Most reviewed Restaurants in Pembroke, Bermuda to visit (Updated February, 2024)

Most reviewed Restaurants in Pembroke

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Pembroke through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 16 places from Restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

Lobster Pot & Boat House Bar

Restaurant

👍👍 Fantastic spot for seafood. Great service and quality of food are fantastic! They also accommodated my dairy allergy by substituting their cream sauce for a tomato based one.

$$ $$

4.20 (327 reviews)

Art Mel's Spicy Dicy

Restaurant

👍👍 Had to get the world famous fish sandwich!! Did not disappoint! Get it traditional, on raisin bread, slaw and hot sauce on the side! One sandwich fed my my girlfriend and I! It’s huge!! Worth the trip!

$ $$$

4.70 (240 reviews)

Harry's at the Waterfront

Restaurant

👍👍 Everything is 5-star at Harry’s. Food, cocktails, service. The bartender, in particular, is awesome - very knowledgable and friendly. The most recent time we stopped by for a mezcal sour and a whiskey sour. The whiskey sour is the best I’ve had in Bermuda. Couple months back, I enjoyed a boozy lunch...

$$$$

4.30 (215 reviews)

Harbourfront Restaurant

Sushi restaurant

👍 Lovely location and delicious mix of sushi and Italian options

$$$ $

4.50 (189 reviews)

1609 BAR AND RESTAURANT

Restaurant

👍👍 Gorgeous to watch the sun set right over the harbour. Not very crowded as it’s off season, but still amazing food and prices honestly comparable to a similar quality restaurant in the states. They even added a special anniversary dessert on the house!

4.50 (178 reviews)

Mad Hatters

Restaurant

👍👍 Centrally located, Mad Hatters offers a selection of wonderfully delicious food. The service is great, and free parking is available. Indoor and outdoor (covered) seating is available.

$$$ $

4.70 (164 reviews)

Huckleberry Restaurant

Restaurant

👍👍 Huckleberry is a 5 star Bermuda brunch experience. Amazing food, drinks and service. The seating area outside is lovely, and if you don't get an outside table the atmosphere inside the restaurant is equally nice.

4.60 (129 reviews)

Crown & Anchor

Restaurant

👍 We had breakfast here twice on our trip to Bermuda, ordering off the menu rather than the buffet. The service was prompt, friendly and professional both times. We sat outside on one of the occasion and inside the netted patio the other. Both times the food was delicious. The bacon was amount the bes...

4.20 (57 reviews)

Ascots Restaurant

Restaurant

👍👍 One of the best places in Bermuda! We had a wonderful dinner and the service was just perfect. High recommend!

4.70 (56 reviews)

Yardie Kitchen

Restaurant

👍👍 These ackee & saltfish stuffed dumplings were sooo tasty & fresh. The inside was soft & well seasoned while the outside was crispy and chewy. Top 10 recommend this local eatery!

4.10 (51 reviews)

Intrepid Bermuda

Restaurant

👍👍 We had a wonderful dinner at intrepid with some friends. The service was topnotch, the food was amazing!!!(definitely the best food we had on the island). I would definitely go back and highly recommend it. I'm not sure how difficult it is to get reservations as we went with a local who is regular,...

4.90 (51 reviews)

Grannie's

Restaurant

👍👍 We were lucky enough to be brought here by a lovely Bermudian local that saw us lost on the path towards Art Mel's (closed Mondays, which we also didn't know). We wouldn't have found Grannie's without her, and would have missed out on the best fish sandwich we've ever had. Grannie's is family run, c...

4.60 (48 reviews)

FIRE & SLICE Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Excellent, always delicious, huge pizzas, decent prices, worth the money.

4.50 (38 reviews)

Byrdies

Restaurant

👍👍 One of the best spots in Bermuda for fish cakes, fries and the typical greasy spoon type fare BUT it is THE absolute best when it comes to their beef and chicken pies. They are hands down, the best pie makers on the island. People top them with mayo, ketchup, relish mainly, but it really needs no ad...

4.30 (38 reviews)