The Prestige Diner in Vineland is #1 in customer satisfaction, their menu has a wide selection to chose from and their meals are relatively priced accordingly.

We had a great lunch here, service was friendly and food was great. We will go back next time we drive through the area.

So Pegasus has been around since I was a kid and it has unfortunately taken a turn for the worst. We were here on a Sunday at 10am and we placed a breakfast order that took FOREVER to come out to our table. Our server Jenn was unkempt and not very enthusiastic - she never came back to our table to check on our food and I had to grab the hostess to let her know there was a problem with my meal. I ordered the Tuscany Benedict and asked to sub the sausage out with avocado. The poached eggs were hard boiled, the avocado was browning, and the basil was spoiled and rancid. It took so long that we had to leave and all I ended up having for breakfast was coffee. The breakfasts are completely overpriced. We ended up spending $20 on an omelette and coffee with a tip. The best part about our experience was the kind young man who was efficient and kept our coffees filled. We will not be returning.

I wish there were more stars! A GREAT place to get breakfast 😋. Our server was AWESOME and friendly. The area was clean and well kept. And the prices were VERY reasonable. I'll be going back for sure!

One of the best diners around! The service here is always above and beyond! The food is excellent, the prices are very good, and the selection of menu items is plenty. During my most recent visit, the waitresses were so friendly and helpful that I can't wait to come back again! If ever in the area, be sure to stop in!

I go here often. Good food. If I dine inside then I leave a generous tip. However, if I am picking up lunch through the drive-up window and being asked for a tip. This is not appropriate. I’ll NEVER return to this diner.. I Tip all the time but tipping culture is getting insane… to ask for a tip for drive up. No not right. Done…

ALL the employees are very friendly!!👍👍👍 The food is great and the service is quick!! The restaurant is clean and inviting. The prices ARE reasonable. The desserts they have there look SO amazing and yummy I wanted to pick one up after we had breakfast!! I HIGHLY recommend if you're in the Malaga, NJ area, you definitely should stop at the Pegasus Diner/Restaurant!! To ALL the employees, keep up the GREAT WORK!!👍👍👍

We had my daughters college graduation luncheon there and I couldn’t be happier. The staff, food and atmosphere was top notch. Cocktails made perfect. I couldn’t have asked for any more. Thank you so much for a great party.

This review is late, We dined here on 10/28/23 for a dinner. And it was my first visit. I was going to get the recommended big Greek salad. But, the fragrance of scampi, once I walked in, changed my mind. I was not disappointed 😋

I was there for a seminar. The room we were in was nice, spacious, NOONE was sitting in another's space (like others I've been to). The food tho was not 'special'. The "roast beef w gravy & mashed potatoes"- roast beef was tender, plentiful but very bland. The gravy was 'canned" and the potatoes, several folks felt they tasted like instant. I had the shrimp Caesar salad. Had a few bits of "old very brown & wilted lettuce to remove, & another at our table had HAIR in hers and it was nowhere near a color match to her own hair. I had to ask for my water & raspberry tea several times before even water came out. Yes, they had a lot of folks to serve, and for the most part, kept all the orders correct. So it was 'just ok". That being said, they get A LOT of business....we don't know why, but they are fairly busy all the time. The chicken dish at our table was 'eh' - he picked it apart because the breading was very soggy.

It’s my first time here at Pegasus and WOW 🤩 I’m very impressed the food was amazing!!! The service was very very good. The hospitality is like no other. The food was exactly what you ordered. The portions are super big. Come with an appetite. You will need it. The dessert was out of this world. You need to try their Jamaican chocolate moose cheesecake or maybe I have the name wrong but I know the server said Jamaican. And the cherry pie was good and the milkshake was awesome and very big too. The bathrooms are very clean and the dinning area very clean too. I will go back there again. If you never have gone I will recommend that you go and give it a try you will not regret it. I had a chicken lemon soup and it was good also. Everything that we eat there was awesome. The food was very tasty. They have a big selection of desserts. You want to eat everything that is there if you have a sweet tooth like I do. 😂 Thank you Pegasus for your wonderful service and food. I will come back with my family again.

We wanted to go somewhere different. It reminds me of an upscale diner. We only had breakfast. I had chipped beef on biscuits.

A classic Jersey diner. Good food, friendly service, fair prices. The menu is extensive. We have eaten there many times and have never been disappointed. Give them a try!

Loved the food! Had a knowledgeable, friendly & professional waitress named Emily. Keep up the good work. One Request: Please can you eliminate using red peppers in so many dishes you serve Please! I will be a return customer!

Lunch was great! Our waitress was good, definitely recommend

Very small inside compared to most NJ diners. Food was okay albeit on the expensive side for what you get. Service looked like it was much better for what seemed to be "regular customers". Our experience wasn't an unpleasant one but rather an average one. Based on prices I would say that breakfast is very profitable for diner/restaurants.

More than a decade ago, I relocated from southern New Jersey to the free state of Florida. Two (2) weeks ago, my father and his companion took me there for a late lunch prior to taking me to the airport for my return flight to the free state of Florida. I had a cup of soup, which I enjoyed; and they seemed to enjoy their respective meals.

White seafood pizza was good, but the calamari? 8 rings in the whole order? They closed a half hour early so I couldn't even get a new order. It was soggy anyway.

Excellent diner and friendly staff. Moderate prices. Awesome food.

A very good dinner that has been in the area for a long time. I always enjoy getting breakfast anytime of the day. The waffle was good. My husband had the tuna club with fries. Wait staff are always attentive but not intrusive. Guaranteed a decent meal at a reasonable price by today's standards.

First time at this restaurant. The food and service were outstanding! I enjoyed the pasta dish, which was loaded with scallops and shrimp! My wife lived her salad. We will definitely eat here again!

Food is almost always awesome. My chicken Alfredo was a little on the oily side and wasn't really a lot of sauce to begin with. It tasted fine just not the best I've ever had. Otherwise still recommend this diner. Very popular and always busy, definitely worth eating there if you lile diners.

Excellent food and service. BEST FRIES! Lovely atmosphere and art all around. I took off a star due to the price of childrens meal vs the amount of food. My kids were still hungry after eating a $9 kids meal (3 small pancakes and probably 1 scrambled egg).

The food & service was very good. One odd thing happened. Tried to order a dinner from the special menu. Waitress came back & said we had the wrong menu, but they could make it, but it would be more $. Don't know why they couldn't just give it to us if they "could make it"?