Top rated Italian grocery stores in Sheffield, United Kingdom to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Italian grocery stores in Sheffield

Experience the best that Sheffield has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 23 places from Italian grocery store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Sheffield

La Piola Italian - Leeds

Cafe

👍👍 Don't be deceived by the small discreet nature of this lovely little restaurant. The food is excellent and the staff are lovely and charming. I had a delicious mushroom soup to start with some amazing Cerignola olives, followed by a delicious Arabiata with Nduja. Really enjoyable and very tasty....

5.00 (220 reviews) (~46.86 km from centre)

Dough & Dolci

Caterer

👍👍 We had a lovely mid-morning treat, a true taste of Italy. The doughnuts we had were fresh, fluffy, and had a full scrumptious filling. The Iced Latte and Americano were tasty, full of flavour, and didn't taste watered-down. Highly recommend a visit!

5.00 (47 reviews) (~17.68 km from centre)

Miele Delicatessen

Deli

👍 Proper coffee 👍 Nice pleasant staff, a nice place to visit for good food and drinks.

4.90 (157 reviews) (~9.38 km from centre)

Macrigi Marketplace Store

Italian grocery store

👍👍 Beautiful authentic Italian pizzas and they even made a vegan one for my mum. All such friendly staff too! We are very lucky to have a shop like this in Tunstall and I hope people support them.

4.90 (45 reviews) (~60.85 km from centre)

La Cucina

Fish and chips takeaway

👍👍 Hands down best chips in the world with the addition of the best pizza ever!! This place is just fantastic and since I was younger I've kept coming back and will continue to, thank you for existing and I 100% recommend coming here.

4.70 (217 reviews) (~99.1 km from centre)

Caffé Valeria Wheldrake

Coffee shop

👍👍 Called in at Caffé Valeria while out on a motorbike ride with my Italian friend GP. Great selection of cakes and pastries, also some savoury options like panini, piadina but this time we didn't try these. We will come back to sample some soon. I must say that the flat white coffee's were excellent....

4.70 (157 reviews) (~65.84 km from centre)

Teresa Lambarelli's

Italian restaurant

👍 Only open on a Saturday evening at the moment but well worth a visit. Unusual pasta sauces - buffalo ragu(!?) - along with a range of starters and desserts, all beautifully presented, make for an enjoyable evening.

4.70 (101 reviews) (~16.25 km from centre)

Paradiso Dolce Salato

Coffee shop

👍👍 I really liked my hot chocolate. The best hot chocolate in York, hands down. It felt like a warm hug. Tiramisu was delicious dessert. Good servings. Certainly one of the most affordable. This location was quite. It's was a wonderful and cosy cafe with a lot of character. Service was quick. Excellent...

4.70 (53 reviews) (~69.17 km from centre)

Pronto Pizzeria, Colne

Pizza delivery

👍👍 I have just seen a Facebook post about a man that works here called Michael and want to say well done on being such a beautiful soul. Random acts of kindness will always make the world a better place and that's what you did. 💗💗

4.60 (109 reviews) (~70.22 km from centre)

Italian Cucina

Bar & grill

👍👍 We have been here 4 time's now and tried different dishes every time. My favourite dishes are the samosa chaat for starter then the butter chicken, mushroom rice and chilli and onion naan which is nothing shy as some of the best Indian food I've had. It is a hidden gem tucked away not far from where...

4.60 (62 reviews) (~55.13 km from centre)

The Pasta Factory

Italian restaurant

The key component of this restaurant is the pasta used in a menu of traditional Italian dishes.

$$ $$

4.50 (1.1K reviews) (~52.14 km from centre)

Fireaway Pizza

Pizza takeaway

👍👍 Absolutely delicious pizza. 10/10. Great dips. Great desserts. Can't recommend enough. Love this place. Order regularly

$ $$$

4.50 (209 reviews) (~86.15 km from centre)

San Giorgio Restaurant

Italian restaurant

😠 I’ve eaten in a few Italian restaurants, both here in the UK & along the Amalfi Coast in Italy. The food here was poor & over-priced & the young girl who served us forgot to bring us the starter we had ordered to share. This was a special occasion fir my wife’s birthday & left me disappointed. The s...

$$ $$

4.50 (207 reviews) (~93.2 km from centre)

Fireaway Pizza Rochdale

Pizza takeaway

👍👍 FireAway, Rochdale: Finally got to try out this place, it's definitely the Subway of pizzas. I can't get over how quickly the pizzas are made. It took less than 180 seconds in a stone baked oven & it was made to perfection. I would even say it’s one of the best pizzas I have ever tried with an authe...

$ $$$

4.40 (119 reviews) (~49.12 km from centre)

Benitos

Italian restaurant

👍👍 The lady that took the order was lovely, the food arrived before time and was absolutely the best pizza I have had I don't normally eat the crust of the pizza but I ate every bit and well worth the money i will be ordering from here again, the delivery was fantastic and the delivery man lovely and p...

$ $$$

4.30 (219 reviews) (~5.69 km from centre)

Franco's

Takeout restaurant

👍👍 The best pizza I have ever had! Much better even then in proper Italy! Love to go there. The place is very cosy. Friendly professional staff. Very romantic place with pure Italian decoration. Great proces for high quality food served. The one thing I am missing there is an Italian music in backgrou...

4.30 (131 reviews) (~89.41 km from centre)

Pizza House Company

Pizza delivery

👍👍 Been using Pizza House Company for long time and the pizza and food we get from here is top notch! They are quick too. Highly recommended

4.20 (176 reviews) (~56.93 km from centre)

Pizza Base

Pizza takeaway

🫤 Oh dear, what cheese have you changed to it is vile. Pizzas look as good as ever service brilliant but why change a winning recipe for a cheese that ends up as glupe in your mouth with no taste. Such a shame guys please go back to before as you will lose lots of custom I fear.

4.00 (72 reviews) (~64.66 km from centre)

Paradise takeaway

Indian takeaway

😠 This place is our usual go to for a beautiful takeaway but lastnight we ordered a margarita pizza from here and were so disappointed. There were absolutely no tomato puree in sight it was basically warm bread with gooey cheese on top that made me and my partner both feel ill. Such a waste of money a...

3.90 (79 reviews) (~38.09 km from centre)

Franko's Pizza

Takeout restaurant

😠 Terrible service. Waited over an hour for food to be told ‘he stood outside of X address for 10 minutes’ the address wasn’t even correct and completely different to the address on the just eat order. Then to be told I won’t be getting a refund as the food had already been made. Stay clear from this...

3.80 (77 reviews) (~38.85 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian grocery stores in Sheffield, United Kingdom