Top rated Mexican restaurants in Arcata

Experience the best that Arcata has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 11 places from Mexican restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Alma's Mexican Food image
1
Alma's Mexican Food
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Alma has it DOWN! In town for work and stumbled across the food truck. If your traveling through or close. Take the turn and try it out! Limited hours. I wish they did breakfast burritos early morning for all the work crews!!!
$ $$$
4.90 (100 reviews)
Valley Azteca Restaurant image
2
Valley Azteca Restaurant
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 one of the best in humboldt. my favorites from here are a torta, a wet burrito, or a chile relleno with any of their aguas frescas. service, drinks, food, chips, and salsa are great, to say the least! the menu is so big, there’s definitely something for everyone. plenty of vegetarian and vegan optio...
$$ $$
4.60 (333 reviews)
El Chipotle Mexican & American Food image
3
El Chipotle Mexican & American Food
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 After a long drive from the San Jose Area, we stumbled upon this gem for some late night eats. There is good outdoor/patio seating with heat lamps. The menu is diverse and the prices are reasonable especially given the portion sizes. The staff was great and very accommodating as we sat near closing...
4.50 (403 reviews)
Taqueria La Barca image
4
Taqueria La Barca
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 I'm so glad they're back!!! In my humble opinion the best Mexican food in Humboldt. Authenticity, flavor, and service are excellent. Better than before the lockdown. If I could give them six stars I would.
$ $$$
4.50 (258 reviews)
Tacos La Bonita image
5
Tacos La Bonita
Mexican restaurant
😠 Not consistent. The al pastor burrito had about a tablespoon of meat. I love this place but can't afford to continuously get bunk burritos. Burritos are double digits $$. In the market for a new favorite taco truck.
4.50 (141 reviews)
Hey Juan Burritos image
6
Hey Juan Burritos
Mexican restaurant
😠 I don’t know if someone recently bought out Hey Juan or what, but they have gone seriously downhill. I haven’t eaten there until tonight in about a month-2 months and was incredibly disappointed to see that not only had the menu changed, but the quality of food had as well. I moved here from the LA...
$ $$$
4.40 (325 reviews)
Esteban image
7
Esteban
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Excellent meal, wonderful fish tacos, fast service, great customer service. Thank you, we loved the hot sauce crispy fish tacos. Best rice and beans. Burritos looked great.
4.40 (94 reviews)
Rita's Margaritas & Mexican Grill image
8
Rita's Margaritas & Mexican Grill
Mexican restaurant
Relaxed local chain serving Mexican classics, plus tequila choices & margaritas in most locations.
$$ $$
4.30 (549 reviews)
Fiesta Grill & Cantina image
9
Fiesta Grill & Cantina
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Holy smokes is this place good! I had the carnitas lunch plate and it was filled! My new fav for this side of humboldt county. Sorry no pics. I ate it all 😁 Update: new owners, new menu, same cooks. Fingers crossed 🤞 still very good! Update #2: took pictures before eating it all this time 🤤 Up...
$$ $$
4.30 (524 reviews)
Carmela's Mexican Restaurant image
10
Carmela's Mexican Restaurant
Mexican restaurant
😠 This place is the worst place ever. There was a dead rat underneath one of the dining tables. I didn’t feel comfortable eating there and I asked if I could get a refund because of that, they said they can’t do that since I got my food already and that it wasn’t their problem. I wouldn’t eat here if...
$$ $$
4.10 (480 reviews)
Raliberto’s Taco Shop image
11
Raliberto’s Taco Shop
Mexican restaurant
😠 Ordered a regular shredded chicken burrito. It was insanely salty and the only thing in it was chicken. It is inedibly salty, super gross. Definitely would not come back here. $21 for 2 burritos that only have one ingredient? Bad to the point that I was confused about how anyone could serve food wit...
$ $$$
3.60 (117 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )