Delicious surprise on our road trip. Meatballs appetizer was amazing and the pizza was delicious. I literally moaned during dinner.

Eva, our server was absolutely amazing! She warmly greeted us as we entered Tony's Pizza, seated us right away, and gave us our menus and drinks right away. She had a gorgeous smile on her face the entire time and checked in on us on a regular basis. The food was great and it was nice and hot. I would go back just to even support Eva. She is that awesome of a server. There is not any amount of a tip that will do her justice. Thank you so very much for your wonderful service. May you be truly blessed. A friend and I were back at Tony's recently, and Kylie was our server. Kylie did an absolutely incredible job and checked in on us regularly and was so sweet and caring. There is not any amount of a tip that will do her justice either. Thank you, Kylie, for your service. May you be truly blessed, Kylie.

My family and myself had dinner on Friday night. It was busy, but not too busy. The only reason I didn't give a perfect score is because I feel like the waitress could have been a little more attentive, but overall she did good and still got a nice tip. We ordered several different things from the menu and they were all outstanding. Especially the cheese sticks! Best pizza in town. The stuffed pizza is worth the wait if you have the time.

Was ok... a bit dissappointed. Expected more from friends descriptions... ate in...good sourdough crust... toppings including cheese very uneven and looked hastily prepared.... flavor was surprisingly plain and was undercooked. Did not meet the price expectation for higher end pizza.

This is the real hometown Italian deal. One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Perfect amount of cheese, homemade flavorful sausage, chewy thin crust with perfect edge char. Sauce is tomato and not overwhelmed with seasoning. Ravioli and meatballs were outstanding. I’m new to Waupun but plant to be a regular here. And the staff, wow, so friendly. Great family. Thank you Tony and crew.

Been coming here for years! Their pizza is some of the best I've ever had. My wife loves their spaghetti dinner is. And to be honest I couldn't tell you a single thing about the rest of their menu, the pizza is so good I've had zero reason to try anything else!

Pizza was not good, everything fell off it and nothing on the pizza had any taste. Took 45 minutes (and place wasn't busy) to get our food and it wasn't made how we asked with spaghetti sauce instead of pizza sauce. Left whole pizza behind and they didn't discount us. My husband works construction and will eat just about anything but complained about the pizza. Husband says he has to stop and eat on the way home.

The best pizza around. Always fresh, tasty and the cheese! Great service, very silcian style. The best

This place is fantastic...I've dined in and have had take out and the quality is always good. The people who work here are amazing and do a great job making it all happen! The pizza is always hot and tastes excellent. BBQ chicken pizza is phenomenal and so is the Hawaiian....the Meatball subs are also very good and my go to sandwich if I want something quick satisfying...but their pizzas are the star here and worth the wait. Tonys Pizza is truly a gem in Waupun!

My gf brought me here. She grew up eating Tony's and just loves it and she wasn't wrong I had the Tony's special (pizza) and it was excellent.... Definitely recommend....

Pictured is the stuffed pizza. Great pizza, awesome environment. Highly recommend

Me and my boyfriend just came out from there we got sat but nobody came to serve us and we even had the staff looking at us like hello you see us but nobody wanted our business I guess thats what you expect when the staff are young I could understand if they were busy but they weren't will not be returning why would we