Top rated Thrift stores in Bay Village

Experience the best that Bay Village has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 39 places from Thrift store category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Antiques & Uniques image
1
Antiques & Uniques
Antique store
5.00 (3.5K reviews) (~41.09 km from centre)
Good Friends Thrift image
2
Good Friends Thrift
Thrift store
👍👍 I have not yet been there yet. Though the fact that they help animals out already deserves a 1,000 star review. Animals, especially dogs 🐕 have literally become our family members, after having them around you can't imagine how other dogs are treated poorly. It is one of these places that gives you...
4.90 (56 reviews) (~16.86 km from centre)
Ratsy's Store image
3
Ratsy's Store
Gift shop
👍👍 This is a must stop in Oberlin for the weird, unusual and down right awesome off the wall items. Make the time to explore this shop, you won't be disappointed and I'm sure after you leave you may be disturbed! A++++ Aka : Crabman.
4.90 (39 reviews) (~32.82 km from centre)
Uptown Cheapskate Mayfield Heights image
4
Uptown Cheapskate Mayfield Heights
Thrift store
Retailer known for buying & selling secondhand designer apparel & accessories for young adults.
4.80 (307 reviews) (~39.39 km from centre)
Wheel'n & Deal'n Thrift Store image
5
Wheel'n & Deal'n Thrift Store
Thrift store
👍👍 I understand people wanna give this place a bad review based on the cleanliness of the place but I like the fact that there are items everywhere. It makes the thrifting experience that much more rich. I got a chance to chat up with Jim, who was super helpful and even let me look upstairs as I was l...
4.80 (32 reviews) (~19.66 km from centre)
The Salvage Yard Resale Shoppe image
6
The Salvage Yard Resale Shoppe
Thrift store
4.70 (127 reviews) (~6.59 km from centre)
Best Resale & Exchange image
7
Best Resale & Exchange
Pawn shop
👍👍 this is the best pawn shop in Ohio. The owners are so friendly. The store is very clean. thank you for helping me sell my treasures.
4.70 (111 reviews) (~49.26 km from centre)
Common Threads - Brook Park image
8
Common Threads - Brook Park
Thrift store
👍👍 I went here for the first time this week and found a ton of unique glasswares/home decor. I couldn’t believe how much pretty stuff they had, I even thought this was a curated consignment store at first, but it’s all donation based like a traditional thrift store. And I barely had time to look at the...
4.70 (58 reviews) (~13.23 km from centre)
Common Threads - Fairview Park image
9
Common Threads - Fairview Park
Thrift store
👍👍 Went there today for the first time. I’ve driven by it for years and always thought it was a really expense place. I was so wrong , this will become a frequent stop for me. I bought home decor, mugs, candy molds and sticks. A wall candle holder. My daughter bought an entire outfit and a purse , wall...
4.60 (246 reviews) (~6.75 km from centre)
Mercy Health - Thrift Store image
10
Mercy Health - Thrift Store
Thrift store
👍👍 Unexpected place for me to notice a thrift store but upon entering the store, they had an easy to notice specials/deals of the day. The store is not that big but very cute and clean. They had more clothes than home decor. Did not notice any type of furniture section especially if you're out on the...
4.60 (61 reviews) (~19.82 km from centre)
Life's Treasures Hospice Thrift Store image
11
Life's Treasures Hospice Thrift Store
Thrift store
👍👍 Life’s Treasures is a fantastic store!!! There’s so much to look at!!! Well organized!!! It has a wonderful Christmas area full of great treasures! 🎄🤶🏼🎁❤️So beautiful! Impressive!
4.50 (90 reviews) (~39.17 km from centre)
River Trading Co. image
12
River Trading Co.
Consignment shop
👍👍 I have been consigning with River Trading for years and recently had a really great experience there. I took in a designer purse, and thought I had gone through everything before consigning and then I received a phone call from Kelly at River Trading. She told me I had left $30 cash in the purse....
4.40 (43 reviews) (~7.02 km from centre)
Jamie's Flea Market image
13
Jamie's Flea Market
Flea market
😠 This is the most unfriendly run flea market. Each time i have sold here as a vender I’m met with attitude and unfriendlyness. I had purchases 2 spots To sell from and it was a super slow day not many venders there. The guy collecting money actually made sure you were not over any lines even though t...
4.30 (772 reviews) (~28.43 km from centre)
Good Neighbor Thrift Shop image
14
Good Neighbor Thrift Shop
Thrift store
👍👍 It’s like a little boutique you almost don’t even know the stuff is reused. And a good atmosphere lovely people cute quaint and a lot of selection. You can either come in and sit and have a cup of coffee
4.30 (75 reviews) (~6.17 km from centre)
Thrifty On The Vine image
15
Thrifty On The Vine
Thrift store
😐 This place is 5 stars as long as Dottie isn't there. It's a great store with great staff and great values. The only exception is Dottie. She is rude, argumentative and I have seen her verbally attack several other customers. She is confrontational and has scared away many customers. Personally I try...
4.30 (40 reviews) (~42.66 km from centre)
Volunteers of America Thrift Store – North Olmsted image
16
Volunteers of America Thrift Store – North Olmsted
Thrift store
😐 This store used to be my favorite. The people are usually very nice and helpful. The store is clean an organized. But I've noticed their prices on "free stuff donated" have gone awry. I was there yesterday and found an old plastic tote (with lid) priced $10.10. It was dirty. There seems to be a vari...
4.20 (453 reviews) (~7.66 km from centre)
The Salvation Army Thrift Store Elyria, OH image
17
The Salvation Army Thrift Store Elyria, OH
Thrift store
👍 I shop here often and they have great prices on household, vintage, and other knickknacks but the clothing is priced so high. $5.99 for a very obviously used T-shirt is crazy. This play is way better and cheaper than ANY goodwill I’ve ever been to but wish the clothes weren't priced so high. Small s...
4.20 (178 reviews) (~18.86 km from centre)
Second Chances Consignment Thrift Shop image
18
Second Chances Consignment Thrift Shop
Thrift store
😠 While this store is very nice and the owner was pleasant, I was very disappointed in the way business was handled. The 2 things I asked about were not priced and she went and looked them up to see what they were selling for to give me a price. I don't know if thats how normal consignment shops work,...
4.20 (48 reviews) (~13.4 km from centre)
The Red Geranium image
19
The Red Geranium
Consignment shop
😠 I would love to go through the store but they are never open. We’ve made three trips and each time they’ve been closed. They also never answer the phone.
4.20 (48 reviews) (~16.4 km from centre)
Goodwill image
20
Goodwill
Second hand store
Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.
4.10 (150 reviews) (~15.84 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Bay Village

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )